Italian Restaurants in Seaford, NY

Two Frozen Pizzas or Two Brooklyn Squares at Brooklyn Square Pizza (Up to 39% Off)

Brooklyn Square Pizza


Square sicilian-style pizzas baked to golden finish for dine-in or takeout; frozen pizzas available for takeout

$18.50 $12

Italian Cuisine for Dinner at AcQua Restaurant (Up to 42% Off). Four Options Available.

AcQua Restaurant


Waterfront restaurant serves family-style Italian meals such as white-clam linguini, veal marsala, eggplant parmigiana, and lobster ravioli

$60 $35

Italian Food at La Piazzetta Cafe II (Up to 46% Off). Three Options Available.

La Piazzetta Cafe II

East Meadow

Neapolitan and Sicilian-style pizzas with gluten-free crusts, and more than 35 traditional and baked pasta dishes

$35 $19

$19 for $30 Worth of Italian Cuisine at Umberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Umberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant


Restaurateurs with nearly 50 years in business craft specialty pizzas, salads, and elegant Italian entrees

$30 $19

Upscale Italian Food and Drinks at Passione (Up to 50% Off). Three Options Available.

Passione Restaurant

Carle Place

Gourmet pizzas, seafood entrees, and classic Italian pastas served in an elegant dining room with golden curtains and sparkling chandeliers

$40 $20

"Zagat"-Rated Coal-Fired Brick-Oven Pizza at Grimaldi's Pizzeria (Up to 50% Off). Three Options Available.

Grimaldi's Pizzeria

Garden City

Thin-crust pizzas with handmade mozzarella, fragrant tomato sauce, and fresh toppings baked in coal-fired brick ovens

$20 $12

Italian Food and Drinks for Two or Four at Eatalia Family Style (50% Off)

Eatalia Family Style


Family-style pasta, pizza, and other Italian favorites made with farm-fresh ingredients and served in lively, welcoming atmosphere

$50 $25

Italian Dinner for Two or Four at Bravo! Nader (47% Off)

Bravo Nader


Twelve cozy tables are set with appetizers, soups, or salads, entrees such as veal parmesan or house-made gnocchi with pesto, and coffees

$50 $28

Italian Cuisine or Pizza and Wings Takeout Packages at Pomodorino Ristorante (Up to 48% Off).

Pomodorino Ristorante

West Hills

Brick-oven pizza with san marzano tomatoes and fresh basil, spaghetti with housemade meatballs, and lasagna with imported parmesan cheese

$30 $16

Pizza and Italian Food at Rocco's Amici Express (45% Off). Two Options Available.

Rocco's Amici Express

Miller Place

Expansive Italian-influenced menu features fried calamari, meatball heroes, veal francese, and specialty pies like the chicken marsala pizza

$20 $11

Italian Dinner or Lunch for Two or Four at Osteria Da Nino (Up to 44% Off)

Osteria Da Nino

Osteria Da Nino

Handmade pastas and unique proteins enhance rustic Italian dishes such as kale-and-spinach gnocchi, rabbit cacciatore, and seared branzino

$25 $15

Italian Food at Nick's Tuscan Grill (31% Off). Four Options Available.

Nick's Tuscan Grill


Menu includes lobster ravioli, sautéed lemon chicken, gorgonzola-crusted rib eye, and pizza with housemade meatballs

$30 $21

Wood-Fired Pizza and Iron-Skillet Pasta from Red Tomato Pizza (Up to 54% Off). Six Options Available.

Red Tomato Artisanal Pizza

East Norwich

Wood-fired margherita pizza made with fresh mozarella and extra virgin olive oil; pastas cooked in an iron skillet; sangria and dessert

$93 $45

Italian Food for Dine-In, or a Family Meal for Carryout at Plum Tomatoes Pizzeria Restaurant (Up to 47% Off)

Plum Tomatoes Pizzeria Restaurant

Plum Tomatoes Pizzeria Restaurant

Award-winning Italian eatery uses fresh ingredients, from broccoli to artichoke, to create gluten-free pastas, seafood, and pizza

$40 $22

Italian Food and Drinks at Frank and Maria's (40% Off). Two Options Available.

Frank and Maria's

Bay Shore

The shop’s meats, sausages, and charcuterie often find their way into the onsite Italian eatery’s pasta, entrees, paninis, and sandwiches

$10 $6

$15 for Italian Cuisine and Drinks at Junior's Pizza ($30 Value)

Junior's Pizza

Junior's Pizza

Thin, stuffed, and Sicilian- and grandma-style pizzas, plus veal parmigiana, manicotti, and other Italian classics

$30 $15

Dinner and Drinks for Two or Four at 900 Park (Up to 45% Off)

900 Park

Morris Park

This upscale, second-floor Italian restaurant serves dishes such as seafood pastas, brick-oven pizzas, and veal chops with brandy sauce

$70.85 $39

Italian Meal for Two or Four with Appetizers and Fountain Drinks (Up to 56% Off)

Matese Pizzeria Ristorante


Plates of calamari share table space with shrimp-parmigiana hero sandwiches, baked shells with ricotta & veal picatta in casual pizzeria

$56.25 $25

Italian Dinner for Two or Four at Matteo's Trattoria of Roslyn (Up to 27% Off)

Matteo's Trattoria of Roslyn

Roslyn Heights

Pair linguine and clams or veal chop Milanese with sips from an encyclopedic wine list at this upscale Italian eatery

$80 $60

Upscale Italian Dinner for Two or Four at Cala di Mare Italian Grill and Catering (45% Off)

Cala di Mare Italian Grill and Catering

Rockville Centre

Elegant restaurant and banquet hall serves a menu of Italian classics including stuffed pork chops and seafood risotto

$40 $22

Italian Lunch or Dinner for Two or More at Ornella Trattoria Italiana (Up to 40% Off). Two Options Available.

Ornella Trattoria Italiana

Ditmars Steinway

Regional Italian food including prosciutto di parma, penne with San Marzano tomato sauce, spaghetti carbonara, and salmone primavera

$50 $30

$15 For $30 Worth Of Casual Italian Dining

Bella Bambina's Pizzeria & Restaurant


$30 $15

Italian Food at Luciano's (Up to 50% Off). Four Options Available.


Colonial Heights

Plates of salmon, veal, chicken, and steak mingle with housemade pasta inside an eatery with live music and dancing on weekends

$40 $20

Pizza and Pasta for Dine-In or Carry-Out at Gino's of Northport (Up to 42% Off). Four Options Available.

Gino's of Northport

East Northport

Family-owned restaurant serves up Neapolitan and Sicilian style pizza, along with dishes like eggplant rollatini stuffed with ricotta

$25 $15

$20 For $40 Worth Of Italian Dinner Dining

Reno's Trattoria

Bryn Mawr

$40 $20

Italian Food at San Remo Ristorante Italiano (Up to 43% Off). Two Options Available.

San Remo Ristorante Italiano

Sanremo Italian Resturant

Italian eatery offers dishes of homemade pasta made with the freshest ingredients available and an impressive wine list

$30 $17

Italian Dinner for Two or Four at Enzo's Restaurant (Up to 50% Off). Four Options Available.



Homemade pasta and flavorful chicken and steak dishes decorate linen-topped tables at eatery with outdoor seating

$40 $20

$15 For $30 Worth Of Fine Italian Cuisine


Old Howard Beach

$30 $15

Pizza Meal for Two or Four or Chicken-Parmigiana Meal for Eight at Harrison Pizza and Pasta (Up to 58% Off)

Harrison Pizza and Pasta

Harrison New York

Pizza dinners placate tongues with one-topping pizzas, salad, and ziti; catered chicken parmigiana brings a backup of mixed salads

$78 $33

Italian Dinner for Two or Four with Wine at Vito’s of Port Jeff (Up to 50% Off)

Vito's of Port Jeff

Vito's of Port Jeff

Elvis impersonators and lounge singers entertain diners enjoying Old World Italian favorites and glasses of house wine

$75 $45

Select Local Merchants

  • Mario's Pizzeria
    Score your next slice at Mario's Pizzeria — this joint has pizza-lovers dishing out cream of the crop reviews. Gluten-free and low-fat is the name of the game at Mario's Pizzeria, where eating healthy, flavorful dishes is of utmost importance. Parents, bring your kids along to this pizzeria, where you'll find a family-friendly menu and ambience. Enjoy wifi here free of cost. Be sure to make reservations so you can get seated right away. If you need to feed a big crowd, Mario's Pizzeria also offers catering services for parties and get-togethers. You might have thought your order was a tough decision, but you still have one more. Delivery or carryout? Free parking is offered every day of the week at the lot near Mario's Pizzeria. If your preferred mode of transit is of the two wheel variety, you're in luck — there's tons of bike parking outside the pizzeria. Take a break from the kitchen without breaking the bank! Mario's Pizzeria will fill you up with top-notch fare that s modestly priced. If pizza is your all-time favorite, it's important to find a pie that's worth your while. With star-studded reviews and sky-high ratings, there's no better way to spend your time than eating some 'za at Mario's Pizzeria. Pizza lovers can't get enough of Mario's Pizzeria where the ratings are as hot as the pies, so come on down for a quick slice or two. Next time you're in the mood for a casual night out, be sure to stop for a delicious pizza at Mario's Pizzeria. So stop fantasizing about ordering pizza and call the team at Mario's Pizzeria to make that amazing pie a reality. Highly regarded, the Italian food at Mario's Pizzeria is perfect for diners looking for a nice meal out. Do you hear your stomach growling? Answer the call with a tasty Italian meal from Mario's Pizzeria.
    Read More
    Seaford, NY US
  • Cara Mia Restaurant
    Over-the-top ratings make up the menu at Cara Mia Restaurant, and hopeless romantics call this intimate Italian spot one of the tastiest in town. Cara Mia Restaurant will keep those with dietary needs happy with a menu filled with gluten-free and low-fat items. Find the perfect vintage to complement your meal — this restaurant offers a fine selection of wines, beers, and beyond. Your group can sit comfortably at Cara Mia Restaurant, a local restaurant. Sunny day plus appetite equals the perfect time to head to Cara Mia Restaurant. Access the Internet free of charge via Cara Mia Restaurant's complimentary wifi. Reserve a table ahead of time and avoid the lines. Cara Mia Restaurant promotes formal attire, so you can finally get some use out of your favorite, dressiest dress. Feed the gang at your next get-together with catering from Cara Mia Restaurant as well. Or, take your grub to go. Street parking is available, or, on busy nights, a nearby lot is another option for drivers. Cara Mia Restaurant offers a nice selection of mid-range cuisine, so you can expect a meal there to cost about $30 or less per person. AM, midday, and PM meals are served at the restaurant, but supper takes the cake for best in show. When you're looking for a romantic meal filled with rich Italian dishes, Cara Mia Restaurant is your answer. Visit Cara Mia Restaurant for great Italian food that is well worth the price. Next time you're in the mood for authentic Italian cooking, remember to try the delicious fare at Cara Mia Restaurant.
    Read More
    Seaford, NY US
  • Tarallo's Pizza
    Score your next slice at Tarallo's Pizza — this joint has pizza-lovers dishing out cream of the crop reviews. Great food is best enjoyed comfortably, so Tarallo's Pizza encourages less-than-fancy attire. It's been too long since you've had a great meal at home. Order takeout or delivery from this pizzeria and enjoy! Tarallo's Pizza prides itself in its delicious catering. Drive to lunch or dinner at Tarallo's Pizza and find easy parking in a lot close by or on the street. At Tarallo's Pizza, bikers can lock their bikes safely outside. Cash is the only payment method accepted by Tarallo's Pizza. With food so tasty, you'll want to have breakfast, lunch, and dinner here...and you can go right ahead as Tarallo's Pizza serves three meals a day. Smothered in piping hot cheese and toppings of your choice, the pies at Tarallo's Pizza come highly recommended by pizza connoisseurs. Not all pizzas are made the same. For a quality pie that packs in all the delicious flavors you love, be sure to stop by Tarallo's Pizza.
    Read More
    Seaford, NY US
  • Formaggio Restaurant
    Whether you are looking for a slice of pizza or a whole pizza pie, Seaford's Formaggio Restaurant offers a wide variety of pizza types and sizes. Both low-fat and gluten-free menu items are offered at Formaggio Restaurant. Access the Internet free of charge via Formaggio Restaurant's complimentary wifi. Take it nice and easy at Formaggio Restaurant, where casual dress is the rule of the day. You might have thought your order was a tough decision, but you still have one more. Delivery or carryout? Bring the Formaggio Restaurant's great food to your place. Diners at Formaggio Restaurant will love the free parking nearby. Travel by bike to Formaggio Restaurant and store your bike at a nearby rack. Prices tend towards the moderate side, with the average tab at Formaggio Restaurant running under $30 per person. Convenience is essential at Formaggio Restaurant, and food is served from morning until night. If you need a quick and easy dinner option, head on over to Formaggio Restaurant and pick up a pizza pie.
    Read More
    Seaford, NY US
  • Za Late Night Pizzeria
    Hungry? Get ready to lick your plate clean at Za Late Night Pizzeria in Seaford. Healthy fare, including some vegan options, is also featured on Za Late Night Pizzeria's menu. This restaurant is a terrific spot for families to gather with its kid-friendly ambience and menu. Between the music and the crowds, Za Late Night Pizzeria's noise levels can be intense. Za Late Night Pizzeria is completely informal — dress as you see fit (and are most comfortable). It's been too long since you've had a great meal at home. Order takeout or delivery from this restaurant and enjoy! There is parking close to the restaurant. Za Late Night Pizzeria offers outdoor bike racks for cyclists. Frugal foodies will especially love the prices at Za Late Night Pizzeria, with a meal typically hovering under the $15 mark.
    Read More
    Seaford, NY US
  • Gino's of Seaford
    Gino's of Seaford touts itself not only as a familiar pizzeria, but a trattoria, a traditional term for a friendly, slightly informal restaurant serving rustic Italian cuisine. Walk in, and you'll find just that, with lunch crowds enjoying slices of margherita pizza on the storefront-side barstools, and a dining area in the back flooded with warm light and decorated with black-leather seats and red carnations at each table. Meanwhile, the near-encyclopedic menu of pastas, pizzas, and appetizers includes favorites like spicy mussels marinara fra diavolo, creamy fettucini carbonara, and, of course, pizzas, made with either a thin, chewy neapolitan–style crust or a hearty Sicilian crust.
    Read More
    Seaford, NY US

Groupon Guide