Request a Deal

Love this business? The more people who sign up, the more likely we are to get a deal.

4 signed up for this.

About this business

  • Cuisine
    Bagels, Cafe, Bakery, Donuts, Coffee
  • Meals
    Breakfast

Tips

250

Please check your tip for inappropriate content.

You have already submitted a tip for this merchant. Please reload the page.

You have already submitted too many tips. Please wait and try again later.

There was an unexpected error. Please reload the page and try again.

Kim D.
Verified
Report | 8 months ago
Love Bagel Jays!!!
Patricia S.
Verified
Report | 8 months ago
You get charged tax on your purchase!
Beatrice A.
Verified
Report | 8 months ago
Great service, clean surroundings, fresh food, large menu, plenty of tables inside & a few outside. Would definitely visit again.
deb b.
Verified
Report | 8 months ago
We'll be back! Great selection of fresh made sandwiches & salads. Very clean and excellent customer service!
Wendy M.
Verified
Report | 9 months ago
My favorite is the Downtowner sandwich.
Meaghann
Verified
Report | 9 months ago
Tuna melt on Everything Bagel... best flavor ever. I get one once a week. Also the breakfast sandwich with egg and cheese is the highest quality eggs around for fast food. Love Love Love Bagel Jays.
dianne w.
Verified
Report | 9 months ago
always great
LINDA B.
Verified
Report | 9 months ago
Food was fresh and good and the service by the owner was excellent.
Dino J.
Verified
Report | 10 months ago
Wish there was one in Niagara Falls, NY
Cynthia F.
Verified
Report | 10 months ago
Best bagels outside of NYC!
Showing 1-10 of 49 tips
Show 10 more tips

From Our Editors

Like Prometheus stealing fire from the gods to give it to humankind, the founders of Bagel Jay's Bakery and Cafe brought bagels to Western New York in 1976. Since then, owner Bagel Jay has been crafting circular standbys with a menu of freshly baked bagels paired with savory deli meats. Diners dress their hearth-baked bagel with cream-cheese shmears of scallions, vegetable, and cinnamon honey, or construct sandwiches of sliced roasted turkey, hot corned beef, or ham. A steaming cup of Jakee's Java and a breakfast bagel with bacon and cheese help jump-start the morning, and classic tuna salad fortifies muscles after a long day of playing Jenga with railroad ties.

Is this your business?
Claim this page to add your promotions and content