Find the flavor that satisfies your sweet tooth at Tuck Shop, a lovely ice cream shop in the Shelter Island region of Shelter Island.

Pull into one of the many parking spaces nearby if you choose to drive to the ice cream shop.

Frugal foodies will especially love the prices at Tuck Shop, with a meal typically hovering under the $15 mark. When you have a hankering for some ice cream, make your way over to the highly-rated Tuck Shop.