Mystery Cafe

Diner
231 South College Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46202 231 South College Avenue, Indianapolis Directions
Closed Today Closed All Hours
+13176840668
Be the first to recommend this place!
83% of 483 customers recommended

Food doesn't get much better than Mystery Cafe. This Indianapolis staple is sure to satisfy your appetite no matter what your stomach wants.

About this Business

  • Cuisine
    Cafe
  • Hours
    Sun-Tue
    Closed
    Wed-Fri
    10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
    Sat
    10:00 AM - 7:00 PM
  • Cuisine
    Cafe
  • Show More
  • Attire
    Casual
  • Parking
    Street
  • Reservations
    Yes
  • Show Less

Tips

250
189 Tips
Verified
Report | 2 years ago
Be sure to join in the fun and play a part.
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 4 years ago
My husband and I really enjoyed our experience and would do it again. Dinner was good, service was good and the play was very funny! Enjoyed the audience participation.
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 4 years ago
Crackers or something on the table would be nice until dinner actually started !
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 4 years ago
Had a good time.
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 4 years ago
It was bad, and we found a sink drain plug in our salad bowl of all things
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 4 years ago
I think I expected more in terms of the mystery-- fun, but pretty lame.
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 4 years ago
Loved it!!! Will go again and have recommended to many!
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 4 years ago
Our tickets said the show started at 6:30pm, we were not seated till 6:45pm and didnt get a drink till 7:30pm. The show didnt even start till 8:00pm, an hour and a half after the ticket said. With having three children and havin to hire a babysitter for the night, this was highly unacceptable. Besides the show not starting on time our service was terrible. When we were able to get our waitresses attention it still took 30 minutes for us to get our drinks everytime. I will say the actors and the show itself was very enjoyable and they made what we thought was going to be a horrible Anniersary dinner very good.
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 4 years ago
Food was good. Mystery story line lame.
Was this helpful?
Verified
Report | 4 years ago
Loved it
Was this helpful?

From Our Editors

Spice up your week with a trip to Mystery Cafe in Indianapolis, and enjoy grub at the top of its game.

Heading to Mystery Cafe for a tasty meal? Drive on over and park in a matter of seconds.

Prices are a bit on the higher side, so this might be a good pick for a special night out.

Explore Nearby
Mystery Cafe

Sun-Tue
Closed
Wed-Fri
10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Sat
10:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Groupon has verified that the customer actually visited Mystery Cafe.