Italian Restaurants in West Milford, NJ

Specialty Pizza, Oven-Baked Heroes, and Family-Style Pasta for Two or Four at TJ's Pizzeria Cafe (Up to 50% Off)

TJ's Pizzeria Cafe


Expansive Italian menu with specialty pizza and baked pasta also includes Angus rib eye cheesesteaks and oven-baked heroes

$25 $13

Pizzeria Fare for Dine-In at TJ's Pizzeria Cafe of Sussex (Up to 50% Off). Two Options Available.

TJ's Pizzeria Cafe of Sussex

Tj's Pizzeria

Dig into meaty pastas, hearty calzones, and custom and specialty pizzas

$25 $13

$10 For $20 Worth Of Casual Dining

Rookie's Restaurant, Pizzeria & Bar


$20 $10

Italian Cuisine for Dinner or Lunch at Pavinci Italian Grill (Up to 50% Off). Five Options Available.

Pavinci Italian Grill


Diners enjoy wine and Italian staples, such as gnocchi with pesto or scallops scampi, while soaking in gorgeous views of the adjacent lake

$30 $15

Italian Food and Burgers at Nunzio's Dolce Vita (Up to 51% Off). Four Options Available.

Nunzio's Dolce Vita


Chef folds market-fresh ingredients into Italian classics, such as chicken cacciatore, and burgers made with kobe beef

$40 $20

Italian Cuisine for Two on Sunday–Thursday or Friday–Saturday at Luna Rossa Ristorante (Up to 50% Off)

Luna Rossa Ristorante


Flounder piccata, handmade pastas, and other traditional Italian dishes from a family-run restaurant that’s honed their recipes for decades

$30 $15

Italian Cuisine at Mario's Famous Pizza (Up to 52% Off). Four Options Available.

Mario's Famous Pizza


Menu includes clams casino, bruschetta pizza, gnocchi alfredo, chicken marsala, veal scampi, eggplant parmigiana subs, and proscuitto pitas

$50 $30

Pizza and Italian Food for Dine-In, Take-Out, or Delivery from Fratello's Pizzeria and Trattoria (Up to 52% Off)

Fratellos Pizzeria and Trattoria

Upper Vailsburg

An expansive menu features everything from lasagna, eggplant parmesan, and shrimp fra diavolo to paninis, pizza, and wings

$20 $12

Italian Lunch or Dinner for Two at Nanni Ristorante (Up to 43% Off)

Nanni Ristorante

Rochelle Park

Classic Italian restaurant serves favorites that range from manicotti to vermicelli primavera to spaghetti carbonara to broiled sea scallops

$30 $17

$17 for $30 Worth of Italian Dinner at Limoncello Ristorante

Limoncello Ristorante


Chefs use the restaurant’s namesake lemon liqueur to flavor Italian dishes—from vetello benito veal to cheese ravioli with basil

$30 $17

$32 for $50 Worth of BYOB Italian Food at Cara Mia, Available Sunday-Thursday

Cara Mia


This elegant family-owned BYOB restaurant serves refined Italian dishes like grilled branzino with balsamic reduction and seafood fettuccine

$50 $32

Italian Food for Lunch, Dinner, or Takeout at Sofia's Italian Restaurant (Up to 50% Off). Two Options Available.

Sofia's Italian Restaurant

Sofia's Italian Restaurant

BYO wines complement traditional Italian entrees; perfect for date night

$50 $25

Italian Food at Palazzo Restaurant (Up to 45% Off). Two Options Available.

Palazzo Restaurant

Palazzo Restaurant

Pork milanese, chicken porcini, spaghetti vongole, and other Italian classics at this authentic Montclair mainstay

$40 $22

Italian Food for Dine-In at Eatalian Bistro (Up to 46% Off). Two Options Available.

Eatalian Bistro


BYOB eatery creates rustic and hearty Italian dishes such as lobster ravioli and shrimp, eggplant rollatini, and garlic white basil pizza

$35 $19

$19 for $30 Worth of Italian Cuisine and Drinks at Bensi


Multiple Locations

Each day the chefs hand-toss pizzas, blend homemade soups and salads and whip up housemade sauces to pour over made-to-order Italian cuisine

$30 $19

Pizza and Italian Food at 3 Brothers from Italy Pizza (40% Off). Two Options Available.

3 Brothers from Italy Pizza

Bromat Plaza

Casual family pizza joint serves up giant slices, subs, and classic bowls of Italian-American pasta favorites

$20 $12

$32 for $50 Worth of Italian Food at Theresa's Restaurant

Theresa's Restaurant


Italian entrees from veal scaloppini to asiago-crusted chicken; pasta made in-house daily

$50 $32

Brick-Oven Pizza, Drinks, and More at The Brick Fire Baked Pizza (Up to 44% Off

The Brick Fire Baked Pizza


Fresh pizza baked in a brick oven in a variety of styles, from margherita to nacho supreme

$30 $17

Italian Dinner at Alex's Italian Restaurant (Up to 46% Off). Two Options Available.

Alex's Italian Restaurant

The Waterfront

BYOB Eatery dishes out Italian food such as eggplant rollatini, gnocchi with salmon and fresh asparagus, veal milano, and PEI mussels

$40 $22

Two-Course Italian Lunch at Luka's Italian Cuisine (Up to 55% Off)

Luka's Italian Cuisine


Montenegro-born Chef Luka crafts Italian classics and signature dishes influenced by his continent-spanning culinary studies

$35.85 $17

Italian Cuisine and Drink for Two or Four at Noce77 (Up to 47% Off). Four Options Available.



From the merchant: Enjoy a romantic dinner for two or a special double date night while listening to beautiful music in a cozy atmosphere.

$30 $18

$15 For $30 Worth Of Italian Cuisine


Downtown Elizabeth

$30 $15

$17 for Two Three-Topping Pizzas of Any Size at Pizza Zone ($34 Value)

Pizza Zone


Create your own pizzas choosing from toppings such as salami, Italian sausage, green peppers, garlic, and cheddar cheese

$34 $17

$15 For $30 Worth Of Italian Cuisine & Specialties

Benvenuti Italian Specialties & Catering


$30 $15

Pizza or Pasta Meal for Two at Giovanni's Restaurant Pizzeria (Up to 40% Off). Four Options Available.

Giovanni's Restaurant Pizzeria


Laid-back eatery dishes out cuisine such as salmon over a broccoli wrap, chicken marsala, orecchiette pasta vodka sauce, salads, and pizzas

$36.45 $22

$12 for $20 for Dine-In, Carry Out, or Delivery from Pizza Stop.

My Pizza Stop


Pizzas topped with sauce and your choice of meats and veggies

$20 $12

Upscale Italian Dinner Cuisine and Drinks at Vicolo Ristorante (Up to 42% Off)

Vicolo Ristorante

Old Tappan

Enjoy house-made Italian pasta, chicken, veal, and seafood dishes at upscale eatery

$40 $23

Italian Cuisine for Two or Four at Cucina 355 Ristorante Pizza (Up to 50% Off)

Cucina 355 Ristorante and Pizzeria


Menu includes linguini with shrimp and broccoli rabe, chicken marsala, veal parmigiana, loaded baked potato pizza, and italian hot dogs

$20 $12

$20 For $40 Worth Of Italian Fine Dinner Dining


Briarcliff Manor

$40 $20

Italian Food from Tommy Lasagna's Pizza & Pasta Company (Up to 47% Off). Two Options Available.

Tommy Lasagna's Pizza & Pasta Company

Montclair Heights

Menu of homestyle Italian favorites includes pastas made in-house and hand-tossed, new-york-style pizzas

$30 $16

Select Local Merchants

  • Tony's Family Restaurant Pizza
    If you're searching for a quick and casual spot to grab some pizza in Hardyston Township's Hardyston, look no further than Tony's Family Restaurant Pizza. Drinks here are readily available, so you can enjoy a glass of red or try something new. The perfect place to take the kids, dining out at this pizzeria won't cost you a sitter. Shake off your workday and treat yourself to Tony's Family Restaurant Pizza's happy hour. Dance to the beat of a live DJ and show off your moves on the pizzeria floor. Weekends are busy at the pizzeria, so be prepared for longer wait times. Fancy-schmancy attire is not required; in fact, guests are told to keep things casual. Catering is also available if you'd like to serve Tony's Family Restaurant Pizza's tasty dishes at your next party. The food's ready when you are. Come on in or carry out. Dine at Tony's Family Restaurant Pizza and keep your car safely parked in a nearby lot. Make use of the luxurious bike racks at Tony's Family Restaurant Pizza. Meals at Tony's Family Restaurant Pizza are incredibly tasty and reasonably priced around $30. Paying with your major credit card is one payment option at Tony's Family Restaurant Pizza. The pizzeria's got you covered whether you're hungry for breakfast, lunch, or dinner, but die-hard fans always opt for an evening meal. Come spend a casual night out over a delicious pizza at Tony's Family Restaurant Pizza. Before ordering just a generic box of pizza, re-think that decision and go with a pie above the rest from Tony's Family Restaurant Pizza.
    Read More
    Hardyston Township, NJ US
  • Tony's Pizza & Pasta Restaurant
    Fans of Tony's Pizza and Pasta Restaurant make every night "pizza night" — reviews prove that this Hardyston hub sells steaming slices of five-star bliss. Tony's Pizza and Pasta Restaurant serves food that not only tastes great, but is low in fat and gluten-free. The pizzeria accepts reservations, so you can get around the busy crowd. Tony's Pizza and Pasta Restaurant goes easy on the dress code — business casual is expected, so no need to squeeze into your finest attire. For the nights you just want to stay in and cozy up, order in great takeout or delivery from this pizzeria. Through their catering service, Tony's Pizza and Pasta Restaurant can also set out a delicious spread for your next party. At Tony's Pizza and Pasta Restaurant, service is a priority. That why we provide parking spaces on site. Tony's Pizza and Pasta Restaurant s mid-range cuisine will please your pockets as well as your palate. Roni, sausage, and veggie are just a few of the delicious options at Tony's Pizza and Pasta Restaurant. Taste the shining reviews for yourself when you head to Tony's Pizza and Pasta Restaurant for a tasty pizza pie. If you're looking for the hottest pies in town, you'll want to place your order in quick to Tony's Pizza and Pasta Restaurant. For prime Italian fare, Tony's Pizza and Pasta Restaurant is one of the highest-rated restaurants around. You'll definitely be wowed by the A+ renditions of classic Italian dishes served up at Tony's Pizza and Pasta Restaurant.
    Read More
    Hamburg, NJ US
  • Vesuvio Pizzeria
    If cooking isn't on the agenda, the perfect pie awaits you at Vesuvio Pizzeria, where customers praise the pizza like no other. If gluten is something you try to avoid, check out the G-free menu at Vesuvio Pizzeria. Low-fat fare is also available for those keeping an eye on their diet. Skip long waits and head to Vesuvio Pizzeria with your large group for easy seating. The pizzeria can fill up quickly, so reservations are recommended. Vesuvio Pizzeria's guests are no strangers to casual clothing, and sneakers are spotted around every corner. You can also grab your grub to go. The pizzeria also offers catering if you want to bring the flavors of Vesuvio Pizzeria to your next party or event. With a parking lot adjacent to Vesuvio Pizzeria, you won't get stuck circling the block. If you don't want a night that will cost you an arm and a leg but you do want a delicious meal, come to Vesuvio Pizzeria. Breakfast, lunch, and dinner are all available at Vesuvio Pizzeria. Everyone's talking about Vesuvio Pizzeria. Find out why when you treat yourself to a delicious pizza pie. Not all pizzas are made the same. For a quality pie that packs in all the delicious flavors you love, be sure to stop by Vesuvio Pizzeria.
    Read More
    West Milford, NJ US
  • Frank's Pizza
    Find great food in a comfortable setting at Warwick's Frank's Pizza and Restaurant — pizza lovers flock to this Warwick joint. You can't go wrong with pizza or pasta, so take your time sampling the menu from start to finish. Little ones are free to make a mess at this pizzeria, where the whole family is invited to dine. At Frank's Pizza and Restaurant, business casual is the norm, so save your suit and tie for another day. Catering is also available if you'd like to serve Frank's Pizza and Restaurant's tasty dishes at your next party. With delivery and take-out options, you can enjoy this pizzeria's cooking from the comfort of your own living room. Diners that drive to dinner will find street parking readily available at Frank's Pizza and Restaurant's Main Street address. If cycling is more your speed, you'll find plenty of space to stash your bike outside the pizzeria. There's no need to spend a fortune on a delicious meal at Frank's Pizza and Restaurant — most prices are under $15. If you've had a long and hard week, come visit Frank's Pizza and Restaurant and enjoy a pizza in a casual atmosphere. No matter what type of pizza you are craving, Frank's Pizza and Restaurant has you covered.
    Read More
    Warwick, NY US
  • Momento II
    Momento II is serving you great Italian cuisine in an atmosphere you'll love. Life is all about choices, and they are not limited here with plenty of gluten-free and low-fat dishes. A night out deserves a drink to celebrate, and this restaurant has the perfect selection of beer and wine to go with your meal. Momento II's outdoor seating is available during the warmer months. Gather up your group of friends and head to Momento II, a local restaurant that has room for large groups. Whether it's just you and a date or you're bringing the whole gang, it's best to call ahead and make a reservation. If you're hoping to make a smashing impression at your next soiree, you can also have Momento II cater for you. Short on time? Don't wait for a driver — pick it up yourself. Parking is provided in a nearby lot, so diners can easily walk to and from their cars. Who s hungry for great grub at a reasonable rate? Momento II s yummy creations will leave a mark in your memory but not a dent in your pocketbook. The restaurant serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner, but it's the dinner menu that really draws the crowds. Ready to try all the best flavors of Italy? Check out the authentic dishes at Momento II.
    Read More
    West Milford, NJ US
  • Grappa Ristorante
    Grappa Ristorante is the perfect place for sweethearts to share a plate of pasta Bolognese. Specializing in gluten-free and low-fat fare, Grappa Ristorante has something that every stomach will enjoy. Drinks here are readily available, so you can enjoy a glass of red or try something new. Grappa Ristorante is the perfect spot to enjoy a great meal outside (weather permitting). Gather up your friends, coworkers or family members and head to Grappa Ristorante for a group meal. Reserve a table in advance and steer clear of long wait times. If you need to feed a big crowd, Grappa Ristorante also offers catering services for parties and get-togethers. For those in a hurry, the restaurant lets you take your meal or snack to go. Street parking is always accessible for those dining at Grappa Ristorante. Prices are a bit on the higher side, so this might be a good pick for a special night out. Whether you're planning a first date or a fiftieth anniversary, Grappa Ristorante is just the place to share a classic Italian meal with the one you love. You don't need a plane ticket to experience all the best flavors of Italy. They're all under one roof at Grappa Ristorante.
    Read More
    Warwick, NY US