Bay Burger, Sag Harbor

Although it's easy to describe what makes Bay Burger great—grade-A beef, house-baked buns sprinkled with kosher salt—it's best to watch the mouthwatering video of how it all gets made. You'll also see fresh lobster rolls, BLTs, and all-natural ice cream in the footage, all of which helped the eatery earn a spot on Thrillist's list of the top 5 burger joints in the Hamptons.

Liza and Joe Tremblay have been running Bay Burger since 2007, where they serve up classic American cuisine. They take fresh meat, ground in-house, along with handmade buns to their signature burgers, which can come in beef or fish variety topped with all the fixings or spinach and tartar sauce. Hot dogs, BLT's, and falafel pitas round out the menu along with sides of fries and tots.