Spicy's Barbecue Restaurants, Riverhead

A mixture of mustards, vinegars, and plenty of heat, Spicy's Barbecue Restaurants' signature sauce might look a little different than a typical barbecue blend, but it's the heart and soul of the restaurant. Their sandwiches are smothered with it, their chicken dinners serve it as a side for dipping, and hardcore-fans can even take the sauce home by the pint. But fear not, mild-loving eaters—even those who can't take the heat can find something to love at Spicy's, such as their flavorful seafood platters or thick homemade chili.