Since 1848, Applegate Farm has existed under many guises, but its purpose has always remained the same: to provide fresh dairy products for local families. Originally home to the Sitger family and their golden guernsey milk, the farm has changed hands several times since the late 1800s and survived through the Civil War, both World Wars, and all six Star Wars. It experimented with its first ice-cream cone in the late 1920s under the guidance of owner Julian Tinkham, who also had the good foresight to preserve the farm's historic structures so that future generations could visit the 19th-century farmhouse that once helped slaves to freedom or count the number of tiles in an authentic 1919 tile silo––one of only three built in the state.
Since then, the farm has expanded and operates under the current leadership of the Street family, who hold themselves to the same dedication to quality that has sustained the dairy for more than 164 years. The range of ice-cream flavors changes seasonally but usually includes at least 63 distinctive varieties ranging from orange pineapple and toasted almond to vanilla peanut butter and Graham Central Station––which won top prize at the New Jersey State Ice Cream Festival. No-sugar-added and dairy-free treats can also be found in scoopable form, along with ice-cream cakes, ice-cream pies, ice-cream sandwich breads, and other things that are best when sliced.
Maria has spent the past 30 years trying to satisfy her sweet tooth (and the sweet teeth of others) with homemade cakes and cupcakes frosted in decadent buttercream. It was her penchant for sweets that led her to open Sensational Cakes by Maria, a bakery specializing in custom cakes with whimsical designs that incorporate fondant and colorful frostings. In addition to cakes and cupcakes, Maria also bakes apple, cherry, and other fruit pies topped with a double crust, crumble, or a tiny note warning the reader that you’re about to pie him in the face.
Erica Lieberman's lifelong affinity for baking began in her mother's kitchen 25 years ago. Since then, Erica has turned her passion for making treats into Whipped Bites, where she churns out cupcakes in a variety of sweet flavors. Featured cupcakes include apple pie with cinnamon-apple cake and vanilla-cream-cheese frosting and the PB&J, or peanut-butter cake filled with grape jelly and topped with vanilla-bean frosting.
Manhattan Bagel’s expert dough-smiths craft 21 flavors of fresh-baked bagels daily, serving them alongside a menu of deli-style sandwiches made with Boar’s Head meats and cheeses. Vainly search for the beginning or end of a traditionally flavored bagel ($.89 each, $8.99 a dozen), such as everything and pumpernickel, or explore the innovative tastescape of the french-toast variety, which doubles as an engagement ring for a Parisian giantess. Diners can festoon their bagels with cheese and eggs cooked any way ($2.49) or wrap mandibles around the grilled Ellis Island pastrami sandwich, sealed with gooey swiss cheese and onion ($6.49). Patrons can also sip on a selection from the espresso bar while noshing on the Wall Street roast beef ($6.49), a diversified sandwich portfolio of roast beef and mild horseradish sauce on a cheddar roll.
FrozenPeaks Frozen Yogurt serves as many as 24 flavors such as lemon, watermelon, coconut, and chocolate. Patrons can gussy up frosty swirls with fresh fruit, candy, nuts, and other toppings, or opt for a fresh, handcrafted frozen yogurt pops dipped in rich coatings and rolled in toppings. Nondairy options are available as well.
Bakers at Peace of Cake craft their cupcakes with fresh ingredients for rich texture. They create a rotating menu of flavors, including raspberry swirl stuffed with jam and cookie dough filled with real cookie dough and crowned with chocolate frosting.
At Cinnabon, the aroma of scrumptious baked goods wafts through the air as chilled beverages help sate the snack appetites of weary mallwalkers. Munch on a variety of cinnamon-infused treats, such as the Cinnabon classic roll, temptingly filled with Cinnabon’s famous makara cinnamon ($3.49), or the caramel Pecanbon, topped with an edible medley of luscious caramel and tasty pecans ($3.79). An assortment of goodies can be toted home for hungry broods in one of the stores’ regular Cinnapacks ($11.99 for four, $16.99 for six), and a 15-pack Minibon box ($18.99) is perfect for a sparsely attended reunion of former Power Rangers. After snacking, revitalize taste buds with a cup of iced coffee ($2.49–$3.49) or the chocolate-augmented, frosty Mochalatta Chill ($3.49–$4.19), a more refreshing way to cool down than a game of patty-cake against a polar bear.