Main menu Open search menu

Legends

Menu
Food & Drink
835 1st Street, New Suffolk, NY 11956 835 1st Street, New Suffolk Directions
Today 12:00 PM - 11:59 PM Closed All Hours
+16317345123
View Website
View Menu
Map & Contact Info

Swing by New Suffolk community for a quick cocktail at Legends. For the tastes of Legends from the comfort of your next party, the bar also offers catering services.

About this Business

  • Cuisine
    American, Eclectic, Seafood, Contemporary, Fusion
  • Meals
    Lunch, Dinner
  • Price
    $15-$30
  • Hours
    Sun
    12:00 AM - 1:00 AM, 12:00 PM - 11:59 PM
    Mon-Fri
    12:00 PM - 11:59 PM
    Sat
    12:00 AM - 1:00 AM, 12:00 PM - 11:59 PM
  • Cuisine
    American, Eclectic, Seafood, Contemporary, Fusion
  • Meals
    Lunch, Dinner
  • Show More
  • Attire
    Casual
  • Alcohol
    Available
  • Parking
    Street
  • Free Parking
    Yes
  • Delivery
    No
  • Takeout
    Yes
  • Reservations
    Yes
  • Vegetarian Options
    Yes
  • Catering
    Yes
  • Good For Kids
    Yes
  • WiFi
    Yes
  • Show Less

Tips

250

From Our Editors

Planted in the middle of New Suffolk district, the mellow drinker will appreciate Legends' low-key vibe. It's always the right time to eat a delicious, healthy meal. Find one that won't disappoint at Legends. Watch the game with fellow fans to get the full sports experience. This bar is kid-friendly, so little ones are welcome to tag along. Need to catch up on some work or the latest news? Get online at Legends with their complimentary wifi.

Avoid playing the waiting game and call ahead for a table. Legends welcomes laid-back diners, so there's no pressure to throw on heels or a tie.

Legends is located in a prime location where street parking is always readily available. Store your bike at a nearby rack and enjoy a bite to eat at Legends.

For great dishes that fall smack dab in the middle when it comes to price, Legends is a reasonable option for diners of different budgets.

map
Legends
Legends

Starters

Housemade Guacamole and Corn Tortilla Chips
avocado, red onion, fresh lime juice, hint of cilantro, surprise ingredient
$12.00
Toasted Porcini Ravioli with Spinach and Garlic Butter
lightly truffled porcini ravioli sautéed with spinach, garlic and butter; parmigiano-reggiano
$12.00
Braised Short Rib "Toastie"
boneless short ribs with caramelized onions, mushrooms and goat cheese; toasted focaccia
$15.00
Korean Style "Shaking" Beef on Napa Cabbage
strips of beef marinated in soy, sesame, ginger and a wee bit of spice, with green onions; kimchi
$14.00
"The Big Easy's" Oysters LeBrig
broiled oysters on the half shell stuffed with shrimp, crabmeat, cream, breadcrumbs, parmesan cheese, hint of spice
$16.00
Thai Sausage and Shrimp in Wonton "Saucers"
crunchy wontons; somewhat spicy; garlic, cilantro, basil and ginger
$13.00
Classic Maryland Crab Cake
"jumbo lump" (refers to size of lump) crab cake, wedge of lemon
$20.00
Shrimp Scampi with Crostini
garlic butter, lemon, parsley
$14.00
Sautéed Octopus
tender octopus with garlic butter, lemon, parsley, extra virgin olive oil
$15.00
Shrimp and Vegetable Spring Rolls
ginger-pineapple dipping sauce
$14.00
Shrimp Cocktail
$15.00
Steamed Hard Clams or P.E.I. Mussels
garlic-white wine broth or marinara
$15.00
New Orleans Style Baked Stuffed Clams
chopped clams, chorizo, garlic, parmigiano-reggiano
$13.00
Fried Calamari
fried; tossed with garlic, pepperoncini, olive oil
$15.00
Mike's Calamari
fried; tossed with garlic, pepperoncini, olive oil
$16.00
Clams or Oysters on the Half Shell*
cucumber mignonette or cocktail sauce
Tuna Napoleon*
raw tuna, miso-ginger dressing, seaweed salad layered between crispy wontons
Sesame-Crusted Tuna Sashimi*
seared tuna, pickled ginger, wasabi, seaweed salad
Buffalo Wings
$14.00
Onion Rings
$8.00
Chicken Fingers
$10.00
Mozzarella Sticks
$8.00

Soup and Salads

New Suffolk Clam Chowder
spicy, tomato based, clams and crabmeat
$8.00
Eggplant Napoleon Tower Salad
chilled layered eggplant, tomato, basil and feta cheese; drizzles of balsamic syrup; pesto
$13.00
Baby Greens and Grapefruit with Feta Cheese
intoxicating creation of baby greens; grapefruit; sliced toasted almonds, mint and cilantro, lime, agave and toasted cumin vinaigrette
$13.00
Hawaiian Chicken Salad
grilled chicken layered with crispy egg roll wrappers, romaine, sweet red and yellow peppers, green beans, cucumber, red onion, mango, sesame seeds, carrots, scallions, macadamia nuts; lemon miso dressing
$19.00
Rocket with Tricolor Beets and Goat Cheese
arugula, avocado, walnuts, dried cranberries; honey-shallot balsamic dressing
$14.00
Caesar Salad
romaine, house made croutons, parmesan crostini, anchovy-caesar dressing
$12.00
Legends Salad
baby lettuce, tomato, red onion, cucumber, carrots
$9.00

Salad Add-Ons

Grilled Chicken
$7.00
Lobster Tail
$16.00
Grilled Shrimp
$10.00
Grilled Skirt Steak
$13.00

Sides

Asparagus
$9.00
Haricots Verts
$7.00
Mixed Veggies
$4.00
Onion Rings
$8.00
French Fries
$4.00
Sweet Potato Fries
$5.00
Mashed Potatoes
$6.00
Rice
$4.00

Lunch Mains

Southern-Style Buttermilk Fried Chicken
boneless breast of chicken, buttermilk marinade, crispy outer shell; buttermilk gravy; summer succotash - corn, lima beans, tomatoes, garlic, onions, sugar snap peas
$18.00
Mediterranean Style Grilled Skirt Steak*
warm fingerling potato, chickpea and arugula pesto mélange; charred tomatoes; medium rare-ish
$25.00
Pan-Seared, Roasted Salmon* with a Summery, Light Coconut-Curry Sauce
basmati rice; sugar snap peas; sprinkle of sesame seeds
$22.00
Cacciucco – Tuscan Seafood Stew
tuna, shrimp, salmon, mussels, clams in spicy tomato broth; garlic crostini
$23.00
Legendary Seafood Pot Pie
shrimp, scallops, tuna, crawfish, puff pastry crust; sherried lobster sauce
$22.00
Pad Thai with Shrimp
slightly spicy with rice noodles, vegetables, ginger, sesame, peanuts, egg, cilantro
$14.00
Asian Vegetable Stir-Fry
sweet red peppers, red onion, green beans, carrots, lotus root, rice; ginger-sesame-soy (gluten-free) and sprinkled with sesame seeds – we may add/substitute seasonal vegetables
$17.00
"North Fork Favorites" and Special Sandwiches
ask your server

Pizza, Quesadilla, Sandwiches, etc.

Stone-Baked 10-Inch Thin Crust Pizza
ask your server for today's toppings
Petite Quesadillas P.A.
cheddar, mozzarella, sweet red and yellow peppers, onion, guacamole, sour cream, salsa; minimum 2, priced individually: beef, chicken, shrimp
Beef
cheddar, mozzarella, sweet red and yellow peppers, onion, guacamole, sour cream, salsa; minimum 2, priced individually: beef, chicken, shrimp
Chicken
cheddar, mozzarella, sweet red and yellow peppers, onion, guacamole, sour cream, salsa; minimum 2, priced individually: beef, chicken, shrimp
Shrimp
cheddar, mozzarella, sweet red and yellow peppers, onion, guacamole, sour cream, salsa; minimum 2, priced individually: beef, chicken, shrimp
$7.00
Mahi Mahi Tacos
lightly fried mahi, pepperjack, salsa, napa cabbage-carrot-red onion slaw; avocado, cilantro, lime cream
$16.00
Chicken Quesadilla Stogies
crispy, rolled, sour cream-tomatillo dipping sauce
$14.00
Pork and Shrimp "Shumai" Burger^
ground pork, chopped shrimp, onion, soy, and cilantro; chipotle aioli
$15.00
Grilled Chicken, Avocado and Bacon Sandwich^
grilled chicken, bacon, crumbled blue cheese, white balsamic, lettuce, tomato, focaccia
$16.00
Grilled Shell Steak* Sandwich^
garlic focaccia (open-face)
$25.00
Legends Half-Pound Burger* ^
^Served with french fries. Instead, substitute sweet potato fries $1.50 | vegetable medley $1; 'side' vegetables (ask your server) $3 | Legends half salad $3.50
$12.00
Grilled Vegetable "Muffuletta"
eggplant, zucchini, roasted red peppers, spinach, provolone, herbed vinaigrette, focaccia side of spicy Italian vegetable salad (giardiniera)
$13.00
Lobster Tail Sandwich^
fried Canadian lobster tail; ginger-mustard aioli; brioche roll, napa cabbage-carrot-red onion slaw
$22.00
Salmon B.L.T.* ^
seared and roasted salmon, bacon, lettuce, tomato; caper mayo, focaccia
$15.00
Grilled Sesame Tuna Sandwich* ^
grilled red onion, ginger-mustard aïoli, brioche roll
$19.00
Fried Fish Sandwich^
cod or flounder, depending on market available/pricing

Starters

Housemade Guacamole and Corn Tortilla Chips
avocado, red onion, fresh lime juice, hint of cilantro, surprise ingredient
$12.00
Toasted Porcini Ravioli with Spinach and Garlic Butter
lightly truffled porcini ravioli sautéed with spinach, garlic and butter; parmigiano-reggiano
$12.00
Braised Short Rib "Toastie"
boneless short ribs with caramelized onions, mushrooms and goat cheese; toasted focaccia
$15.00
Korean Style "Shaking" Beef on Napa Cabbage
strips of beef marinated in soy, sesame, ginger and a wee bit of spice, with green onions; kimchi
$14.00
"The Big Easy's" Oysters LeBrig
broiled oysters on the half shell stuffed with shrimp, crabmeat, cream, breadcrumbs, parmesan cheese, hint of spice
$16.00
Thai Sausage and Shrimp in Wonton "Saucers"
crunchy wontons; somewhat spicy; garlic, cilantro, basil and ginger
$13.00
Classic Maryland Crab Cake
"jumbo lump" (refers to size of lump) crab cake, wedge of lemon
$20.00
Shrimp Scampi with Crostini
garlic butter, lemon, parsley
$14.00
Sautéed Octopus
tender octopus with garlic butter, lemon, parsley, extra virgin olive oil
$15.00
Shrimp and Vegetable Spring Rolls
ginger-pineapple dipping sauce
$14.00
Shrimp Cocktail
$15.00
Steamed Hard Clams or P.E.I. Mussels
garlic-white wine broth or marinara
$15.00
New Orleans Style Baked Stuffed Clams
chopped clams, chorizo, garlic, parmigiano-reggiano
$13.00
Fried Calamari
fried; tossed with garlic, pepperoncini, olive oil
$15.00
Mike's Calamari
fried; tossed with garlic, pepperoncini, olive oil
$16.00
Clams or Oysters on the Half Shell*
cucumber mignonette or cocktail sauce
Tuna Napoleon*
raw tuna, miso-ginger dressing, seaweed salad layered between crispy wontons
Sesame-Crusted Tuna Sashimi*
seared tuna, pickled ginger, wasabi, seaweed salad
Buffalo Wings
$14.00
Onion Rings
$8.00
Chicken Fingers
$10.00
Mozzarella Sticks
$8.00

Soup and Salads

New Suffolk Clam Chowder
spicy, tomato based, clams and crabmeat
$8.00
Eggplant Napoleon Tower Salad
chilled layered eggplant, tomato, basil and feta cheese; drizzles of balsamic syrup; pesto
$13.00
Baby Greens and Grapefruit with Feta Cheese
intoxicating creation of baby greens; grapefruit; sliced toasted almonds, mint and cilantro, lime, agave and toasted cumin vinaigrette
$13.00
Hawaiian Chicken Salad
grilled chicken layered with crispy egg roll wrappers, romaine, sweet red and yellow peppers, green beans, cucumber, red onion, mango, sesame seeds, carrots, scallions, macadamia nuts; lemon miso dressing
$19.00
Rocket with Tricolor Beets and Goat Cheese
arugula, avocado, walnuts, dried cranberries; honey-shallot balsamic dressing
$14.00
Caesar Salad
romaine, house made croutons, parmesan crostini, anchovy-caesar dressing
$12.00
Legends Salad
baby lettuce, tomato, red onion, cucumber, carrots
$9.00

Salad Add-Ons

Grilled Chicken
$7.00
Lobster Tail
$16.00
Grilled Shrimp
$10.00
Grilled Skirt Steak
$13.00

Sides

Asparagus
$9.00
Haricots Verts
$7.00
Mixed Veggies
$4.00
Onion Rings
$8.00
French Fries
$4.00
Sweet Potato Fries
$5.00
Mashed Potatoes
$6.00
Rice
$4.00

Dinner Main

Filet Mignon* with Steak Diane Sauce
pan juices, mushrooms, parsley, shallots, mustard and cognac; fingerling potatoes; asparagus
$41.00
Grilled Black Angus New York Strip Steak*
plain or marinated; mashed potatoes; haricots verts
$39.00
Mediterranean Style Grilled Skirt Steak*
warm fingerling potato, chickpea and arugula pesto mélange; roasted tomatoes; medium rare-ish
$30.00
Cuban Style Pork Shank with Black Bean Corn Salsa
marinated in rum, lime, jalapeno peppers, cilantro and fresh herbs — braised and served with black bean and corn salsa
$31.00
Pappardelle Pasta with Boneless Braised Short Rib and Horseradish Cream
pasta tossed with boneless braised short ribs, horseradish cream, dollop of orange gremolata — orange zest, minced garlic and parsley
$29.00
Parmesan, Panko and Herb Crusted Chicken with Lemon-Sage Sauce
creamy citrus sauce; haricots verts; fingerling potatoes
$28.00
Pan–Seared and Roasted Salmon* with a Summery, Light Coconut-Curry Sauce
basmati rice, sugar snap peas; sprinkle of sesame seeds
$30.00
Cacciucco – Tuscan Seafood Stew
shrimp, mussels, clams, tuna, salmon, garlic crostini; spicy tomato sauce
$34.00
Seafood Vol-Au-Vent
shrimp, scallops, crawfish, tuna, puff pastry triangles, haricots verts; sherried lobster sauce
$32.00
Paccheri con Gamberi
shrimp, spinach, roasted tomato, garlic, white wine, finished with extra virgin olive oil and parmigiano-reggiano
$28.00
Alaskan King Crab Legs
approximately 1.2 pounds; mashed potatoes, french fries, or rice; haricots verts
$49.00
Pad Thai with Shrimp
slightly spicy with rice noodles, vegetables, ginger, sesame, peanuts, egg, cilantro
$17.00
North Fork Favorites
ask your server
Asian Vegetable Stir-Fry
sweet red peppers, red onion, green beans, carrots, lotus root, rice; ginger-sesame-soy (gluten-free) and sprinkled with sesame seeds – we may add/substitute seasonal vegetables. Vegan: Ask your server
$19.00
Paccheri Pasta with Italian Sausage, Spinach, and White Beans
large tubular pasta (slightly larger than rigatoni); crumbled, hot Italian sausage (Teitel Bros, Arthur Ave) sautéed spinach; cannellini beans; extra virgin olive oil; parmigiano-reggiano. Vegan: Ask your server
$28.00

Starters and Small Plates

Housemade Guacamole and Corn Tortilla Chips
avocado, red onion, fresh lime juice, hint of cilantro, surprise ingredient
$11.00
Oysters Miguel
baked with spinach, chipotle, tequila, parmigiano-reggiano
$13.00
Lobster Mac & Cheese
lobster chunks, orecchiette pasta, gruyère, cheddar, parmigiano-reggiano
$16.00
Shrimp and Vegetable Spring Rolls
ginger-pineapple dipping sauce
$14.00
Shrimp Cocktail
all meats are precooked weight, please ask your server vegetarian and gluten-free options
$14.00
Pan-Seared Asian Style Crabcakes
lemongrass, ginger, garlic; with sake teriyaki
$14.00
Steamed Hard Clams or P. E. I. Mussels
garlic-white wine broth or marinara
$14.00
New Orleans Style Baked Stuffed Clams
chopped clams, chorizo, garlic, parmigiano-reggiano
$11.00
Fried Calamari
all meats are precooked weight, please ask your server vegetarian and gluten-free options
$12.00
Mike's Calamari
fried then tossed with garlic, spicy pepperoncini , olive oil
$16.00
Clams or Oysters on the Half Shell*
all meats are precooked weight, please ask your server vegetarian and gluten-free options
Tuna Napoleon
raw tuna, miso-ginger dressing, seaweed salad layered between crispy wontons
Sesame-Crusted Tuna Sashim*
seared tuna, pickled ginger , wasabi , seaweed salad
Buffalo Wings
all meats are precooked weight, please ask your server vegetarian and gluten-free options
$12.00
Onion Rings
all meats are precooked weight, please ask your server vegetarian and gluten-free options
$8.00
Chicken Fingers
all meats are precooked weight, please ask your server vegetarian and gluten-free options
$8.00
Mozzarella Sticks
all meats are precooked weight, please ask your server vegetarian and gluten-free options
$7.00

Soups and Salads

New Suffolk Clam Chowder
spicy, tomato based, clams and crabmeat
$7.00
Eggplant Napoleon
layered eggplant, tomato, basil and feta cheese; drizzles of balsamic syrup and pesto sauce
$12.00
Mediter-Asian Salad
sundried tomato, artichoke, edamame, chickpeas, black-eyed peas, scallion, basil, mint, pumpkin seeds, vinaigrette
$8.00
Hawaiian Chicken Salad
grilled chicken, baby field greens, sweet red and yellow peppers, green beans, cucumber, red onion, mango, sesame seeds, carrots, scallions, macadamia nuts; lemon miso dressing
$18.00
Rocket with Tricolor Beets and Goat Cheese
arugula, avocado, walnuts , dried cranberries; honey-shallot balsamic dressing
$13.00
Caesar Salad
all meats are precooked weight, please ask your server vegetarian and gluten-free options
$8.00
Legends Salad
romaine greens, tomato, red onion, cucumber, carrots
$8.00

Salad Add - Ons

Grilled Chicken
add to any salad
$7.00
Lobster Tail
add to any salad
$18.00
Grilled Shrimp
add to any salad
$10.00
Grilled Skirt Steak
add to any salad
$9.00

Pizza, Sandwiches Etc.

Stone-Baked 10-Inch Thin Crust Pizza
ask your server for today's toppings
Mahi Mahi Tacos
pepperjack, salsa, napa cabbage-carrot-red onion slaw; avocado, cilantro and lime cream
$14.00
Chicken Quesadilla Stogies
rolled and fried, sour cream tomatillo dipping sauce
$13.00
Fried Lobster Tail Sandwich**
ginger-mustard aïoli; brioche roll
$22.00
Scottish Salmon Blt* **
grilled salmon, bacon, baby greens, tomato; dill-caper mayo, focaccia
$15.00
Grilled Sesame Tuna Sandwich* **
grilled red onion, ginger-mustard aïoli, brioche roll
$17.00
Petite Quesadillas P. A.
cheddar, mozzarella, sweet red and yellow peppers, onion, guacamole, sour cream, salsa; minimum 2, priced individuall
Beef
cheddar, mozzarella, sweet red and yellow peppers, onion, guacamole, sour cream, salsa; minimum 2, priced individuall
Pork
cheddar, mozzarella, sweet red and yellow peppers, onion, guacamole, sour cream, salsa; minimum 2, priced individuall
Chicken
cheddar, mozzarella, sweet red and yellow peppers, onion, guacamole, sour cream, salsa; minimum 2, priced individuall
Lobster
cheddar, mozzarella, sweet red and yellow peppers, onion, guacamole, sour cream, salsa; minimum 2, priced individuall
Shrimp
cheddar, mozzarella, sweet red and yellow peppers, onion, guacamole, sour cream, salsa; minimum 2, priced individuall
$6.50
Grilled Chicken, Avocado and Bacon Sandwich**
grilled chicken, bacon, crumbled blue cheese, white balsamic, focaccia
$14.00
Cuban-Style Frita**
chorizo & sweet italian sausage burger, fried onion, chipotle-cilantro mayo, brioche roll
$13.00
Grilled Vegetable "Muffuletta"
eggplant, zucchini, roasted red peppers, asparagus, provolone, herbed vinaigrette, focaccia side of spicy italian vegetable salad (giardiniera)
$13.00
Fried Flounder Sandwich**
all meats are precooked weight, please ask your server vegetarian and gluten-free options
$15.00
"Usda Prime" Shell Steak Sandwich* **
12 oz. on garlic focaccia
$21.00
Legends Half-Pound Burger* **
all meats are precooked weight, please ask your server vegetarian and gluten-free options
$11.00

Larger Plates

Seared and Roasted Scottish Salmon*
all of the below dishes served with french fries and vegetable medley
$18.00
Boneless Pork Chop
all of the below dishes served with french fries and vegetable medley
$15.00
Fried Oyster
all of the below dishes served with french fries and vegetable medley
$17.00
Fried Shrimp
all of the below dishes served with french fries and vegetable medley
$16.00
Fried Flounder
all of the below dishes served with french fries and vegetable medley
$17.00
Pad Thai with Shrimp
slightly spicy with rice noodles, vegetables, ginger, sesame, peanuts, egg, cilantro
$13.00
attribution

Explore Nearby
Legends

Recommended For You View All

Nearby Places

Popular Searches

Searches Nearby

Switch to Desktop Version
Sun
12:00 AM - 1:00 AM, 12:00 PM - 11:59 PM
Mon-Fri
12:00 PM - 11:59 PM
Sat
12:00 AM - 1:00 AM, 12:00 PM - 11:59 PM
Groupon has verified that the customer actually visited Legends.