Bay Harbor, Sandusky

Lobster tail tastes best with drawn butter, Gouda mashed potatoes, and waterfront views—and luckily for diners at Bay Harbor, the culinary team serves lobster tail with both of those sides. Their eatery is best known for its seafood dishes, and is appropriately situated on the shores of Lake Erie at Cedar Point Marina, quite near the lake's village of sass-mouthed mermaids. Beyond the sea, the restaurant also offers classic steak dishes like filet mignon and specialty pastas. Before digging in, diners can toast with a glass of wine, or one of the bartender's cocktails, which include martinis and Irish coffee.