Italian Restaurants in Sayville, NY


$19 for $30 Worth of Italian Cuisine at Umberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Umberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Plainview

Restaurateurs with nearly 50 years in business craft specialty pizzas, salads, and elegant Italian entrees

$30 $19

Pasta, Pizza, and Pasta-Pizza for Two or Four at Cafe Rosa Pizzaria (Up to 48% Off)

Cafe Rosa Pizzaria

Cafe Rosa Pizzaria

Pizzeria creates thin crust and stuffed crust pizzas that include novelty pies such as the baked ziti pizza filled with ricotta and penne

$20 $12

Upscale Italian Food and Drinks at Passione (Up to 50% Off). Three Options Available.

Passione Restaurant

Carle Place

Gourmet pizzas, seafood entrees, and classic Italian pastas served in an elegant dining room with golden curtains and sparkling chandeliers

$40 $20

Italian Dinner for Two or Four with Wine at Vito’s of Port Jeff (Up to 50% Off)

Vito's of Port Jeff

Vito's of Port Jeff

Elvis impersonators and lounge singers entertain diners enjoying Old World Italian favorites and glasses of house wine

$75 $45

Upscale Italian Dinner for Two or Four at Cala di Mare Italian Grill and Catering (45% Off)

Cala di Mare Italian Grill and Catering

Rockville Centre

Elegant restaurant and banquet hall serves a menu of Italian classics including stuffed pork chops and seafood risotto

$40 $22

Italian Dinner for Two or Four at Bravo! Nader (47% Off)

Bravo Nader

Huntington

Twelve cozy tables are set with appetizers, soups, or salads, entrees such as veal parmesan or house-made gnocchi with pesto, and coffees

$50 $28

Pizza and Italian Fare at Prince Umberto Pizzeria & Restaurant (50% Off). Three Options Available.

Prince Umberto Pizzeria & Restaurant

Franklin Square

Laid-back Italian restaurant serves up classic and unique pies topped with anything from fried calamari to potato and egg

$40 $20

$15 for Italian Cuisine and Drinks at Junior's Pizza ($30 Value)

Junior's Pizza

Junior's Pizza

Thin, stuffed, and Sicilian- and grandma-style pizzas, plus veal parmigiana, manicotti, and other Italian classics

$30 $15

Italian Food for Dine-In, or a Family Meal for Carryout at Plum Tomatoes Pizzeria Restaurant (Up to 47% Off)

Plum Tomatoes Pizzeria Restaurant

Plum Tomatoes Pizzeria Restaurant

Award-winning Italian eatery uses fresh ingredients, from broccoli to artichoke, to create gluten-free pastas, seafood, and pizza

$40 $22

Italian Food and Drinks for Two or Four at La Terazza (50% Off)

La Terazza

Franklin Square

New York–inspired Italian cuisine includes appetizers such as eggplant rollatini to go with entrees such as shrimp scampi

$50 $25

Italian Food at Nick's Tuscan Grill (31% Off). Four Options Available.

Nick's Tuscan Grill

Mineola

Menu includes lobster ravioli, sautéed lemon chicken, gorgonzola-crusted rib eye, and pizza with housemade meatballs

$30 $21

Italian Food and Drinks for Two or Four at Eatalia Family Style (50% Off)

Eatalia Family Style

Huntington

Family-style pasta, pizza, and other Italian favorites made with farm-fresh ingredients and served in lively, welcoming atmosphere

$50 $25

Italian Food for Two or Four or Takeout Family Pizza Dinner at Gino's of Seaford (Up to 42% Off)

Gino's of Seaford

Seaford

This casual, family-friendly Italian spot serves up pastas, seafood specialties, and Neapolitan– or Sicilian–style pizzas

$30 $18

Italian Cuisine or Pizza and Wings Takeout Packages at Pomodorino Ristorante (Up to 48% Off).

Pomodorino Ristorante

West Hills

Brick-oven pizza with san marzano tomatoes and fresh basil, spaghetti with housemade meatballs, and lasagna with imported parmesan cheese

$30 $16

Pizza and Pasta for Dine-In or Carry-Out at Gino's of Northport (Up to 42% Off). Four Options Available.

Gino's of Northport

East Northport

Family-owned restaurant serves up Neapolitan and Sicilian style pizza, along with dishes like eggplant rollatini stuffed with ricotta

$25 $15

Pizza Meal or $12 for $20 Worth of Pizzeria Food at Mamma Gina Pizza

Mamma Gina Pizza

Mamma Gina Pizza

Hearty pizzas and authentic Italian fare at pizzeria opened in 1990

$20 $12

Italian Dinner for Two or Four at Giardinetto Restaurant (Up to 54% Off)

Giardinetto Restaurant

Inwood

Eatery serves up Old World cuisine with apps like caprese and shrimp cocktail, and entrees like veal chops and lobster ravioli

$96 $49

Italian Cuisine for Dinner or Lunch at Eric's Italian Bistro (Up to 53% Off). Four Options Available.

Eric's Italian Bistro

Mineola

Restaurant praised by the New York Times specializes in rustic Italian dishes such as frutti de mare or lasagna made from a family recipe

$83.80 $39

Italian Dinner or Lunch for Two or Four at Osteria Da Nino (Up to 44% Off)

Osteria Da Nino

Osteria Da Nino

Handmade pastas and unique proteins enhance rustic Italian dishes such as kale-and-spinach gnocchi, rabbit cacciatore, and seared branzino

$50 $30

Pizza and Italian Food at Gino's Pizza of Kings Park (Up to 42% Off). Four Options Available.

Gino's Pizza of Kings Park

Kings Park

Pizza, pasta, salads, soups, and seafood dishes crafted from family recipes at cozy eatery

$25 $15

Italian Food for Dine-In or Takeout at Mulberry Street of Seaford (42% Off)

Mulberry Street of Seaford

Seaford

Classic Italian fare, such as stuffed rigatoni, veal marsala, and baked ziti are complemented by unique dishes, such as Thai-style calamari

$50 $29

Pizza and Italian Cuisine for Dine-In or Take-Out at Azzurro's Pizzeria Restaurant Bar (50% Off)

Azzurro's Pizzeria Restaurant Bar

Azzurro's Pizzeria Restaurant Bar

This Italian eatery’s owners take an active role in the kitchen, serving up tortellini bolognese, veal sorrentino, and Neapolitan pizza

$50 $25

Two Frozen Pizzas or Two Brooklyn Squares at Brooklyn Square Pizza (Up to 39% Off)

Brooklyn Square Pizza

Seaford

Square sicilian-style pizzas baked to golden finish for dine-in or takeout; frozen pizzas available for takeout

$18.50 $12

$10 for $15 Worth of Pizza — Mama Gina Pizza

Mama Gina Pizza

Valley Stream

From the merchant: Mamma Ginas’s Pizza has been serving authentic Italian cuisine to the Valley Stream Community since 1990.

$15 $10

Italian Dinner for Two or Four at Matteo's Trattoria of Roslyn (Up to 51% Off)

Matteo's Trattoria of Roslyn

Roslyn Heights

Pair linguine and clams or veal chop Milanese with sips from an encyclopedic wine list at this upscale Italian eatery

$80 $39

Wood-Fired Pizza and Iron-Skillet Pasta from Red Tomato Pizza (Up to 54% Off). Six Options Available.

Red Tomato Artisanal Pizza

East Norwich

Wood-fired margherita pizza made with fresh mozarella and extra virgin olive oil; pastas cooked in an iron skillet; sangria and dessert

$93 $45

Large Pizza with Baked Ziti, or Italian Food and Drinks for Two or Four at Paesano Pizzeria (Up to 46% Off)

Paesano Pizzeria

Huntington

Italian dishes, including homemade gnocchi and baked ziti and pizza such as the Paesano Special, topped with a trio of meats and veggies

$20 $12

Italian Dinner for Two or Four at Solé (Up to 42% Off)

Sole

Oceanside

Chef Bobby Carmosino crafts Italian-inspired cuisine from fresh ingredients and some family recipes.

$60 $35

Italian Cuisine at Tony Colombos Italian Bistro (Up to 51% Off). Four Options Available.

Tony Colombos Italian Bistro

Rockville Centre

Menu includes grilled veal chops, eggplant rollatini, lasagna, prosciutto pizza, beef short rib ravioli, and shrimp scampi bread

$50 $29

Italian Food at Anthony's Lucky Duck (Up to 51% Off). Two Options Available.

Anthony's Lucky Duck

Garden City South

Cooks specialize in Italian flavors both classic and unconventional, with 21 different pasta selections, veal, and many seafood entrees

$40 $20

Select Local Merchants

  • Butera's Restaurant of Sayville
    Buon appetito! Eat your heart out at Butera's Restaurant of Sayville, where the freshest, five-star fare will fill any Italian appetite. For a hot slice or a steaming bowl of pasta, the menu is chock-full of your favorite carbs. If you're avoiding fat or gluten, you can still eat great at Butera's Restaurant of Sayville, which offers a number of low-fat and gluten-free choices. Drinks here are readily available, so you can enjoy a glass of red or try something new. This restaurant is more than willing to accommodate families, so kids are welcome to tag along. Plan your next big gathering at Butera's Restaurant of Sayville — patrons will appreciate the spacious interior, and there's even a private room for special occasions. At Butera's Restaurant of Sayville, the prime seating is on the patio. Come check out what all the buzz is about. If waiting to be seated isn't your style, plan ahead and make reservations. Leave the fancy duds at home — patrons at the restaurant dress informally. This restaurant offers carryout for your convenience. If you need to feed a big crowd, Butera's Restaurant of Sayville also offers catering services for parties and get-togethers. Drivers can take advantage of the parking lot near Butera's Restaurant of Sayville and save time on hunting for a parking spot. Bikers can store their bikes safely while they enjoy a meal at Butera's Restaurant of Sayville. Take a break from the kitchen without breaking the bank! Butera's Restaurant of Sayville will fill you up with top-notch fare that s modestly priced. High-quality Italian food awaits you at Butera's Restaurant of Sayville! All the best flavors of Italy await you at Butera's Restaurant of Sayville.
    Read More
    100 North Main Street
    Sayville, NY US
  • Satellite Pizza
    Fresh from the oven every time, the insanely-cheesy slices at Satellite Pizza have visitors hooked on five-star reviews. If gluten is something you try to avoid, check out the G-free menu at Satellite Pizza. Low-fat fare is also available for those keeping an eye on their diet. Parents appreciate this pizzeria's kid-friendly attitude, and little ones are often seen dining out with the adults. Give the pizzeria a call to reserve your table ahead of time. Leaving the couch is half the battle. Your foods awaits your pickup at this pizzeria. Throwing a big party? Count on Satellite Pizza to provide top-notch catering with the same great dishes you love. Parking is always free and easy when you dine at Satellite Pizza. Travel by bike to Satellite Pizza and store your bike at a nearby rack. If pizza is your all-time favorite, it's important to find a pie that's worth your while. With star-studded reviews and sky-high ratings, there's no better way to spend your time than eating some 'za at Satellite Pizza. Pizza doesn't have to be fancy to be great. Delicious pies await you at Satellite Pizza (along with star-studded reviews and sky-high ratings), so grab a seat and dig in. For hot pizza and a cool atmosphere, be sure to stop in at Satellite Pizza. For a pizza that is out of the world, call or make a visit to Satellite Pizza.
    Read More
    799 Montauk Highway
    Bayport, NY US
  • La Tavola
    La Tavola knows how to perfect pasta, and foodies rave about its cream-of-the-crop Italian eats. Keep your diet in check at La Tavola, a local restaurant with gluten-free and low-fat menu items. Complement your meal with a beer or wine from this restaurant's delightful drink menu. No need to splurge on a babysitter — tots will be right at home chowing down at this restaurant. With plenty of room to go around, La Tavola also offers a private area perfect for large groups. Surround yourself with the wonderful weather at your next night out at La Tavola. Make a reservation to ensure your night goes according to schedule. Keep it casual at La Tavola — the restaurant is laid-back and patrons dress accordingly. Just through the door at this restaurant, you can claim your food. No delivery required. Feed the gang at your next get-together with catering from La Tavola as well. La Tavola is just steps away from a parking lot. Most items on the menu are reasonably priced, so expect to spend around $30 per person at La Tavola. The restaurant's dinner menu receives the most attention, though breakfast and lunch are also options. While high-priced, the Italian food at La Tavola is well worth every penny! Experience the fine art of authentic Italian cooking when you sit down a meal at the charming La Tavola.
    Read More
    183 West Main Street
    Sayville, NY US
  • Sayville Pizza
    Score your next slice at Sayville Pizza — this joint has pizza-lovers dishing out cream of the crop reviews. Whether rocking a gluten-free lifestyle or looking for something low-fat, this place will serve you just what you need. Surround yourself with the wonderful weather at your next night out at Sayville Pizza. If waiting to be seated isn't your style, plan ahead and make reservations. Head to Sayville Pizza in comfort, where attire is business casual. Take the comfort of your own home and add great grub from Sayville Pizza to create the perfect night. Don't want to go out tonight but still want great food? Order takeout or delivery from this pizzeria. Drive to lunch or dinner at Sayville Pizza and find easy parking in a lot close by or on the street. Cyclists are in luck. Sayville Pizza provides bike parking. Roni, sausage, and veggie are just a few of the delicious options at Sayville Pizza. Taste the shining reviews for yourself when you head to Sayville Pizza for a tasty pizza pie. The pizza at Sayville Pizza is filled with endless flavors, so head on over today and enjoy a slice or two of yummy goodness. See for yourself why Sayville Pizza's Italian food is so highly considered. When in Rome, you do as the Romans do. When at Sayville Pizza, you eat as deliciously as the Italians do.
    Read More
    60 Main Street
    Sayville, NY US
  • Mark Anthony Pizza
    If cooking isn't on the agenda, the perfect pie awaits you at Mark Anthony Pizza, where customers praise the pizza like no other. Shake off the stiff workday duds at Mark Anthony Pizza — attire is casual. Through their catering service, Mark Anthony Pizza can also set out a delicious spread for your next party. Short on time? Don't wait for a driver — pick it up yourself. Mark Anthony Pizza's diners will appreciate the free parking in a lot next door. Store your bike safely at one of the main bike racks near Mark Anthony Pizza. Some people say that if you've had one pizza, you've had them all. Diners who've tried Mark Anthony Pizza's pizza say it is the absolute best. When you are feeling hungry, pay Mark Anthony Pizza a visit and enjoy a hot and fresh pizza filled with endless flavors.
    Read More
    37 N Main St
    Sayville, NY US
  • Oakdale Pizzeria
    Oakdale Pizzeria's cheesy goodness cannot be beat — this mellow establishment has perfected the art of pizza. Tots are more than welcome to dine with their parents at this pizzeria. Need to get out of the house? Order and pick up from this pizzeria. Catering from Oakdale Pizzeria will take your party to the next level. Parking can always be a hassle. That's why we've done half the work for you. Parking available onsite for our guests. Travel by bike to Oakdale Pizzeria and store your bike at a nearby rack. Find your sweet (or savory) spot at Oakdale Pizzeria, where you can opt for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. So head on over to Oakdale Pizzeria, where the pizzas are always hot and the ambiance is always cool. Pizza is a food staple that is done right by Oakdale Pizzeria.
    Read More
    887 Montauk Highway
    Oakdale, NY US

Groupon Guide

Grouber