Italian Restaurants in Suffern, NY

$10 For $20 Worth Of Casual Dining



$20 $10

$20 For $40 Worth Of Italian Cuisine



$40 $20

Italian Cuisine for Dinner or Lunch at Pavinci Italian Grill (Up to 50% Off). Five Options Available.

Pavinci Italian Grill


Diners enjoy wine and Italian staples, such as gnocchi with pesto or scallops scampi, while soaking in gorgeous views of the adjacent lake

$30 $15

Italian Food and Burgers at Nunzio's Dolce Vita (Up to 51% Off). Four Options Available.

Nunzio's Dolce Vita


Chef folds market-fresh ingredients into Italian classics, such as chicken cacciatore, and burgers made with kobe beef

$40 $20

Italian Cuisine at Mario's Famous Pizza (Up to 52% Off). Four Options Available.

Mario's Famous Pizza


Menu includes clams casino, bruschetta pizza, gnocchi alfredo, chicken marsala, veal scampi, eggplant parmigiana subs, and proscuitto pitas

$50 $30

Surf 'n' Turf Dinner with Wine for Two or Four at Portofino Restaurant (Up to 58% Off)

Portofino Ristorante

City Island

An Italian appetizer and dessert bookend a main course of Maine lobster tail and sirloin steak

$223.85 $99

Specialty Pizza, Oven-Baked Heroes, and Family-Style Pasta for Two or Four at TJ's Pizzeria Cafe (Up to 50% Off)

TJ's Pizzeria Cafe


Expansive Italian menu with specialty pizza and baked pasta also includes Angus rib eye cheesesteaks and oven-baked heroes

$25 $13

$20 For $40 Worth Of Italian Fine Dinner Dining


Briarcliff Manor

$40 $20

Italian Cuisine for Two on Sunday–Thursday or Friday–Saturday at Luna Rossa Ristorante (Up to 50% Off)

Luna Rossa Ristorante


Flounder piccata, handmade pastas, and other traditional Italian dishes from a family-run restaurant that’s honed their recipes for decades

$30 $15

One, Two, or Three Large Pizzas with Up to Five Toppings and Sides at Papa John's (Up to 71% Off)

Papa John's

Multiple Locations

Hand-tossed pizzas slathered with sauce made from vine-ripened, California-grown tomatoes

$68.50 $19.99

Pizza and Italian Food for Dine-In, Take-Out, or Delivery from Fratello's Pizzeria and Trattoria (Up to 52% Off)

Fratellos Pizzeria and Trattoria

Upper Vailsburg

An expansive menu features everything from lasagna, eggplant parmesan, and shrimp fra diavolo to paninis, pizza, and wings

$20 $12

Upscale Italian Dinner Cuisine and Drinks at Vicolo Ristorante (Up to 42% Off)

Vicolo Ristorante

Old Tappan

Enjoy house-made Italian pasta, chicken, veal, and seafood dishes at upscale eatery

$40 $23

$15 For $30 Worth Of Italian Cuisine & Specialties

Benvenuti Italian Specialties & Catering


$30 $15

Italian Dinner for Two or Four With or Without Wine at Caesar's Grill Restaurant (Up to 46% Off)

Caesar's Grill Restaurant

Mount Ivy

Veal sorrentino sautéed in red sauce and layered with prosciutto, mozzarella, and eggplant highlights a menu of Italian cuisine

$49.80 $29

$15 For $30 Worth Of Italian Cuisine


Downtown Elizabeth

$30 $15

Italian Dinner for Two or Four or Takeout at The Recipe (Up to 50% Off)

The Recipe


This cozy Italian spot features dishes such as linguine with clam sauce, lasagna, and veal marsala

$30 $15

Italian Cuisine at Mamma Francesca (Up to 42% Off). Three Options Available.

Mamma Francesca

Residence Park

Traditional Italian dishes such as chicken parmigiana, veal marsala, and manicotti and ravioli made from family recipes

$50 $29

Contemporary Italian Meal with Apps, Entrees & Desserts for Two or Four at Giulio's Restaurant (Up to 47% Off)

Giulio's Restaurant

Giulio's Restaurant

Appetizers such as fried calamari with goat cheese and entrees such as lobster-and-shrimp risotto and skirt steak in veal stock

$84 $45

Italian Dinners for Two or Four with Appetizers and Wine at Pasta Cucina (Up to 35% Off). Two Options Available.

Pasta Cucina

Stony Point

Classic Italian recipes come alive in plates of linguine with fresh clams, veal saltimbocca over beds of spinach, and fettuccine carbonara

$64.97 $45

$17 for $30 Worth of Italian Dinner at Limoncello Ristorante

Limoncello Ristorante


Chefs use the restaurant’s namesake lemon liqueur to flavor Italian dishes—from vetello benito veal to cheese ravioli with basil

$30 $17

Italian Cuisine for Dinner or Lunch at The Cake Lounge & Restaurant (Up to 52% Off). Five Options Available.

The Cake Lounge & Restaurant

Little Ferry

Chefs prepare a lineup of authentic Italian cuisine, including pastas and veal dishes, alongside custom cakes and inventive cocktails

$30 $15

Italian Food for Lunch, Dinner, or Takeout at Sofia's Italian Restaurant (Up to 50% Off). Two Options Available.

Sofia's Italian Restaurant

Sofia's Italian Restaurant

BYO wines complement traditional Italian entrees; perfect for date night

$50 $25

Two Appetizers and Bar Credit or Italian Dinner for Two or Four at Frankie & Augie'Z (Up to 53% Off)

Frankie & Augie'Z

Jefferson Valley-Yorktown

Birra Moretti and house wines wash down risotto in saffron cream sauce, chicken in madeira brown sauce, and stuffed shells

$64.95 $33

$15 For $30 Worth Of Italian Dinner Dining


North End

$30 $15

Pizzeria Fare for Dine-In at TJ's Pizzeria Cafe of Sussex (Up to 50% Off). Two Options Available.

TJ's Pizzeria Cafe of Sussex

Tj's Pizzeria

Dig into meaty pastas, hearty calzones, and custom and specialty pizzas

$25 $13

Italian Food for Dine-In at Eatalian Bistro (Up to 46% Off). Two Options Available.

Eatalian Bistro


BYOB eatery creates rustic and hearty Italian dishes such as lobster ravioli and shrimp, eggplant rollatini, and garlic white basil pizza

$35 $19

Italian Food at Palazzo Restaurant (Up to 45% Off). Two Options Available.

Palazzo Restaurant

Palazzo Restaurant

Pork milanese, chicken porcini, spaghetti vongole, and other Italian classics at this authentic Montclair mainstay

$40 $22

Pizza or Pasta Meal for Two at Giovanni's Restaurant Pizzeria (Up to 40% Off). Four Options Available.

Giovanni's Restaurant Pizzeria


Laid-back eatery dishes out cuisine such as salmon over a broccoli wrap, chicken marsala, orecchiette pasta vodka sauce, salads, and pizzas

$36.45 $22

Italian Dinner and Drinks for Two or Four at Lorenzo's (Up to 51% Off). Four Options Available.


Woodland Park

Lasagna, pasta fagioli, and sausage rabi made from recipes imported from Italy & handed down through generations; large wine list & full bar

$40 $20

$10 For $20 Worth Of Casual Italian Cuisine



$20 $10

Select Local Merchants

  • Nonna's Pizza & Restaurant
    Deemed "pizza of the year" every year by Nonna's Pizza and Restaurant's loyal fans, this deliciously-cheesy pizza will have you reaching for seconds, thirds, and even fourths. Bring the whole family to this pizzeria, where kiddos are welcomed with open arms. Folks tend to dress down at Nonna's Pizza and Restaurant, so keep comfort in mind when heading to the pizzeria. This pizzeria also offers delivery and take-out options for those who want to make it a night in. Nonna's Pizza and Restaurant can also cater your next party; call today for details. For easy dining, Nonna's Pizza and Restaurant provides convenient parking in a connecting lot. Nonna's Pizza and Restaurant offers various parking options, including bike parking. Take a break from the kitchen without breaking the bank! Nonna's Pizza and Restaurant will fill you up with top-notch fare that s modestly priced. Roni, sausage, and veggie are just a few of the delicious options at Nonna's Pizza and Restaurant. Taste the shining reviews for yourself when you head to Nonna's Pizza and Restaurant for a tasty pizza pie. If you can't get enough pizza, be sure to try the pies at Nonna's Pizza and Restaurant, which earn ratings too hot to handle. Nonna's Pizza and Restaurant serves up fresh and tasty pizzas each and every time, so head on over today and enjoy some good pizza in a casual ambiance. When you order pizza from Nonna's Pizza and Restaurant, you'll maximize any evening for sure.
    Read More
    Mahwah, NJ US
  • Roxanne's Restaurant
    Load up on meatballs and marinara at Roxanne's Restaurant, and find out for yourself if the five-star ratings are up to par. Some may say it's rare to see healthy, gluten-free menu options, but Roxanne's Restaurant says it's a necessity. A night out deserves a drink to celebrate, and this restaurant has the perfect selection of beer and wine to go with your meal. This restaurant welcomes kids, too, so you can feel good about bringing the whole family. During the summer months, don't miss out on Roxanne's Restaurant's outdoor patio seating. The restaurant is on the noisier end, which is something to keep in mind when planning intimate get-togethers. Take advantage of the restaurant's reservation system, and book a table for your party. Roxanne's Restaurant wants guests to dine in comfort, so save that stuffy suit for another date. You can also have Roxanne's Restaurant cater your next event. Meeting the gang for a movie? Pick up some food from this restaurant. Stop the stress of trying to find a parking spot and head to the lot next to Roxanne's Restaurant for parking and valet services. Cyclists will love the spacious bike racks outside of Roxanne's Restaurant. For a decently-priced meal that s not too fancy, Roxanne's Restaurant hits the nail on the head. High-quality Italian food awaits you at Roxanne's Restaurant! So amp up your lunch hour with a delicious and authentic Italian meal from Roxanne's Restaurant.
    Read More
    Mahwah, NJ US
  • Tirreno Pizza
    Tirreno Pizza's piping pizza is just as hot as its ratings, and customers call this tasty spot one of the best around. Looking for healthy and low-fat eats? No problem. Tirreno Pizza has both. This pizzeria's fully stocked bar is a perk for patrons who enjoy a fine wine (or more) with their meal. Don't go off the grid! With the free wifi at Tirreno Pizza, you can surf the web and get some work done. At Tirreno Pizza, you won't have to wait for your large or small group to be seated. For a fancy night out, Tirreno Pizza's formal dress code will make you feel like royalty. Bring the Tirreno Pizza's great food to your place. You might have thought your order was a tough decision, but you still have one more. Delivery or carryout? You can easily find street parking near Tirreno Pizza or pull up curbside and make use of the valet service. Take a break from the kitchen without breaking the bank! Tirreno Pizza will fill you up with top-notch fare that s modestly priced. With food so tasty, you'll want to have breakfast, lunch, and dinner here...and you can go right ahead as Tirreno Pizza serves three meals a day. Swing by the pizzeria at literally any hour — it's open 24 hours a day. So who's hungry? The highly-acclaimed pizza at Tirreno Pizza is ready and waiting to be served. So for a piece of pizza that truly sings, you'll love taking a bite out of the pie from Tirreno Pizza.
    Read More
    Mahwah, NJ US
  • Marcello's
    Inside the kitchen of Marcello’s, teardrop chandeliers cast their warm gaze over copper cookware and a dining table that wraps around the stove. Here, Chef Marcello sheds light on the techniques of preparing Italian cuisine during cooking classes and private parties. In such events, up to 12 guests can sip wine while he picks recipes secretly stored in his chef’s hat and demonstrates how to assemble artful dishes, which may include risotto with chicken and spinach or pasta with fresh tomato mozzarella and basil. Although the private dining experience is the easiest way to witness Chef Marcello’s passion for sharing the cuisine of his native Italy, guests can also enjoy his dynamic entrees without front-row seats at the chef’s table. In the restaurant’s dining room, floor-to-ceiling murals depict the Tuscan countryside and ferns adorn honey-colored walls as diners anticipate hearty meals. Atop crisp white tablecloths, servers present platters of housemade pastas and veal prepared seven ways. The knowledgeable staff is also happy to recommend pairings from the vast Italian wine list.
    Read More
    Suffern, NY US
  • Sunnyside's Bar & Grill
    For Italian fare that doesn't mess around, Sunnyside's Bar and Grill is home to top-notch ratings and reviews. Complete your meal with the perfect glass of wine or beer from this restaurant's drink list. Parents, bring your kids along to this restaurant, where you'll find a family-friendly menu and ambience. Your group can sit comfortably at Sunnyside's Bar and Grill, a local restaurant. The restaurant accepts reservations, so you can get around the busy crowd. Casual dining at its best, Sunnyside's Bar and Grill customers are free to enjoy themselves in jeans and a T-shirt. Or, take your grub to go. Catering is also available if you'd like to serve Sunnyside's Bar and Grill's tasty dishes at your next party. Parking is available at an adjacent lot. Sunnyside's Bar and Grill offers various parking options, including bike parking. Meals at Sunnyside's Bar and Grill are moderately priced — most diners spend about $30 per person. Come see why the Italian food at Sunnyside's Bar and Grill is well worth the price. Do you hear your stomach growling? Answer the call with a tasty Italian meal from Sunnyside's Bar and Grill.
    Read More
    Sloatsburg, NY US
  • Mahwah Pizza Master
    Hot cheesy goodness awaits your appetite at Mahwah Branch — this Mahwah pizza joint is the place to go for a serious five-star slice. Mahwah Branch's low-fat and G-free items make it easy to eat right. Stay connected at no cost thanks to Mahwah Branch's wifi. Your large group can all sit together at Mahwah Branch. Pups of all sorts are also welcome at the pizzeria. Don't sacrifice comfort for style — Mahwah Branch's dress code is business casual, so guests can look and feel great. This pizzeria lets you stop by or stay home for your food. Mahwah Branch is known for serving great food, and they are able to serve it at your next event with their excellent catering. Easily accessible parking options are located near this dining establishment. Meals at Mahwah Branch are moderately priced — most diners spend about $30 per person. When melted cheese and quality crust is all you can think about, it may be time for a hot slice or two. Experience pizza at its best when you order a pie from top-rated Mahwah Branch. Mahwah Branch serves up hot and fresh pizzas, so head on over today and enjoy a tasty slice of paradise.
    Read More
    Mahwah, NJ US