Italian Restaurants in New Castle


Mama Nita's: Two $10 Vouchers or Pizza Meal for Two or Four at Mama Nita's Pizza (Up to 45% Off)

Two $10 Vouchers or Pizza Meal for Two or Four at Mama Nita's Pizza (Up to 45% Off)

Mama Nita's

New Palestine

Pie prodigies hand-toss dough for thin-crust pizzas and top each creation with choice of more than one dozen toppings

$10 $6

View Deal

Hungry Howie's: $18 for Three Groupons, Each Good for $10 Worth of Pizza at Hungry Howie's ($30 Value). Four Locations Available.

$18 for Three Groupons, Each Good for $10 Worth of Pizza at Hungry Howie's ($30 Value). Four Locations Available.

Hungry Howie's

Multiple Locations

Diners build pizzas from the dough up with customizable arrangement of crusts, sauces, cheese, and toppings

$10 $6

View Deal

Mardi Gras Pizzeria: Pizzeria Food for Two or Four or $14 for $20 Worth of Delivery or Takeout at Mardi Gras Pizzeria

Pizzeria Food for Two or Four or $14 for $20 Worth of Delivery or Takeout at Mardi Gras Pizzeria

Mardi Gras Pizzeria

Lapel

Try the No. 1 selling specialty pizza, the chicken ranch pie or build your own creation; burgers, calzones, wings, and sandwiches, too

$25 $15

View Deal

Greek's Pizzeria of Noblesville: Three Groupons, Each Good for $10 Worth of Pizza, or Football Package at Greek's Pizzeria (Up to 50% Off)

Three Groupons, Each Good for $10 Worth of Pizza, or Football Package at Greek's Pizzeria (Up to 50% Off)

Greek's Pizzeria of Noblesville

Greek's Pizzeria

Pizzas with housemade dough and a signature italian sauce, sandwiches, and pastas; football package with large pizza and breadsticks

$10 $5

View Deal

Cagney's Pizza King : Pizza at Cagney's Pizza King (Up to 40% Off). Two Options Available.

Pizza at Cagney's Pizza King (Up to 40% Off). Two Options Available.

Cagney's Pizza King

Shelbyville

Enjoy a wide variety of menu items including hot wings, tacos, and hot sandwiches, or try specialty pies like the BLT Pizza or Taco Pizza

$10 $6

View Deal

Greek's Pizzeria: $18 for Three Groupons, Each Good for $10 Worth of Pizza at Greek's Pizzeria ($30 Value)

$18 for Three Groupons, Each Good for $10 Worth of Pizza at Greek's Pizzeria ($30 Value)

Greek's Pizzeria

Multiple Locations

Pizzas with housemade dough and a signature italian sauce, sandwiches, and pastas; football package with large pizza and breadsticks

$10 $6

View Deal

Iozzo’s Garden of Italy: $69 for a Dinner for 2 at Iozzo’s Garden of Italy (Up to $115 Total Value). Groupon Reservation Required.

$69 for a Dinner for 2 at Iozzo’s Garden of Italy (Up to $115 Total Value). Groupon Reservation Required.

Iozzo’s Garden of Italy

Downtown Indianapolis

Award-winning Italian eatery modernizes family recipes to craft plates of goat-cheese scallops, lasagna bolognese, and lamb chops

$115 $69

View Deal

Riteway Pizza: $18 for Three Groupons, Each Good for $10 Worth of Carryout or Delivery from Riteway Pizza ($30 Value)

$18 for Three Groupons, Each Good for $10 Worth of Carryout or Delivery from Riteway Pizza ($30 Value)

Riteway Pizza

Indianapolis

Specialty pizzas, wings, sandwiches, and ribs are served until the wee hours of the morning; citywide delivery

$10 $6

View Deal

Zionsville Pizzeria: Pizza and Breadsticks for Dine-in or Takeout at Zionsville Pizzeria (Up to 44% Off)

Pizza and Breadsticks for Dine-in or Takeout at Zionsville Pizzeria (Up to 44% Off)

Zionsville Pizzeria

Zionsville

Locally owned pizzeria in downtown Zionsville where patrons enjoy slices of housemade, breadsticks & meatballs; gluten-free crust available

$26.75 $15

View Deal

So Italian: Pizza and Drinks for Two or Four, or Carry-Out at So Italian (Up to 44% Off)

Pizza and Drinks for Two or Four, or Carry-Out at So Italian (Up to 44% Off)

So Italian

Brownsburg

Pizza selections abound with build-your-own pies, vegetarian specialties, and chicken alfredo pizza and Dr. David’s barbecue stuffed pizza

$25.99 $17

View Deal

Fairfield Pizza & Pasta Company: $11 for $20 Worth of Italian Food at Fairfield Pizza & Pasta Company

$11 for $20 Worth of Italian Food at Fairfield Pizza & Pasta Company

Fairfield Pizza & Pasta Company

Fairfield

Baked ziti and ravioli accompany signature pizzas such as the Deluxe, with pepperoni, bacon, sausage, and mushrooms

$20 $11

View Deal

Stefano's Italian Cafe: Italian Food During Lunch or Dinner or for Take-Out at Stefano's Italian Cafe (Up to 50% Off)

Italian Food During Lunch or Dinner or for Take-Out at Stefano's Italian Cafe (Up to 50% Off)

Stefano's Italian Cafe

Middletown

Homemade sauces and wood-fired pizzas shine on a menu of classic Italian dishes

$20 $11

View Deal

Captain 9's: $12 for $20 Worth of Pizzas, Sandwiches, and Pasta at Captain 9’s

$12 for $20 Worth of Pizzas, Sandwiches, and Pasta at Captain 9’s

Captain 9's

Germantown

Pizza, pasta, Hershey’s ice cream, and subs in a diner decorated with authentic firefighter suits

$20 $12

View Deal

Angilo's Pizza: $19.99 for Italian Feast Family Meal for Four at Angilo's Pizza ($34.98 Value)

$19.99 for Italian Feast Family Meal for Four at Angilo's Pizza ($34.98 Value)

Angilo's Pizza

Harrison

Groups of four can enjoy a feast that includes a Sicilian deep-dish pizza, steak hoagies, garlic bread with cheese, and Pepsi drinks

$34.98 $19.99

View Deal

PJ's Paesan's Pizza: Pizzas, Breadsticks, and Soft Drinks at PJ's Paesan's Pizza (Up to 49% Off). Three Options Available.

Pizzas, Breadsticks, and Soft Drinks at PJ's Paesan's Pizza (Up to 49% Off). Three Options Available.

PJ's Paesan's Pizza

Huntington

16-inch pizzas are supplemented by crisp breadsticks and sub stuffed with ham, salami, or meatballs

$19.95 $11

View Deal

Mama Mimi's Take 'N Bake Pizza: $11 for $20 Worth of Gourmet Pizza from Mama Mimi's Take 'N Bake Pizza

$11 for $20 Worth of Gourmet Pizza from Mama Mimi's Take 'N Bake Pizza

Mama Mimi's Take 'N Bake Pizza

Multiple Locations

Gourmet pizzas, lasagnas, pastas and salads made fresh in house daily that you can heat up and enjoy in the comfort of your home

$20 $11

View Deal

Pizza Tower: Pizza and Italian Food for Two or Four at Pizza Tower (Up to 48% Off)

Pizza and Italian Food for Two or Four at Pizza Tower (Up to 48% Off)

Pizza Tower

Cincinnati

Chefs make pizzas from scratch with more than 30 toppings, including fresh mozzarella cheese

$20 $11

View Deal

Tusculum Grille: $12 for $20 Worth of Pizza and Sandwiches at Tusculum Grille

$12 for $20 Worth of Pizza and Sandwiches at Tusculum Grille

Tusculum Grille

East End

Italian-style thin-crust specialty pizzas such as buffalo chicken, veggie, and vegan veggie

$20 $12

View Deal

Bloc Head Pizza: $11 for Two Groupons, Each Good for $10 Worth of Pizza and Hoagies at Bloc Head Pizza ($20 Total Value)

$11 for Two Groupons, Each Good for $10 Worth of Pizza and Hoagies at Bloc Head Pizza ($20 Total Value)

Bloc Head Pizza

Cincinnati

All proceeds from the restaurant’s pizza and hoagies go toward afterschool and community programs; run by Bloc Ministries

$10 $5.50

View Deal

Sorrento's Restaurant & Lounge: $11 for $20 Worth of Italian Cuisine at Sorrento's Restaurant & Lounge (45% Off)

$11 for $20 Worth of Italian Cuisine at Sorrento's Restaurant & Lounge (45% Off)

Sorrento's Restaurant & Lounge

Reading

In a historical building that dates back the 1800s, cooks whip up classic Italian pastas alongside charbroiled steaks, seafood, and hoagies

$20 $11

View Deal

The Red Star Pizza Company: $12for Two Groupons, Each Good for $10 Worth of Food at The Red Star Pizza Company ($20 Total Value)

$12for Two Groupons, Each Good for $10 Worth of Food at The Red Star Pizza Company ($20 Total Value)

The Red Star Pizza Company

Seymour

Hand-tossed specialty pizzas highlight a menu of hot sandwiches, salads, appetizers, and more

$10 $6

View Deal

Ferrari's Little Italy and Bakery: Italian Cuisine at Lunch for Two at Ferrari’s Little Italy and Bakery (Up to 53% Off). Two Options Available.

Italian Cuisine at Lunch for Two at Ferrari’s Little Italy and Bakery (Up to 53% Off). Two Options Available.

Ferrari's Little Italy and Bakery

Madeira

Family-recipe Italian food, gelato, fresh-baked focaccia bread, and homemade pizzas served amid rustic exposed-brick walls and outdoor patio

$20 $11

View Deal

Giuseppe’s Neighborhood Pizzeria: $11 for $20 Worth of New York-Style Pizza and Hoagies at Giuseppe's Neighborhood Pizzeria

$11 for $20 Worth of New York-Style Pizza and Hoagies at Giuseppe's Neighborhood Pizzeria

Giuseppe’s Neighborhood Pizzeria

Covington

Made-from-scratch dough, fresh bread, and delicious toppings power New York-style pizzas and overstuffed hoagies

$20 $11

View Deal

Mio's Pizzeria: $11 for $20 Worth of Pizza, Subs, and Drinks for Dine-In Service at Mio’s Pizzeria

$11 for $20 Worth of Pizza, Subs, and Drinks for Dine-In Service at Mio’s Pizzeria

Mio's Pizzeria

Miami Township

Original-crust pizza topped with wholesome cheese, tangy tomato sauce, and fresh ingredients

$20 $11

View Deal

Domino's Pizza: Pan Pizza, Parmesan Bread Bites, and Coca-Cola Soda at Domino's Pizza (Up to 47% Off)

Pan Pizza, Parmesan Bread Bites, and Coca-Cola Soda at Domino's Pizza (Up to 47% Off)

Domino's Pizza

New Haven

Ubiquitous pizza franchise bakes classic pies with more than 37 toppings to choose from accompanied by garlic-laden breadsticks or bites

$17.07 $9

View Deal

Grazie! Italian Eatery: $28 for $50 Worth of Italian Dinner for Two or More at Grazie! Italian Eatery

$28 for $50 Worth of Italian Dinner for Two or More at Grazie! Italian Eatery

Grazie! Italian Eatery

Downtown Bloomington

Casual Italian restaurant with a lively atmosphere features steaks, fresh seafood, and pastas crafted from locally sourced ingredients

$50 $28

View Deal

DeAngelos: Italian and Louisianan Cuisine for Lunch or Dinner  at DeAngelos (40% Off). Two Options Available.

Italian and Louisianan Cuisine for Lunch or Dinner at DeAngelos (40% Off). Two Options Available.

DeAngelos

Bloomington

Crispy New York–style pizzas share menu space with other Italian classics and Louisianan specialties including homemade meat lasagna

$20 $12

View Deal

Noble Romans Take N' Bake Pizza: $10 for Two Groupons, Each Good for $10  at Noble Romans Take N' Bake Pizza        ($20 Value)

$10 for Two Groupons, Each Good for $10 at Noble Romans Take N' Bake Pizza ($20 Value)

Noble Romans Take N' Bake Pizza

West Lafayette

Take-and-bake pizzas in deep-dish, traditional, or wafer-thin cracker crusts; sides such as breadsticks and wings

$10 $5

View Deal

Select Local Merchants

  • Dale's Pizza
    If you haven't experienced Dale's, now is the perfect time to enjoy the highly-rated pizza place. Stop by for the great quality and stay for helpful service. You'll be planning your next trip to Dale's before you know it. There's no specific recommended attire, so feel free to dress casually and comfortably. If you're on the lookout for the perfect spot for family or friends, it's been reviewed as a solid option for large groups and kids. In addition to its quick service (take-out is available), the restaurant also offers delivery, and can even cater an event for you. Or, if you just want to stop by for a beverage, the restaurant has a pretty broad selection at its bar. A staple in the community for nearly 60 years, a trip to Dale's is definitely worthwhile, no matter how you slice it. Visitors to the restaurant have access to a private lot nearby or can park on the street.
    Read More
    75 W Main St
    Hagerstown, IN US
  • Mancino's Pizza and Grinders
    Whether you are looking for a slice of pizza or a whole pizza pie, New Castle's Mancino's Pizza and Grinders offers a wide variety of pizza types and sizes. Keep your diet in check at Mancino's Pizza and Grinders, a local restaurant with gluten-free and low-fat menu items. Your group can sit comfortably at Mancino's Pizza and Grinders, a local restaurant. Business casual dress, tasty food and a classic atmosphere makes this a great place for any occasion. Delivery and take out are both available if you prefer to eat in the comfort of your own home. Catering is also available if you'd like to serve Mancino's Pizza and Grinders' tasty dishes at your next party. Drivers can park in the neighboring lot. Mancino's Pizza and Grinders proves that an amazing meal can be both delicious and affordable.
    Read More
    2111 S Memorial Dr
    New Castle, IN US
  • Pizza Hut
    If you are in search of a satisfying meal that won't empty the wallet, then look no further than Pizza Hut on S Memorial Dr. Whether you are stopping in for the excellent quality, friendly service, or both, you will always leave this restaurant impressed. There's no specific recommended attire, so feel free to dress casually and comfortably. Also, though the prices may be low, you can bank on the ingredients being fresh. If you don't feel like eating in, you can always grab your food to go, or just place an order for delivery. One of the better pizza chains in the area, this particular Pizza Hut is definitely the place to gather 'round the good stuff.
    Read More
    1649 S Memorial Dr
    New Castle, IN US
  • Big Bounce Family Fun Center
    In Big Bounce?s 7,500-square-foot fun center, kids scatter across the cushy, rainbow-colored patchwork floor and sprint between inflatable obstacle courses and tropical-themed bounce houses. They filter through the doorway in droves for open-bounce play or private parties and glide down the enormous air-filled slide or shoot baskets in the sports inflatable. In the adjoining diner, which offers views into the play area, families slip into booths to dine on pizza, jumbo hot dogs, and 16 flavors of hand-dipped ice cream. In between bounces and nibbles, kids can shoot hoops and play crane games to learn the painful truth about natural selection.
    Read More
    1701 S Main St
    New Castle, IN US
  • Noble Roman's
    One of the better-priced Italian restaurants in New Castle, guests of Noble Roman's won't have to smash their piggy banks for a satisfying meal and pleasant experience. Whether you are stopping in for the great quality, lightning-fast service, or both, you are sure to leave this restaurant with a smile on your face. Though the prices may be low, you can bank on the ingredients being fresh. If you don't feel like driving over to South 14th, placing a delivery order is an option. A reliable option in New Castle, a trip to Noble Roman's is definitely worthwhile, no matter how you slice it.
    Read More
    2505 South 14th Street
    New Castle, IN US
  • Suzy's Pizza
    If you have yet to eat at Suzy's, it's a great time to enjoy the acclaimed pizza place. Whether you are visiting for the excellent quality, helpful service, or both, you will always leave this restaurant impressed. Though the overall price can be a bit on the low side, you won't be sacrificing any quality. If you don't feel like eating in, you can always grab your food to go, or just place an order for delivery. Add it all up, and Suzy's stands out, no matter how you slice it. Visitors to the restaurant have the ability to park nearby on the street.
    Read More
    2 E Main St
    Knightstown, IN US

Groupon Guide

Advertisement