Italian Restaurants in New Providence, NJ

Italian Food for Dine-In at Eatalian Bistro (Up to 46% Off). Two Options Available.

Eatalian Bistro


BYOB eatery creates rustic and hearty Italian dishes such as lobster ravioli and shrimp, eggplant rollatini, and garlic white basil pizza

$35 $19

Italian Food for Two or Four at La Piazza Ristorante & Pizzeria Italiano (Up to 46% Off). Four Options Available.

La Piazza Ristorante & Pizzeria Italiano

Florham Park

This charming Italian eatery serves pizzas, pastas, and hot and cold sandwiches in a mural-bedecked dining room or on its outdoor patio

$25 $15

Italian Cuisine at Mario's Famous Pizza (Up to 52% Off). Four Options Available.

Mario's Famous Pizza


Menu includes clams casino, bruschetta pizza, gnocchi alfredo, chicken marsala, veal scampi, eggplant parmigiana subs, and proscuitto pitas

$50 $30

$32 for $50 Worth of BYOB Italian Food at Cara Mia, Available Sunday-Thursday

Cara Mia


This elegant family-owned BYOB restaurant serves refined Italian dishes like grilled branzino with balsamic reduction and seafood fettuccine

$50 $32

$32 for $50 Worth of Italian Food at Theresa's Restaurant

Theresa's Restaurant


Italian entrees from veal scaloppini to asiago-crusted chicken; pasta made in-house daily

$50 $32

Italian Food for Lunch, Dinner, or Takeout at Sofia's Italian Restaurant (Up to 50% Off). Two Options Available.

Sofia's Italian Restaurant

Sofia's Italian Restaurant

BYO wines complement traditional Italian entrees; perfect for date night

$50 $25

$15 for Speciality Pizza with Garlic Knots and Soda at The Pizza Shack ($25 Value)

The Pizza Shack

Upper Vailsburg

Pair garlic knots and soda with a speciality pizza like veggie, the ‘Grandma Special’, and The CBR with chicken, bacon and ranch

$25 $15

Italian Cuisine for Two on Sunday–Thursday or Friday–Saturday at Luna Rossa Ristorante (Up to 50% Off)

Luna Rossa Ristorante


Flounder piccata, handmade pastas, and other traditional Italian dishes from a family-run restaurant that’s honed their recipes for decades

$30 $15

Italian Food at Table 42 (Up to 40% Off). Two Options Available

Table 42


Fried calamari, chicken parmigiana, steak in brandy cream sauce, and other old-world staples

$20 $12

$15 For $30 Worth Of Italian Cuisine


Upper Vailsburg

$30 $15

Italian and Mexican Food for Dine-In or Takeout at Ultimate Famous Pizza (Up to 50% Off). Two Options Available.

Ultimate Famous Pizza

Ultimate Famous Pizza

Italian and Mexican favorites unite on a menu featuring four-cheese pizzas, meatball subs, tacos, and chimichangas

$25 $15

Italian Cuisine for Dine-In or Takeout at Mancino's Pizza & Italian Cuisine (Up to 50% Off)

Mancino's Pizza & Italian Cuisine


Brick-oven-baked pizzas served alongside house-made pastas in elegant dining room

$30 $15

Italian Cuisine and Drink for Two or Four at Noce77 (Up to 47% Off). Four Options Available.



From the merchant: Enjoy a romantic dinner for two or a special double date night while listening to beautiful music in a cozy atmosphere.

$30 $18

Italian Food at Palazzo Restaurant (Up to 45% Off). Two Options Available.

Palazzo Restaurant

Palazzo Restaurant

Pork milanese, chicken porcini, spaghetti vongole, and other Italian classics at this authentic Montclair mainstay

$40 $22

Italian Cuisine and Pizza at Nauna's Bella Casa (Up to 50% Off). Three Options Available.

Nauna's Bella Casa

Montclair Heights

Try Nauna’s Sunday gravy, served with a meatball, sausage, spare rib, and dollop of ricotta, or seafood, steak, or pizza

$30 $16

$15 For $30 Worth Of Italian Cuisine & Specialties

Benvenuti Italian Specialties & Catering


$30 $15

Pizza and Italian Food for Dine-In, Take-Out, or Delivery from Fratello's Pizzeria and Trattoria (Up to 52% Off)

Fratellos Pizzeria and Trattoria

Upper Vailsburg

An expansive menu features everything from lasagna, eggplant parmesan, and shrimp fra diavolo to paninis, pizza, and wings

$20 $12

Italian Cuisine for Dinner or Lunch at Pavinci Italian Grill (Up to 50% Off). Five Options Available.

Pavinci Italian Grill


Diners enjoy wine and Italian staples, such as gnocchi with pesto or scallops scampi, while soaking in gorgeous views of the adjacent lake

$30 $15

Pizza, Appetizers, and Drinks for Two or Four at South Slope Public House (Up to 51% Off)

South Slope Public House

South Slope Public House

Tavern serving up crispy brick-oven pizza loaded with unique ingredients; shareable plates including wings, pretzel bites, and more

$45 $22

Italian Cuisine at Silvio's Italian Villa (Up to 45% Off). Two Options Available.

Silvio's Italian Villa


Classic Italian dishes such as homemade ravioli and veal parmigiana share menu space with specialties such as filet mignon and rack of lamb

$40 $22

$10 For $20 Worth Of Italian Cuisine

Scaturro's Pizzeria & Cafe

Downtown Elizabeth

$20 $10

Italian Meal with Wine or Cocktails for Two or Four at Aleo (Up to 52% Off)


Aleo Restaurant

Local markets supply the ingredients for Mediterranean-inspired dishes, including chicken parmigiano, pumpkin ravioli, and veal scaloppini

$78 $39

$10 For $20 Worth Of Casual Dining


Southwestern Perth Amboy

$20 $10

Italian Food for Two or Four at Casa Turano Restaurant (Up to 47% Off)

Casa Turano Restaurant

Casa Turano Restaurant

Italian favorites as well as beer, wine, and cocktails served in a festive, familial atmosphere

$60 $32

Two Groupons, Each Good For a Large Pizza with Up to Three Toppings at Papa John's Pizza (46% Off). 7 Locations.

Papa John's Pizza

Multiple Locations

Hand-tossed pizzas slathered with sauce made from vine-ripened, California-grown tomatoes

$18.36 $9.99

Specialty Pizza, Oven-Baked Heroes, and Family-Style Pasta for Two or Four at TJ's Pizzeria Cafe (Up to 50% Off)

TJ's Pizzeria Cafe


Expansive Italian menu with specialty pizza and baked pasta also includes Angus rib eye cheesesteaks and oven-baked heroes

$25 $13

One, Two, or Three Large Pizzas with Up to Five Toppings and Sides at Papa John's (Up to 71% Off)

Papa John's

Multiple Locations

Hand-tossed pizzas slathered with sauce made from vine-ripened, California-grown tomatoes

$68.50 $19.99

Italian Lunch or Dinner for Two at Nanni Ristorante (Up to 43% Off)

Nanni Ristorante

Rochelle Park

Classic Italian restaurant serves favorites that range from manicotti to vermicelli primavera to spaghetti carbonara to broiled sea scallops

$30 $17

$20 For $40 Worth Of Italian Cuisine


New Brunswick

$40 $20

Italian Picnic in the Park for Two or Four from Pappardella (Up to 58% Off)


Upper West Side

Head over to Central Park for a picnic complete with Pappardella’s antipasti, sandwiches, and desserts

$90 $39

Select Local Merchants

  • Bellariva Trattoria - Pizzeria
    Take a break with a hot slice at Bellariva Pizzeria and Restaurant — this casual pizza joint is a favorite in New Providence's New Providence community. Specializing in gluten-free and low-fat fare, Bellariva Pizzeria and Restaurant has something that every stomach will enjoy. Tots and tykes will be right at home at this pizzeria with its kid-approved food and ambience. Large groups will appreciate Bellariva Pizzeria and Restaurant for its ability to seat them quickly. Enjoy the luxury of eating a delicious meal outside at Bellariva Pizzeria and Restaurant. Make a reservation to ensure your night goes according to schedule. Take it nice and easy at Bellariva Pizzeria and Restaurant, where casual dress is the rule of the day. Choose wisely. Wait at home for delivery or come into this pizzeria for carryout. Impress the visitors at your next gathering by calling in Bellariva Pizzeria and Restaurant for catering. Dining at Bellariva Pizzeria and Restaurant? Enjoy the easy and free parking in the lot next door. Want top-notch taste for less than top-dollar prices? Bellariva Pizzeria and Restaurant s mid-range cuisine is sure to satisfy on both fronts, where pennies stretch into perfectly seasoned platters. It's time you enjoyed a piece of pizza casually with your friends and family at Bellariva Pizzeria and Restaurant's restaurant. Fight for a great pizza pie by placing your order into Bellariva Pizzeria and Restaurant today.
    Read More
    New Providence, NJ US
  • Coppola Ristorante & Pizzeria
    Wrap up your busy week with a signature pizza or custom pizza at Coppola Ristorante and Pizzeria. Coppola Ristorante and Pizzeria will keep those with dietary needs happy with a menu filled with gluten-free and low-fat items. With its kid-friendly vibe, this pizzeria is a great spot for families to chow down. Coppola Ristorante and Pizzeria will be able to accommodate your large party. It's best to call ahead for a table as the pizzeria can get packed. Dress to impress before heading out — formal wear is a must here. Want to enjoy this pizzeria without the wait? Get it to go. Love the food so much you want to serve it at your next soiree? No problem — Coppola Ristorante and Pizzeria offers catering. The parking lot next to the restaurant offers quick and free parking, allowing drivers to park with ease. Coppola Ristorante and Pizzeria s fare is so good, you ll want to sample everything on the menu (and with its middle-of-the-road prices, you can!). So head on over to Coppola Ristorante and Pizzeria, where the pizzas are always hot and the ambiance is always cool. If you're looking for the hottest pies in town, you'll want to place your order in quick to Coppola Ristorante and Pizzeria.
    Read More
    New Providence, NJ US
  • Angelos
    With plenty of hearty Italian options, patrons of Angelos can enjoy delicious dishes that taste like the real deal. Between the music and the crowds, Angelos' noise levels can be intense. Can't stay long? Not a problem with the restaurant's take-out and delivery options. Drive to Angelos and find parking in the area. The average check at Angelos will stay below $30 per person, so it's a relatively affordable option. So pay the highly-rated Angelos a visit today and enjoy some tasty and classic Italian dishes.
    Read More
    New Providence, NJ US
  • Bacci Brick Oven Restaurant
    If fine food and refreshing beverages are on your to-do list, check out Bacci Brick Oven in New Providence. Fancy-schmancy attire is not required; in fact, guests are told to keep things casual. Bacci Brick Oven is known for serving great food, and they are able to serve it at your next event with their excellent catering. Easily accessible parking options are located near this dining establishment.
    Read More
    New Providence, NJ US
  • Di Maio Pizza & Restaurant
    If cooking isn't on the agenda, the perfect pie awaits you at Di Maio Pizza and Restaurant, where customers praise the pizza like no other. Healthy eaters will enjoy Di Maio Pizza and Restaurant, a local restaurant filled with healthy eats and gluten-free options. Take the kids along too — this pizzeria is a great spot for families with food that even little ones will love. At Di Maio Pizza and Restaurant, easily plan a night out with family, friends, coworkers and more — large parties are always welcome, and a private room is available for use. Enjoy wifi here free of cost. Don't get stuck waiting for a table — the pizzeria accepts reservations. No need to dress up for a trip to Di Maio Pizza and Restaurant — the casual pizzeria encourages laid-back attire. You can also serve food from Di Maio Pizza and Restaurant at your next party — the pizzeria offers catering. Can't stay at this pizzeria long? Pick up and go home. Free parking is offered every day of the week at the lot near Di Maio Pizza and Restaurant. Cyclists will also appreciate the plentiful space to lock up their bikes outside the pizzeria. At Di Maio Pizza and Restaurant, you can ease your appetite and please your pocketbook the menu offers a selection of mid-priced, budget-friendly meals. For the cheesiest, most delicious pie in town, pizza lovers claim that Di Maio Pizza and Restaurant is at the top of the list. When you don't feel like cooking dinner, pay Di Maio Pizza and Restaurant a visit and enjoy a hot and fresh pizza pie. See for yourself why Di Maio Pizza and Restaurant's Italian food is so highly considered. You don't need to fly to Rome to try all wonderful flavors of Italy. They're all under one roof at Di Maio Pizza and Restaurant.
    Read More
    Berkeley Heights, NJ US
  • Chimney Rock Inn
    What time is it? Time to grab one of American's favorite dishes at Chimney Rock Inn. For gluten-free dishes filled with flavor, head to Chimney Rock Inn. Drinks are also on the menu here, so diners can start the night off right. Both the young and the young-at-heart will dig the family-oriented menu and ambience at this restaurant. Wifi is on the house at Chimney Rock Inn, so bring along your tablet or laptop. Planning a special night? Call ahead to reserve a table. Comfort is prioritized at Chimney Rock Inn, and guests are encouraged to come as they are. The food is prepared and packaged, just waiting for your pickup. Chimney Rock Inn is known for serving great food, and they are able to serve it at your next event with their excellent catering. Take advantage of the quick and easy parking near Chimney Rock Inn. You'll also find plenty of safe spaces to lock up your bike if you prefer to cycle to the restaurant. No matter what you choose off the menu at Chimney Rock Inn, you won't completely break the bank with prices averaging around $30. AM, midday, and PM meals are served at the restaurant, but supper takes the cake for best in show. When you have a hunger craving, head over to Chimney Rock Inn and treat yourself to an American classic. Chimney Rock Inn has something for everyone with great American fare for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. So take your next meal to the next level and indulge in some great American eats at the highly-rated Chimney Rock Inn.
    Read More
    Gillette, NJ US