From Our Editors
Bacon, cheese, pickles, lettuce, tomato, and onion crown the award-winning Butch burger, the nearly plate-sized signature item at Butch Cassidy's Cafe. Founded in April 1993 and named for Paul Newman and Robert Redford's classic film, the café tips its hat to other legends of the wild days with a menu steeped in Western references.
A reuben sandwich on rye pays homage to the Sundance Kid, a beef patty melt honors Calamity Jane, and a club sandwich name checks the Pinkertons, an agency still vying to make pink part of the rainbow. Other popular offerings include the Rio Grande nachos and Baggs Wyoming buffalo wings, and a low-carb menu highlights the kitchen's more health-conscious offerings.