Handel's Homemade Ice Cream, Fishers

Since 1945, employees at Handel's Homemade Ice Cream & Yogurt have been hand-making batches of frozen treats everyday using top-secret ingredients, equipment, and recipes. Their on-site freezers are designed to produce an irresistibly smooth, creamy consistency, which they then enhance with generous handfuls of fresh fruit, dark chocolate, and nuts.

The ice cream's signature texture and rotating menu of more than 140 flavors—which include creative combinations such as cherry cordial, peppermint stick, chocolate peanut butter brownie, and salty caramel truffle—have earned accolades from customers, industry professionals, and sentient ice-cream scoopers alike, including National Geographic, who awarded Handel's the number one spot in their list of "Ten Best Ice Creams" from their "Ten Best of Everything" issue.