Italian Restaurants in Metuchen, NJ

Two Groupons, Each Good For a Large Pizza with Up to Three Toppings at Papa John's Pizza (46% Off). 7 Locations.

Papa John's Pizza

Multiple Locations

Hand-tossed pizzas slathered with sauce made from vine-ripened, California-grown tomatoes

$18.36 $9.99

$32 for $50 Worth of Italian Food at Theresa's Restaurant

Theresa's Restaurant


Italian entrees from veal scaloppini to asiago-crusted chicken; pasta made in-house daily

$50 $32

Italian Cuisine for Dinner at Nonnas Citi Cucina (Up to 42% Off). Two Options Available.

Nonnas Citi Cucina


Italian joint dishes out fried calamari, meatball sliders, penne bolognese, short rib, and pear blue cheese pizzetta with crispy proscuitto

$40 $23

$10 For $20 Worth Of Casual Dining


Southwestern Perth Amboy

$20 $10

Dine-In or Takeout Pizza from Sal's Gourmet Pizzeria and Restaurant (Up to 50% Off). Three Options Available.

Sal's Gourmet Pizzeria and Restaurant


Pizza-hungry diners can enjoy the casual, family-friendly atmosphere of Sal’s or enjoy their feast at home via takeout or delivery

$30 $15

$32 for $50 Worth of BYOB Italian Food at Cara Mia, Available Sunday-Thursday

Cara Mia


This elegant family-owned BYOB restaurant serves refined Italian dishes like grilled branzino with balsamic reduction and seafood fettuccine

$50 $32

Italian Food for Lunch, Dinner, or Takeout at Sofia's Italian Restaurant (Up to 50% Off). Two Options Available.

Sofia's Italian Restaurant

Sofia's Italian Restaurant

BYO wines complement traditional Italian entrees; perfect for date night

$50 $25

$15 For $30 Worth Of Italian Cuisine & Specialties

Benvenuti Italian Specialties & Catering


$30 $15

Italian Food for Dine-In at Eatalian Bistro (Up to 46% Off). Two Options Available.

Eatalian Bistro


BYOB eatery creates rustic and hearty Italian dishes such as lobster ravioli and shrimp, eggplant rollatini, and garlic white basil pizza

$35 $19

Italian Cuisine for Dine-In, Takeout, or Delivery at Goodfella's Old World Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta (50% Off)

Goodfella's Old World Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta

Dongan Hills

Enjoy award-winning brick-oven pizzas and Italian entrees and pastas in a bistro setting or at home

$30 $15

$15 For $30 Worth Of Italian Cuisine


Downtown Elizabeth

$30 $15

Italian Cuisine for Two or More or Four or More at Luna Piena Restaurant (Up to 46% Off)

Luna Piena Restaurant

Midtown East

Classic Italian dishes include homemade pasta dubbed “light and airy” by New York magazine, Black Angus steak, and many seafood dishes

$60 $35

$10 For $20 Worth Of Italian Cuisine

Scaturro's Pizzeria & Cafe

Downtown Elizabeth

$20 $10

Pizza, Pasta, and International Food for Two or Four at Pete's Pizza (Up to 52% Off). Two Options Available.

Pete's Pizza


Chefs serve Italian, Greek and American favorites to hungry diners in a family-owned restaurant

$51.90 $25

Italian Food and Burgers at Nunzio's Dolce Vita (Up to 51% Off). Four Options Available.

Nunzio's Dolce Vita


Chef folds market-fresh ingredients into Italian classics, such as chicken cacciatore, and burgers made with kobe beef

$40 $20

Pizza, Appetizers, and Drinks for Two or Four at South Slope Public House (Up to 51% Off)

South Slope Public House

South Slope Public House

Tavern serving up crispy brick-oven pizza loaded with unique ingredients; shareable plates including wings, pretzel bites, and more

$45 $22

Italian Meal with Wine or Cocktails for Two or Four at Aleo (Up to 52% Off)


Aleo Restaurant

Local markets supply the ingredients for Mediterranean-inspired dishes, including chicken parmigiano, pumpkin ravioli, and veal scaloppini

$78 $39

$20 For $40 Worth Of Italian Cuisine


New Brunswick

$40 $20

Surf 'n' Turf Dinner with Wine for Two or Four at Portofino Restaurant (Up to 58% Off)

Portofino Ristorante

City Island

An Italian appetizer and dessert bookend a main course of Maine lobster tail and sirloin steak

$223.85 $99

$20 Italian Food for Two at Maria Restaurant ($40 Value)

Maria Restaurant

Sheepshead Bay

Restaurant with 80 years of history serves up traditional Italian pastas and entrees, such as chicken cacciatore and penne alla vodka

$40 $20

Italian Cuisine for Two for Four at Suzie's Starlight Lounge & Restaurant (Up to 54% Off)

Suzie's Starlight Lounge & Restaurant


An elegant setting serves classic Italian staples beneath a starlit ceiling

$75 $35

Pizza and Italian Food for Dine-In, Take-Out, or Delivery from Fratello's Pizzeria and Trattoria (Up to 52% Off)

Fratellos Pizzeria and Trattoria

Upper Vailsburg

An expansive menu features everything from lasagna, eggplant parmesan, and shrimp fra diavolo to paninis, pizza, and wings

$20 $12

One, Two, or Three Large Pizzas with Up to Five Toppings and Sides at Papa John's (Up to 71% Off)

Papa John's

Multiple Locations

Hand-tossed pizzas slathered with sauce made from vine-ripened, California-grown tomatoes

$68.50 $19.99

One or Two 16" Large Pizzas at Pronto Pizza (Up to 50% Off)

Pronto Pizza

Southern Brooklyn

Family-owned eatery handcrafts dough for thin-crust and deep-dish pizzas

$20 $11

Dinner and Drinks for Two or Four at 900 Park (Up to 45% Off)

900 Park

Morris Park

This upscale, second-floor Italian restaurant serves dishes such as seafood pastas, brick-oven pizzas, and veal chops with brandy sauce

$70.85 $39

Italian Picnic in the Park for Two or Four from Pappardella (Up to 58% Off)


Upper West Side

Head over to Central Park for a picnic complete with Pappardella’s antipasti, sandwiches, and desserts

$90 $39

Italian Dinner for Two or Four with Appetizers, and Entrees at Alfredo 100 (Up to 51% Off)

Alfredo 100


Manhattan outpost of the Roman restaurant that invented fettuccine alfredo serves five takes on the dish, as well as other Italian classics

$108 $54

Italian Meal for Two or Four with Appetizers and Fountain Drinks (Up to 56% Off)

Matese Pizzeria Ristorante


Plates of calamari share table space with shrimp-parmigiana hero sandwiches, baked shells with ricotta & veal picatta in casual pizzeria

$56.25 $25

Italian Food at Palazzo Restaurant (Up to 45% Off). Two Options Available.

Palazzo Restaurant

Palazzo Restaurant

Pork milanese, chicken porcini, spaghetti vongole, and other Italian classics at this authentic Montclair mainstay

$40 $22

$15 For $30 Worth Of Casual Dining



$30 $15

Select Local Merchants

  • Antonio's Brick Oven Pizza
    Known for its casual and fun atmosphere, Antonio's Brick Oven Pizza serves up the best pizza in town. Watching your diet? Stay on track at Antonio's Brick Oven Pizza, a local restaurant with gluten-free and low-fat options. Little guys and gals will also love dining at this pizzeria, which offers a family-friendly environment (and menu). Antonio's Brick Oven Pizza is the perfect spot to enjoy a great meal outside (weather permitting). Antonio's Brick Oven Pizza has a large dining room, making it easy to seat large parties. Up for grabs (and free of charge) is Antonio's Brick Oven Pizza's wifi. Comfort is prioritized at Antonio's Brick Oven Pizza, and guests are encouraged to come as they are. If you need to feed a big crowd, Antonio's Brick Oven Pizza also offers catering services for parties and get-togethers. This pizzeria will bring your food right to your doorstep if you prefer to make it a night in, or swing by the pizzeria yourself to carry out your meal. Street and lot parking is simple near Antonio's Brick Oven Pizza. Bicyclists will also find lots of space to safely lock up their bikes. An average meal at Antonio's Brick Oven Pizza will set you back about $30. Don't stress over planning a fancy dinner. Keep it fun and casual with a fresh, handmade pizza from Antonio's Brick Oven Pizza. Not all pizzas are made the same. For a quality pie that packs in all the delicious flavors you love, be sure to stop by Antonio's Brick Oven Pizza.
    Read More
    Metuchen, NJ US
  • Novita Bistro & Lounge
    Big tastes abound at Novita Bistro and Lounge, and Italian-fare enthusiasts can't stop talking about the five-star menu. Take a peek at the drink menu here, and make sure to sample something off the list. For your next big bash, consider hosting at Novita Bistro and Lounge, a great space for big groups with a private room to boot. Novita Bistro and Lounge is the perfect spot to enjoy a great meal outside (weather permitting). Wireless Internet access is just a click away at Novita Bistro and Lounge. Planning a special night? Call ahead to reserve a table. Business casual attire is acceptable, so guests can let go of the "dress to impress" standard. Call Novita Bistro and Lounge for catering if you have a big event coming up. You can also grab your grub to go. Store your car on the street or in a nearby lot at Novita Bistro and Lounge. Store your bike at one of the many racks outside of Novita Bistro and Lounge. If you go out for a nice meal, it doesn't need to cost $100, come treat yourself at Novita Bistro and Lounge. At Novita Bistro and Lounge, you can pay with Visa, MasterCard, Discover, American Express or any other major credit card. Highly regarded, the Italian food at Novita Bistro and Lounge is perfect for diners looking for a nice meal out. When you're ready to take a break for lunch, head over to Novita Bistro and Lounge and indulge in some tasty Italian dishes.
    Read More
    Metuchen, NJ US
  • Joey D's Pizzeria
    Load up on toppings or opt for a simple slice of cheese at Joey D's Pizzeria, Metuchen's classic pizza venue. Whether rocking a gluten-free lifestyle or looking for something low-fat, this place will serve you just what you need. You can also serve food from Joey D's Pizzeria at your next party — the pizzeria offers catering. Don't want to go out tonight but still want great food? Order takeout or delivery from this pizzeria. Don't fret! Parking options are readily available near Joey D's Pizzeria. Make use of the safe and efficient bike parking at Joey D's Pizzeria. For great dishes that fall smack dab in the middle when it comes to price, Joey D's Pizzeria is a reasonable option for diners of different budgets. All major credit cards are accepted, including Visa, MasterCard, Discover, and American Express. Find your sweet (or savory) spot at Joey D's Pizzeria, where you can opt for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. A tasty pizza form Joey D's Pizzeria is perfect for any of your upcoming casual gatherings.
    Read More
    Metuchen, NJ US
  • Torino 2
    For a satisfying meal that will have you reaching for the olive oil, Torino 2 is an Italian restaurant worth trying. Torino 2 will keep those with dietary needs happy with a menu filled with gluten-free and low-fat items. The patio seating at Torino 2 is perfect for those warm summer days. Bring your favorite furball along to Torino 2 — it has a dog-friendly policy and keeps its doors open to pooches. Diners who appreciate a no-frills environment come to Torino 2 in jeans and a hoodie. If you need to get somewhere fast, the restaurant also serves up grub to go. This dining establishment is located near hassle-free parking options. At Torino 2, you can ease your appetite and please your pocketbook the menu offers a selection of mid-priced, budget-friendly meals. So get ready to discover all the best flavors of Italy under one roof at Torino 2.
    Read More
    Metuchen, NJ US
  • What's the Scoop
    When you're ready for dessert, What's The Scoop's ice cream will hit the spot. Bring the whole family to this ice cream shop, where kiddos are welcomed with open arms. Be sure to check out What's The Scoop's outdoor seating when the climate is right. The noise level can often drown out conversation, so make sure your party is prepared to speak up. You can call it in, then carry it out. What's The Scoop's diners can park in a nearby lot or on the street. Prices are rock bottom at What's The Scoop, so load up on snacks and treats. Whether you're hungry first thing in the morning or prefer to eat a little later, What's The Scoop is conveniently open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. So when the temperatures rise, stop by What's The Scoop and cool off with some delicious ice cream.
    Read More
    Metuchen, NJ US
  • La Rosa's Pizza
    La Rosa's Pizza serves up hot and delicious pizza in a casual dining environment. Children are more than welcome to dine at this pizzeria, where there's something for everyone on the menu. This pizzeria lets you stop by or stay home for your food. You can also serve food from La Rosa's Pizza at your next party — the pizzeria offers catering. La Rosa's Pizza provides easy access to an adjacent lot. Store your bike at one of the many racks outside of La Rosa's Pizza. Meals at La Rosa's Pizza are affordable, with the average tab amounting to about $30 per person. So head over to La Rosa's Pizza, where you can sit down to a delicious pizza in a relaxed, casual setting. When you need a good meal in a flash, grab a pizza from the highly-rated La Rosa's Pizza.
    Read More
    Metuchen, NJ US