Michael Anthony's Pizza

Italian Restaurant
2425 Middle Country Rd., Centereach, NY 11720 2425 Middle Country Rd., Centereach Directions
This place has not been rated by customers.
73% of 30 customers recommended
This place is closed.

Want something similar? See related deals

About this Business

  • Cuisine
    Pizza, Italian, American, Cafe, Healthy
  • Meals
    Lunch, Dinner
  • Price
    <$15
  • Cuisine
    Pizza, Italian, American, Cafe, Healthy
  • Meals
    Lunch, Dinner
  • Show More
  • Attire
    Casual
  • Parking
    Lot
  • Delivery
    Yes
  • Takeout
    Yes
  • Reservations
    No
  • Gluten Free Options
    Yes
  • Catering
    Yes
  • Good For Groups
    Yes
  • Show Less

Tips

14 Tips
Verified
Report | 3 years ago
Service sucked .didnt have numerous items on menu .spaghetti sauce was gross and meatball were discusting.baked clams tasted like bad fish. then wouldnt let us order off surf and turf because we were using groupon.horrible experiance.
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 3 years ago
Great big portions . Waitress was nice place looked cleaned. Chicken parm was great
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 3 years ago
we ordered an entree and a slice of pizza. they originally didn't want to serve pizza in the dinning area. then when we split our 2 meals with each other, they charged a plate sharing fee. 2 people, 2 meals, and a plate sharing fee? Then they didn't want to accept the groupon because we order pizza, which isn't a dinner. The manager allowed it, but the plate sharing fee was still charged. The food was great, but I don't know if we would go back with those conditions.
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 3 years ago
Unfortunately the waitress/owner is extremely unprofessional and rude to the customers..Service is slow. Beware of gratuities being added onto your bill not just for parties greater than 7.Increased charges for pizza eaten in the dinning room and for the pizza itself. Also bring cash, can only charge a minimum of $20 on a credit card. Because I had a groupon and had $10 remaining after my voucher plus a tip. Could have been $16, she wouldn't budge and I didn't have cash on me. The owner/waitress embarrassed me in front of all my friends. According to others this isn't the first time either..
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 3 years ago
Your chef is excellent the food was amazing. Unfortunately, one of your owners/waitress' killed the experience by her unprofessionalism. She got in an 11 yr olds face for touching a table arrangement rather than saying something to the parent. Went ahead and removed all the arrangements from the table, even on the adult table. I had a groupon worth $15 and had a balance of $10 remaining on my bill. In front of all my friends she told me it was a minimum of $20 to charge. It would have been $16 with the tip. I had no other form of payment with me. She expected me to leave the restaurant and get cash? You make an exception here for the customer. My friend had to pay for me. Will never go back.
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 3 years ago
Excellent food and service
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 3 years ago
Great food and family owned! Also attention to detail for those who have special dietary needs! Thank you!
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 4 years ago
My husband tried the surf and turf dish and the steak tasted fishy. The pasta dishes are great though. The waitress is very nice.
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 5 years ago
Friendly staff, great food. I came here because of the Groupon, but I will be back!
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 5 years ago
Good food
Was this helpful?

From Our Editors

Cooks at Michael Anthony’s Pizza kick out authentic Italian favorites such as chicken, veal, and seafood dishes as well as pasta and pizza. Breaded cutlets of chicken or veal parmigiana overflow with layers of tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, while the broiled shrimp oregenata comes dressed in rich helpings of garlic and lemon. Pastas such as penne, rigatoni, and six-cheese pasta purses are prepared with sun dried tomatoes, prosciutto, and vegetables tossed in cream sauces or baked with sausage and peppers. The kitchen also kicks out pizzas, including a gluten-free variety, as well as American dishes such as chicken cordon bleu and NY strip steaks. On Friday nights, guests can enjoy live entertainment while they dine.

Explore Nearby
Michael Anthony's Pizza

Groupon has verified that the customer actually visited Michael Anthony's Pizza.