Main menu Open search menu

Italian Restaurants in Coney Island, NY


40% Cash Back at Brooklyn's Best
40% Cash Back at Brooklyn's Best

Restaurant offers a hand-picked selection of kosher pizzas, pasta dishes, salads, poke bowls, and more

Central Brooklyn 2.8 mi
(1)
40% cash_back
20% Cash Back at Papa John's Pizza
20% Cash Back at Papa John's Pizza

Have a pizza night with your favorite Papa John’s pie, made using high-protein flour and fresh produce

Southern Brooklyn 1.6 mi
(12)
20% cash_back
40% Cash Back at Little Caesars Brooklyn
40% Cash Back at Little Caesars Brooklyn

Hot and fresh pizza topped with a range of classic toppings alongside signature garlicky Crazy Bread for dipping in tomato sauce

Sunset Park 5.0 mi
(6)
40% cash_back
5% Cash Back at Vapiano
5% Cash Back at Vapiano

Guests move freely from station to station to order from chefs who whip up pasta and salads right before their eyes

Greenwich Village 10.8 mi
(466)
5% cash_back
25% Cash Back at Big Slice Pizza Of Ny
25% Cash Back at Big Slice Pizza Of Ny

Huge slices or entire made-to-order pies of New York–style pizza made with hand-tossed crusts

Midtown Manhattan 11.2 mi
(117)
25% cash_back
20% Cash Back at Da Nonna Rosa
20% Cash Back at Da Nonna Rosa

Italian food created using family recipes from southern Italy, including pasta and Sicilian-style pizzas made with San Marzano tomato sauce

Park Slope 6.6 mi
(294)
20% cash_back
25% Cash Back at Surf City
25% Cash Back at Surf City

Just a stone’s throw from the Coney Island Boardwalk, this restaurant boasts a big menu of Italian food, including pizza, pastas, and gelato

Southern Brooklyn 0.9 mi
(1)
25% cash_back
30% Cash Back at PIZZA STOP
30% Cash Back at PIZZA STOP

Chefs prepare quick Italian dishes such as sandwiches and pizza

Riverbend 14.7 mi
(98)
30% cash_back
20% Cash Back at Previti Pizza
20% Cash Back at Previti Pizza

Menu features gourmet pizzas along with stromboli, calzones, and sandwiches

Midtown Manhattan 12.0 mi
(52)
20% cash_back
Dinner for Two or Four People at 1742 Wine Bar (Up to 64% Off)
Dinner for Two or Four People at 1742 Wine Bar (Up to 64% Off)

An elegant wine bar and restaurant with tons of brunch and dinner options

Upper East Side 14.2 mi
$108 $39
(12189)
64% discount_off
$3 Cash Back When You Spend $6 or More at Pizza Boulevard
$3 Cash Back When You Spend $6 or More at Pizza Boulevard

Menu with traditional pizza by the slice and calzones, along with an array of specialty pizzas with unique toppings and flavors

Manhattan Beach 2.9 mi
(8)
undefined% cash_back
10% Cash Back at Durso's Pasta & Ravioli Company
10% Cash Back at Durso's Pasta & Ravioli Company

Family-owned Italian specialty store serving a wide variety of pastas, sauces, sandwiches, and ready-to-heat meals, all made fresh daily

Auburndale 16.6 mi
(33)
10% cash_back
5% Cash Back at Giovanni's Trattoria
5% Cash Back at Giovanni's Trattoria

Italian restaurant specializing in brick-oven pizzas and pasta dishes

Giovanni's Trattoria 9.3 mi
(13)
5% cash_back
20% Cash Back at Prospect Tavern
20% Cash Back at Prospect Tavern

Bar serves upscale cuisine such as crab-stuffed calamari, lobster rolls, and Cajun new york strip, all which can be paired with drinks

Upper Vailsburg 25.2 mi
(608)
20% cash_back
15% Cash Back at La Gusto Pizza & Restaurant
15% Cash Back at La Gusto Pizza & Restaurant

Low-key Italian eatery serves pizza and pasta, as well as more casual fare like burgers and sandwiches

Midtown Manhattan 11.8 mi
(23)
15% cash_back
50% Cash Back at Famous NY Pizza
50% Cash Back at Famous NY Pizza

Pizzeria bakes up all manner of pizza in order to accommodate every gustatory preference

North Shore 6.4 mi
(1)
50% cash_back
5% Cash Back at Caffe Buon Gusto
5% Cash Back at Caffe Buon Gusto

Try a housemade pasta like spinach gnocchi or veal tortellini tossed with a freshly made sauce, followed by a slice of ricotta cheesecake

Multiple Locations 8.1 mi
(52)
5% cash_back
10% Cash Back at Luv N Oven Pizza
10% Cash Back at Luv N Oven Pizza

Pizza enthusiasts can enjoy their favorite dish at a local restaurant

Fort Greene 7.8 mi
(3)
10% cash_back
20% Cash Back at Caffe e Vino
20% Cash Back at Caffe e Vino

Get 20% cash back on your first purchase and 10% cash back on all additional purchases

Northwestern Brooklyn 7.8 mi
(1)
20% cash_back
10% Cash Back at D'Cocco's  Restaurant & Pizzeria
10% Cash Back at D'Cocco's Restaurant & Pizzeria

Claim this deal and get 10% cash back rewards when you pay with your linked credit card at D’Cocco’s Restaurant & Pizzeria

Long Beach Road & Mott Street Sands Shopping Center Oceanside 18.9 mi
(682)
10% cash_back
30% Cash Back at Pizza Vizza
30% Cash Back at Pizza Vizza

New York-style topped with Italian meats, Indian spices, or fresh veggies like green peppers and onion

North Shore 8.0 mi
(6)
30% cash_back
20% Cash Back at Pastrami & Pickles
20% Cash Back at Pastrami & Pickles

Deli meats like pastrami and corned beef pair with rye bread, pickles, coleslaw at this counter-style ordering spot

Roselle Park 15.1 mi
(35)
20% cash_back
<strong>Italian</strong> Cuisine for Dinner for Two or Four at Da Francesco (38% Off)
Italian Cuisine for Dinner for Two or Four at Da Francesco (38% Off)

Cuisine includes house-made potato gnocchi, pistachio-crusted salmon, and beer-braised short ribs

Williamsburg 10.0 mi
$60 $37
(1121)
38% discount_off
20% Cash Back at Pi 3.14 Pizzeria
20% Cash Back at Pi 3.14 Pizzeria

Get 20% cash back on your first purchase and 10% cash back on all additional purchases

North Shore 7.6 mi
(4)
20% cash_back
20% Cash Back at Sbarro
20% Cash Back at Sbarro

Classic New York–style pizza, thick-crust Sicilian pies, and strombolis stuffed with mozzarella, pepperonis, and more

Central Brooklyn 6.0 mi
(23)
20% cash_back
20% Cash Back at Stone Bridge Pizza And Salad
20% Cash Back at Stone Bridge Pizza And Salad

Fresh, natural ingredients make up the base for these farm-to-table artisanal pizzas and salads

Midtown East 12.1 mi
(114)
20% cash_back
25% Cash Back at Gencarelli's - Pine Brook
25% Cash Back at Gencarelli's - Pine Brook

Family-friendly restaurant has been serving up authentic Italian cuisine in an elegant yet relaxed atmosphere for more than 25 years

Eagle View at Montville 26.6 mi
(54)
25% cash_back
30% Cash Back at La Piccola Pizza & Deli
30% Cash Back at La Piccola Pizza & Deli

Protein-topped pizzas and sandwiches are the stars of the show at this pizzeria-deli fusion that also offers breakfast sammies in the AM

Union 15.3 mi
(3)
30% cash_back
30% Cash Back at Grimaldi's Pizzeria - Up to $10 in Cash Back
30% Cash Back at Grimaldi's Pizzeria - Up to $10 in Cash Back

Thin-crust pizzas with handmade mozzarella, fragrant tomato sauce, and fresh toppings are baked in coal-fired brick ovens

Garden City 21.5 mi
(1960)
30% cash_back
30% Cash Back at Primo Pizzeria
30% Cash Back at Primo Pizzeria

Menu features gourmet and Sicilian style pizzas topped with freshly-prepared ingredients along with home-made paninis and soups

Dongan Hills 5.5 mi
(71)
30% cash_back

Groupon Guide