The dough doyens at Za Za Fine Salad & Wood Oven Pizza Co. draw from a menu of authentic Italian eats, sizzling up Napoli-style wood-fired pizza, mixing fresh salads with locally sourced ingredients, and crafting house-made gelato from scratch. Guests can kick off their evening of chewing, chatting, and cowabungaing over a Perella pizza slathered with goat cheese, prosciutto, and garlic atop a crust made with imported Italian low-gluten flour ($12), or the tangy barbecue shrimp pizza with scallions and wood-oven roasted shrimp ($12.50). Otherwise, delve into one of the dozen specialty salads, including the asian salad blended with chicken tenders, mandarin oranges, and wonton crisps ($9.25), or mount a one-sided staring contest with the chefs as they blend custom salads tableside ($5.25 + $0.50–$4/ingredient). A scoop of silky gelato, which is made fresh in-house every morning ($3.75 for a small), joyously arrives at tables to conclude hearty nosh fests.
Family-owned Le Star Pizzaria dishes up a menu of regular and thin-crust pizzas alongside traditional pastas and sub sandwiches. Ten specialty pies harbor distinctive combinations of more than a dozen savory toppings and seasonings, and housemade cakes and pies subdue stark, raving sweet teeth in fruit-based straightjackets. The pizza parlor hosts a weekday happy hour and provides discounts for active military and police personnel.
The menu at American Pie Pizza places classic pizza creations alongside delicious sandwich and snack options. Fire up your feast by surfing atop tortilla chips into a bowl of Robbi's Salsa (small $3.99, large $6.99) before making friends with one of the pizzeria's masterful pies. Patrons can create their own pizza, selecting an 8" ($4.29), a 10" ($7.99), or a 14" ($10.99) pie draped with mozzarella cheese and ready to be painted with your choice of toppings from 11 meats and 22 veggies ($.70–$1.10 each). For lunchers too lazy to craft their circular cuisine themselves, American Pie Pizza offers favorites such as the margherita ($6.29–$13.89), the beef-and-veggie bounty of the supreme ($6.99–$15.49), and the pork-packed Hog Wild Pizza ($7.59–$16.99). Gluten-free crusts are available on 10" pizzas for an additional $1. Say no to dough with a sandwich such as a meatball sub ($4.99–$7.79) or the American Club ($4.79–$7.59). Unlike the mythical clutch hitter, the "pizzookie" dessert, a chocolaty, peanut buttery creation topped with syrup and whipped cream ($6.99–$15.49), is as real as it is delicious.
While the heart of Johnny Carino's menu is rooted in genuine Italian traditions, forward-thinking creativity has birthed what they like to call their signature dishes. Led by executive chef Chris Peitersen, the seasoned kitchen staff blends fresh ingredients along with extra time to create high-quality, spiced Italian preparations. Diners will find entrees such as 16-layer lasagna with made-from-scratch sauce, and pizzas made with home-baked crust. Other signature choices include the spicy shrimp and chicken, baked stuffed mushrooms topped with house lemon basil cream sauce, and tiramisu made from the ground up. Entrees can be paired any selection from Carino's extensive wine list and drink menu.
There's an old saying that claims you shouldn't fix what isn't broken. Don't tell that to the team at Old Chicago pizza and taproom, though. Turns out, going against traditional wisdom can sometimes pay off. After more than three decades of success that saw the addition of two locations in Arkansas, the team decided to spice things up and completely revamp their menu. They introduced 40 new menu items, including a tavern-style thin-crust pizza to go along with their classic Chicago-style deep dish. Of course, the new pie adheres to Old Chicago's unwavering commitment to quality ingredients, including preservative-free dough made from just water, sugar, yeast, virgin wheat flour, and salt.?
This commitment to top-notch quality runs throughout the rest of the food roster, from an appetizer of house-made soft pretzels studded with fresh jalapenos to a New York-style cheesecake drizzled with a sauce that takes three days to prepare. The craft-beer selection is equally thoughtful, with 30 on tap that include 6 on rotation. In fact, Old Chicago is so invested in great beer that they even offer tips on how to best drink it, including using a glass instead of a plate.