Bagel Jay's Bakery and Cafe

Multiple Locations

Give as a Gift
Limited quantity available
Over 1,000 bought

In a Nutshell

Specialty sandwiches made on New York–style, hearth-baked bagels with slices of roasted turkey, hot corned beef, or ham

The Fine Print

Promotional value expires Jun 30, 2014. Amount paid never expires. Limit 1 per person, may buy 1 additional as a gift. Limit 1 per table. Limit 1 per visit. Not valid with any other offers or specials. Valid at all 3 locations. Tax is not included. Merchant is solely responsible to purchasers for the care and quality of the advertised goods and services.

The bagel, like the circle from which it takes its shape, is a metaphor for life—it literally never ends. Enjoy eternally enticing eats with this Groupon.

The Deal

  • $9.50 for two sandwiches and two 16 oz. fountain Pepsi's or 12 oz. coffees (a $19.76 total value)

See the full menu

Bagel Jay's Bakery and Cafe

Like Prometheus stealing fire from the gods to give it to humankind, the founders of Bagel Jay's Bakery and Cafe brought bagels to Western New York in 1976. Since then, owner Bagel Jay has been crafting circular standbys with a menu of freshly baked bagels paired with savory deli meats. Diners dress their hearth-baked bagel with cream-cheese shmears of scallions, vegetable, and cinnamon honey, or construct sandwiches of sliced roasted turkey, hot corned beef, or ham. A steaming cup of Jakee's Java and a breakfast bagel with bacon and cheese help jump-start the morning, and classic tuna salad fortifies muscles after a long day of playing Jenga with railroad ties.

Customer Reviews

Nice folks, good food. Honored at full price an expired groupon.
Lisa K. · August 30, 2014
Awesome bagels! Best in town!
Karen K. · July 7, 2014
Restaurant very clean. Workers very friendly and helpful. Can choose any sandwich on the menu, no price restrictions. Food very tastly.
Linda M. · June 28, 2014
Merchant Location Map
  1. 1


    2130 Delaware Ave.

    Buffalo, NY 14207


    Get Directions
  2. 2


    100 A Plaza Dr.

    Williamsville, NY 14221


    Get Directions
  3. 3

    Green Acres North

    2206 Millersport Highway

    Getzville, NY 14068


    Get Directions

By purchasing this deal you'll unlock points which can be spent on discounts and rewards. Every 5,000 points can be redeemed for $5 Off your next purchase.