- $24 for Two Groupons, Each Good for $20 Worth of Deli Sandwiches & Bagels ($40 total value)
Island Bagel & Deli
Besides being islands, of course, Hilton Head Island and Manhattan have one crucial thing in common: they're both home to authentic, New York-style bagels. At Island Bagel & Deli, the cooks do things the Big Apple way, whipping up 16 varieties of bagels each day from scratch, then boiling them in a kettle of purified water. Bagel flavors include chocolate chip, sesame, and cinnamon raisin, and, to make them even more enticing, the kitchen also crafts 12 flavors of cream cheese in-house, so customers don't have to go home and churn their own. Of course, bagels are just the beginning. Here, hungry guests will also find a selection of signature sandwiches served on hoagies (or bagels), including the aptly named "Our Favorite," which features hot pulled turkey and bacon topped with provolone, cream cheese, and an avocado spread.