Big Nick's Pizza Joint, New York

70 W 71st St., New York, NY 10023 Directions
Closed Merchant This place is closed.

Want something similar? See related deals

About Big Nick's Pizza Joint

  • Cuisine
    Pizza, Burgers, Hot Dogs, Diner, American
  • Meals
    Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner
  • Price
  • Attire
  • Alcohol
  • Parking
  • Delivery
  • Takeout
  • Reservations
  • Vegetarian Options
  • Gluten Free Options
  • Good For Kids
  • Good For Groups


Report | 3 years ago
Decent pizza
Report | 5 years ago
Nick’s is under new ownership as of late winter 2018. The minor renovations make the atmosphere a little brighter, but they’re still working on their customer service, creating that neighborhood feel & securing a liquor license. As of now (May 1) it’s BYOB. Pizza was good but not quite as good as before. We’ll return to this old neighborhood joint at some point to hopefully see improvements.
Report | 5 years ago
waited too long to get food. food is not that great. Service was ok. Nothing to scream about. Pastrami was cooked crispy and should not be like that. should be juicy. Also my chix parm was hard and not juicy. not the best that it once was apparently.
Report | 5 years ago
an oasis in the City; feel like you are in a country lodge. pleasant staff, lots of choices for pizza and burgers. may it continue for a long time to come.
Report | 5 years ago
This place never disappoints. Great comfort food. Wait staff always attentive and pleasant.
Report | 5 years ago
Had their burgers in the past and they were great. This time, subpar. My girlfriends whole wheat pizza with spinach was lousy in my opinion...although she liked it.
Report | 5 years ago
Love their pizza
Report | 5 years ago
Not quite worth it all. For a pizza joint, they have awesome sounding options, it the quality of their food isn’t worth the asking prices. The garlic knots were hard and weren’t really garlicky at all and the spicy waffle fries seemed over cooked and weren’t spicy at all. If you want a burger, it’s just the patty and the bun unless you want to pay additional to even just add lettuce and tomato
Report | 5 years ago
Big Nick has been around the West side of NYC forever. Biggest selection of anything you want and available at all hours. A great addition to the neighborhood - and so reasonably priced and GOOD!! Always good service and great pizza too.
Report | 6 years ago
I was a bit disappointed, the food was ok tasting but the quality wasn't very fresh. I had an order of fried calamari, they were very dark and look like they were fried once too many times. The calzone and rolls were also very hard, the bread was almost like eating croutons. I was really hoping this place would be good.

About this Business

Big Nick's Pizza and Burger Joint, a family-owned eatery, has slung pies and beef patties on the Upper West Side since 1962. Owner Jimmy Galanopolous slays appetites with a copious menu that encompasses breakfast classics as well as authentic Italian and Greek cuisine. Patrons populate cozy booths amid the long dining area's exposed-brick walls and wood-grain tables as handsome as George Clooney in a tuxedo made of mustaches until the wee hours. 4 a.m. crowds can chomp on both evening- and morning-themed menu items such as buttermilk pancakes, sweet-potato fries, giant hot dogs, and eggplant-parmigiana hot subs.

Explore Nearby
Big Nick's Pizza Joint

Groupon has verified that the customer actually visited Big Nick's Pizza Joint.