Main menu Open search menu

Smith Island Baking Company

Bakery
27930 Peach Orchard Road, Easton, MD 21601 27930 Peach Orchard Road, Easton Directions

Tips

250
791 Tips
Verified
Report | 5 days ago
Great selection. Easy to order.
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 22 days ago
Everyone enjoyed this cake as dessert Christmas Day. Even family who rarely eat dessert, ate a piece of this and requested a piece to go.
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 24 days ago
Delicious cake but pricey.
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | a month ago
Best cakes ever. And I enjoyed the cake bites as well.
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | a month ago
These cakes are amazing! I highly recommend Smith Island Baking Company.
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | a month ago
Hands down, the most delicious cake we have ever ordered. Whole family agreed and we are now hooked. Already ordered Red Velvet for Xmas and plan on the strawberries and cream for a February birthday. We had the caramel Creme and it was to die for!
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 2 months ago
I was attempting to use a second Groupon and it will not confirm the order. I cannot get anyone at Groupon to reply to my inquiry and Smith Island is closed until Monday. One would think with the impending holidays, the cake co. would have someone available over the weekends to take calls or emails. I ordered a cake earlier this year and wasn't exactly thrilled with it. It was the peanut butter chocolate cake but I am going to try once more only using them as gifts.
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 2 months ago
The cakes were expensive, and shipping cost were outrageous. I have another Groupon I was going to gift but won't because it's such a terrible deal. I'm pretty upset that a bought this Groupon and might never use the sight again.
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 2 months ago
Although my wishes were to send two cakes to men serving our country - I was not able to do it online. So I called the order in to find out this may not be the best item to send to an FBO. Apparently it goes USPS and can take up to two weeks. So Plan B for those worthy people. So I order two cakes for family members in the mid west for the Holidays. Everyone, including myself, love these cakes.
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 2 months ago
This is the second time I am giving my opinion of this business. Today I received the small and I mean small cake from Smith Island Baking Co. This cake measures barely six inches across and not very high. No wonder this business doesn't identify the size of their cakes other then small and large because I think they would get a lot less sales on your Groupon site. I do business with other sites as AvidsDeals, Local Flavor etc. and never was ripped off like this.
Was this helpful?

From Our Editors

Maryland’s official state dessert is the Smith Island Cake. This delicacy brims with homemade layers of goodness and 200 years of tradition. In the 1800's, watermen's families baked cakes for their hubbies’ oyster-fishing journeys. To help the treats withstand the waves, they iced them with fudge as sweet and sturdy as a drawbridge made of candy canes. Fast-forward to 2009, at a market 50 miles from Smith Island’s shores. Brian Murphy, a recent graduate of the Wharton School, was shopping for a birthday cake for his mother. He chose a Smith Island Cake, and the rest is history. He’d always envisioned himself as a commodities trader, he began to think like an entrepreneur. Before long, he founded the Smith Island Baking Company, a business that handcrafts Smith Island cakes and ships them around the world. The bakery’s signature creation, the chocolate Smith Island cake, teems with thin layers of yellow cake and fudge that National Geographic has deemed “an architectural marvel.” Under his leadership, the venture has grown to incorporate myriad other confections such as chocolate fudge the best ice cream on the planet.

Explore Nearby
Smith Island Baking Company

Groupon has verified that the customer actually visited Smith Island Baking Company.