Italian Restaurants in South Orange, NJ

$32 for $50 Worth of BYOB Italian Food at Cara Mia, Available Sunday-Thursday

Cara Mia


This elegant family-owned BYOB restaurant serves refined Italian dishes like grilled branzino with balsamic reduction and seafood fettuccine

$50 $32

Italian Food for Two or Four at La Piazza Ristorante & Pizzeria Italiano (Up to 46% Off). Four Options Available.

La Piazza Ristorante & Pizzeria Italiano

Florham Park

This charming Italian eatery serves pizzas, pastas, and hot and cold sandwiches in a mural-bedecked dining room or on its outdoor patio

$25 $15

$15 For $30 Worth Of Italian Cuisine


Downtown Elizabeth

$30 $15

Italian Cuisine and Pizza at Nauna's Bella Casa (Up to 50% Off). Three Options Available.

Nauna's Bella Casa

Montclair Heights

Try Nauna’s Sunday gravy, served with a meatball, sausage, spare rib, and dollop of ricotta, or seafood, steak, or pizza

$30 $16

$15 For $30 Worth Of Italian Cuisine & Specialties

Benvenuti Italian Specialties & Catering


$30 $15

Italian Food at Palazzo Restaurant (Up to 45% Off). Two Options Available.

Palazzo Restaurant

Palazzo Restaurant

Pork milanese, chicken porcini, spaghetti vongole, and other Italian classics at this authentic Montclair mainstay

$40 $22

Italian Food for Two or Four at Casa Turano Restaurant (Up to 47% Off)

Casa Turano Restaurant

Casa Turano Restaurant

Italian favorites as well as beer, wine, and cocktails served in a festive, familial atmosphere

$60 $32

Italian Food and Burgers at Nunzio's Dolce Vita (Up to 51% Off). Four Options Available.

Nunzio's Dolce Vita


Chef folds market-fresh ingredients into Italian classics, such as chicken cacciatore, and burgers made with kobe beef

$40 $20

$10 For $20 Worth Of Casual Dining



$20 $10

Italian Cuisine and Drink for Two or Four at Noce77 (Up to 47% Off). Four Options Available.



From the merchant: Enjoy a romantic dinner for two or a special double date night while listening to beautiful music in a cozy atmosphere.

$30 $18

Italian Cuisine for Dine-In or Takeout at Mancino's Pizza & Italian Cuisine (Up to 50% Off)

Mancino's Pizza & Italian Cuisine


Brick-oven-baked pizzas served alongside house-made pastas in elegant dining room

$30 $15

One, Two, or Three Large Pizzas with Up to Five Toppings and Sides at Papa John's (Up to 71% Off)

Papa John's

Multiple Locations

Hand-tossed pizzas slathered with sauce made from vine-ripened, California-grown tomatoes

$68.50 $19.99

Italian Meal for Two or Four, Valid Sunday-Thursday or Any Day at Libretti's Restaurant (Up to 51% Off)

Libretti's Restaurant

Upper Vailsburg

Old World Italian pastas, steaks, and seafood prepared in homey neighborhood eatery established in 1950

$76.85 $45

Pizza and Italian Food for Dine-In, Take-Out, or Delivery from Fratello's Pizzeria and Trattoria (Up to 52% Off)

Fratellos Pizzeria and Trattoria

Upper Vailsburg

An expansive menu features everything from lasagna, eggplant parmesan, and shrimp fra diavolo to paninis, pizza, and wings

$20 $12

Italian Cuisine for Two or Four at Vitale's (Up to 48% Off)



Chefs prepare juicy steaks, tender chicken & seafood cutlets & pastas with creamy housemade sauces

$40 $22

$10 For $20 Worth Of Italian Cuisine


Upper Vailsburg

$20 $10

Italian Cuisine at Mario's Famous Pizza (Up to 52% Off). Four Options Available.

Mario's Famous Pizza


Menu includes clams casino, bruschetta pizza, gnocchi alfredo, chicken marsala, veal scampi, eggplant parmigiana subs, and proscuitto pitas

$50 $30

Italian Cuisine for Dinner or Lunch at Pavinci Italian Grill (Up to 50% Off). Five Options Available.

Pavinci Italian Grill


Diners enjoy wine and Italian staples, such as gnocchi with pesto or scallops scampi, while soaking in gorgeous views of the adjacent lake

$30 $15

Italian Food for Dine-In at Eatalian Bistro (Up to 46% Off). Two Options Available.

Eatalian Bistro


BYOB eatery creates rustic and hearty Italian dishes such as lobster ravioli and shrimp, eggplant rollatini, and garlic white basil pizza

$35 $19

$32 for $50 Worth of Italian Food at Theresa's Restaurant

Theresa's Restaurant


Italian entrees from veal scaloppini to asiago-crusted chicken; pasta made in-house daily

$50 $32

Casual Italian Food for Two or Four or More at Barilla Restaurants (52% Off)

Barilla Restaurants

Midtown Manhattan

Fresh, flavorful authentic Italian cuisine, including pizza, Barilla pasta dishes, and indulgent desserts, in a fast-casual setting

$25 $12

Weekday Italian Lunch with Wine for Two, Four, or Eight at Libretti's Restaurant (Up to 50% Off)

Libretti's Restaurant

Upper Vailsburg

Leisurely lunches unfold over glasses of wine, appetizers such as fresh clams on the half shell, and entrees such as scampi or veal piccata

$62.85 $35

Italian Cuisine for Dine-In, Takeout, or Delivery at Goodfella's Old World Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta (50% Off)

Goodfella's Old World Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta

Dongan Hills

Enjoy award-winning brick-oven pizzas and Italian entrees and pastas in a bistro setting or at home

$30 $15

Surf 'n' Turf Dinner with Wine for Two or Four at Portofino Restaurant (Up to 58% Off)

Portofino Ristorante

City Island

An Italian appetizer and dessert bookend a main course of Maine lobster tail and sirloin steak

$223.85 $99

Italian Cuisine for Dinner or Lunch at The Cake Lounge & Restaurant (Up to 52% Off). Five Options Available.

The Cake Lounge & Restaurant

Little Ferry

Chefs prepare a lineup of authentic Italian cuisine, including pastas and veal dishes, alongside custom cakes and inventive cocktails

$30 $15

$10 For $20 Worth Of Casual Italian Fare


Montclair Heights

$20 $10

$10 For $20 Worth Of Casual Dinner Dining


Botany Section

$20 $10

$15 For $30 Worth Of Italian Dinner Dining


North End

$30 $15

Italian Cuisine for Two or Four at Cucina 355 Ristorante Pizza (Up to 50% Off)

Cucina 355 Ristorante and Pizzeria


Menu includes linguini with shrimp and broccoli rabe, chicken marsala, veal parmigiana, loaded baked potato pizza, and italian hot dogs

$20 $12

Italian Food from Tommy Lasagna's Pizza & Pasta Company (Up to 47% Off). Two Options Available.

Tommy Lasagna's Pizza & Pasta Company

Montclair Heights

Menu of homestyle Italian favorites includes pastas made in-house and hand-tossed, new-york-style pizzas

$30 $16

Select Local Merchants

  • Bunny's Restaurant
    Deemed "pizza of the year" every year by Bunny's Restaurant's loyal fans, this deliciously-cheesy pizza will have you reaching for seconds, thirds, and even fourths. Swing by Bunny's Restaurant for a bite to eat or a beverage from the fully stocked bar. Take the kids along too — this pizzeria is a great spot for families with food that even little ones will love. Make the most of the warm summer months by dining outdoors in Bunny's Restaurant's beautiful outdoor seating area. Skip long waits and head to Bunny's Restaurant with your large group for easy seating. Crowds are boisterous at the pizzeria and the music is blaring, so get ready for a very loud night out. You can't reserve a table at Bunny's Restaurant, so be sure to show up early. Folks tend to dress down at Bunny's Restaurant, so keep comfort in mind when heading to the pizzeria. If you're hoping to make a smashing impression at your next soiree, you can also have Bunny's Restaurant cater for you. Turn your living room into a five-star restaurant with takeout or delivery from this pizzeria. Bunny's Restaurant's guests can take advantage of the easy street and lot parking options. When melted cheese and quality crust is all you can think about, it may be time for a hot slice or two. Experience pizza at its best when you order a pie from top-rated Bunny's Restaurant. Find out how many slices you can eat! Bunny's Restaurant's pizza comes with high ratings and a low-key vibe, so take your time enjoying your pie. For hot pizza and a cool atmosphere, be sure to stop in at Bunny's Restaurant. Bunny's Restaurant's pizza is oozing with delicious cheese and sauce, so make sure to pick one up on your way home.
    Read More
    South Orange, NJ US
  • Appian Way Catering & Restaurant
    Butter up your date with some star-studded Italian fare at Appian Way, and get cozy in its romantic City of Orange setting. Be sure to complete your meal at this restaurant with a drink from the restaurant's full bar. With plenty of room to go around, Appian Way also offers a private area perfect for large groups. Up for grabs (and free of charge) is Appian Way's wifi. Whether it's just you and a date or you're bringing the whole gang, it's best to call ahead and make a reservation. Comfort is prioritized at Appian Way, where business casual is the name of the (dress code) game. Appian Way will even bring the amazing food from their kitchen to yours. This restaurant offers carryout for your convenience. Drivers can access the parking lot next door. You can fill up on Appian Way's delicious fare without spending an arm and a leg — in fact, typical meals there run under $15. Easily charge your payment using one of many major credit card options. Critics award the most brownie points to the restaurant's dinner offerings, but breakfast and lunch are also available. Whether you're planning a first date or a fiftieth anniversary, Appian Way is just the place to share a classic Italian meal with the one you love. Appian Way's Italian food gets the highest price; come taste why! If you are looking for a new lunch or dinner spot, make your way over to Appian Way and fill up on Italian fare.
    Read More
    Orange, NJ US
  • Main Street South Orange
    Flavorful, five-star sauces fill the menu at Village Trattoria, and South Orange Village visitors will say it serves the best Italian fare in town. The perfect place to take the kids, dining out at this restaurant won't cost you a sitter. Lines can get long with no reservations, so be sure to plan for an early arrival. Don't spend time or money shopping for a new dinner outfit Village Trattoria's laid-back vibe accepts jeans, T-shirts, and everything in between. You can call it in, then carry it out. Throwing a big party? Count on Village Trattoria to provide top-notch catering with the same great dishes you love. At Village Trattoria, you can find nearby options for both street and lot parking. Cyclists will also appreciate the plentiful space to lock up their bikes outside the restaurant. Hitting the mid-range mark, Village Trattoria s prices are perfectly reasonable for food that goes above and beyond. Village Trattoria is the place to go if you're looking for quality and highly-rated Italian food. For a new take on Italian classics, make your way over to Village Trattoria and taste some great eats.
    Read More
    South Orange, NJ US
  • Giorgio's Ristorante
    Reserve a table for two! Giorgio's Ristorante specializes in intimate Italian cuisine for those looking to add some romance to dinner. Giorgio's Ristorante is making food that everyone loves. Taking it back to the high-calorie basics. Worried about taking a big group out for a night on the town? Giorgio's Ristorante has you covered with private rooms made for loud parties. On warmer days, you can take advantage of Giorgio's Ristorante's al fresco patio seating. Make a reservation to ensure your table is ready when you are. Giorgio's Ristorante tosses the jacket-and-tie dress code convention in favor of a more casual dining experience. Always five minutes behind schedule? Pick up your food to go instead. Catering is also available if you'd like to serve Giorgio's Ristorante's tasty dishes at your next party. Patrons can park in a lot near Giorgio's Ristorante or take advantage of the generous street parking. Taste the greatness Giorgio's Ristorante is serving up with meals around $30. Major credit cards — including Visa, MasterCard, Discover, and American Express — are accepted.
    Read More
    South Orange, NJ US
  • Domino's Pizza
    Craving pizza? Head on over to South Orange's Domino's Pizza for a tasty slice with a crust you can't resist. Whether you are looking for food low in fat or gluten-free, this restaurant is the place you want to eat. Bask in the sun and enjoy a fresh meal outside at Domino's Pizza. Crowds are boisterous at the pizzeria and the music is blaring, so get ready for a very loud night out. Domino's Pizza is completely informal — dress as you see fit (and are most comfortable). Take the comfort of your own home and add great grub from Domino's Pizza to create the perfect night. It's been too long since you've had a great meal at home. Order takeout or delivery from this pizzeria and enjoy! Don't leave the car at home when you come in. We'll give you one of the great spaces in our parking lot. And for free. Domino's Pizza offers outdoor bike racks for cyclists. A tasty pizza form Domino's Pizza is perfect for any of your upcoming casual gatherings.
    Read More
    South Orange, NJ US
  • Pirates Pizza
    Load up on toppings or opt for a simple slice of cheese at Pirate's Pizza, South Orange's classic pizza venue. This place will leave you feeling satisfied no matter what kind of dietary needs you have. Keep it casual at Pirate's Pizza — the pizzeria is laid-back and patrons dress accordingly. This pizzeria serves your food any way you like, delivered or carried-out. Pirate's Pizza can also cater your next party; call today for details. Many diners choose to drive to Pirate's Pizza, as there are numerous parking options nearby. Bike parking is quick and easy at Pirate's Pizza. For a decently-priced meal that s not too fancy, Pirate's Pizza hits the nail on the head. Before ordering just a generic box of pizza, re-think that decision and go with a pie above the rest from Pirate's Pizza.
    Read More
    South Orange, NJ US