Italian Restaurants in Tinton Falls, NJ

Italian Cuisine for Dinner at Nonnas Citi Cucina (Up to 42% Off). Two Options Available.

Nonnas Citi Cucina


Italian joint dishes out fried calamari, meatball sliders, penne bolognese, short rib, and pear blue cheese pizzetta with crispy proscuitto

$40 $23

Italian Lunch or Dinner for Two or More at Ornella Trattoria Italiana (Up to 40% Off). Two Options Available.

Ornella Trattoria Italiana

Ditmars Steinway

Regional Italian food including prosciutto di parma, penne with San Marzano tomato sauce, spaghetti carbonara, and salmone primavera

$50 $30

Italian Picnic in the Park for Two or Four from Pappardella (Up to 58% Off)


Upper West Side

Head over to Central Park for a picnic complete with Pappardella’s antipasti, sandwiches, and desserts

$90 $39

Italian Cuisine for Two or More or Four or More at Luna Piena Restaurant (Up to 46% Off)

Luna Piena Restaurant

Midtown East

Classic Italian dishes include homemade pasta dubbed “light and airy” by New York magazine, Black Angus steak, and many seafood dishes

$60 $35

$15 For $30 Worth Of Casual Dining



$30 $15

$30 for a Family Pizza Dinner for Five at Sciortino's Restaurant ($50 Value)

Sciortino's Restaurant

South Amboy

Groups feast on 24 slices of brick-oven pizza at a restaurant that’s been run by the Sciortino family since the 1930s

$50 $30

Pizza and Italian Food at DoughBoys Wood Fired Pizza (Up to 50% Off). Four Options Available.

DoughBoys Wood Fired Pizza

doughboys Wood Fired Pizza

Wood-fired, Neapolitan–style pizzas served alongside Italian favorites such as penne with vodka sauce, eggplant parmesan, and meatball subs

$10 $6

Pizza, Pasta, and International Food for Two or Four at Pete's Pizza (Up to 52% Off). Two Options Available.

Pete's Pizza


Chefs serve Italian, Greek and American favorites to hungry diners in a family-owned restaurant

$51.90 $25

Italian Dinner for Two or Four with Appetizers, and Entrees at Alfredo 100 (Up to 51% Off)

Alfredo 100


Manhattan outpost of the Roman restaurant that invented fettuccine alfredo serves five takes on the dish, as well as other Italian classics

$108 $54

Organic and All-Natural Italian Food at Naturale Cucina (45% Off). Four Options Available.

Naturale Cucina


Fired in the terra-cotta brick oven, organic pizzas can be cooked to a crisp golden-brown; vegan and gluten free options available

$20 $12

Italian Meal with Wine or Cocktails for Two or Four at Aleo (Up to 52% Off)


Aleo Restaurant

Local markets supply the ingredients for Mediterranean-inspired dishes, including chicken parmigiano, pumpkin ravioli, and veal scaloppini

$78 $39

Pizza and Italian Food at Alfredo's Pizzeria and Restaurant (Up to 48% Off). Three Options Available.

Alfredo's Pizzeria and Restaurant

Alfredos Pizzeria and Restaurant

Fresh, homemade pizza is served alongside seafood, chicken, and pasta as well as Italian favorites such as stromboli and baked ziti

$25 $13

$15 For $30 Worth Of Italian Dining


Leisure Village West Condominiums

$30 $15

Surf 'n' Turf Dinner with Wine for Two or Four at Portofino Restaurant (Up to 58% Off)

Portofino Ristorante

City Island

An Italian appetizer and dessert bookend a main course of Maine lobster tail and sirloin steak

$223.85 $99

$75 for Italian Meal for Two with Appetizers, Entrees, and Champagne at Firenze Ristorante (Up to $130 Value)

Firenze Ristorante

Upper East Side

Clams, bruschetta, and fresh salads begin meals of housemade pasta, sautéed seafood, and Tuscan-style porterhouse steak

$130 $75

Italian Cuisine for Two for Four at Suzie's Starlight Lounge & Restaurant (Up to 54% Off)

Suzie's Starlight Lounge & Restaurant


An elegant setting serves classic Italian staples beneath a starlit ceiling

$75 $35

$20 Italian Food for Two at Maria Restaurant ($40 Value)

Maria Restaurant

Sheepshead Bay

Restaurant with 80 years of history serves up traditional Italian pastas and entrees, such as chicken cacciatore and penne alla vodka

$40 $20

One or Two 16" Large Pizzas at Pronto Pizza (Up to 50% Off)

Pronto Pizza

Southern Brooklyn

Family-owned eatery handcrafts dough for thin-crust and deep-dish pizzas

$20 $11

One, Two, or Three Large Pizzas with Up to Five Toppings and Sides at Papa John's (Up to 71% Off)

Papa John's

Multiple Locations

Hand-tossed pizzas slathered with sauce made from vine-ripened, California-grown tomatoes

$68.50 $19.99

Dinner and Drinks for Two or Four at 900 Park (Up to 45% Off)

900 Park

Morris Park

This upscale, second-floor Italian restaurant serves dishes such as seafood pastas, brick-oven pizzas, and veal chops with brandy sauce

$70.85 $39

Pizza, Crazy Bread, and Wings at Little Caesars (40% Off)

Little Caesars

East Bronx

Pair Hot-N-Ready pizza with toppoings like pepperoni, veggies, and italian sausage with Crazy bread and wings

$10 $6

Italian Cuisine and Drinks for Two or Four at Notaro (50% Off)


Murray Hill

A midtown establishment for more than a decade, Notaro’s low lit and classy dining room makes it easy to enjoy a romantic or quiet meal

$40 $20

Italian Meal for Two or Four with Appetizers and Fountain Drinks (Up to 56% Off)

Matese Pizzeria Ristorante


Plates of calamari share table space with shrimp-parmigiana hero sandwiches, baked shells with ricotta & veal picatta in casual pizzeria

$56.25 $25

Pizza, Appetizers, and Drinks for Two or Four at South Slope Public House (Up to 51% Off)

South Slope Public House

South Slope Public House

Tavern serving up crispy brick-oven pizza loaded with unique ingredients; shareable plates including wings, pretzel bites, and more

$45 $22

$25 for $50 Worth of Italian Cuisine at La Carbonara (50% Off)

La Carbonara

Downtown Manhattan

Inviting eatery serves rustic Italian fare like pappardelle bolognese and spaghetti carbonara

$50 $25

$19 for $30 Worth of Italian Cuisine and Drinks at Bensi


Multiple Locations

Each day the chefs hand-toss pizzas, blend homemade soups and salads and whip up housemade sauces to pour over made-to-order Italian cuisine

$30 $19

Pizzeria Cuisine for Two or Four at Rocco's Pizzeria (40% Off)

Rocco's Pizzeria

Southern Brooklyn

Menu includes buffalo wings, lasagna, pepperoni rolls, and pizzas like barbecue chicken, meat lovers, bacon and cheese, and eggplant

$20 $12

$20 For $40 Worth Of Casual Dinner Dining

La Gondola Restaurant & Pizzeria

Leisure Village West Condominiums

$40 $20

Mediterranean Meal for Two or Four at Acri Cafe (Up to 49% Off)

Acri Cafe

Westchester Village

A meal might begin with fried calamari, grilled octopus, or a wood-fired pizza and then move on to fetuccini with shrimp or chicken parmesan

$88 $45

Italian Cuisine for Dinner for Two or Four at Da Francesco (38% Off)

Da Francesco


Cuisine includes house-made potato gnocchi, pistachio-crusted salmon, and beer-braised short ribs

$60 $37

Select Local Merchants

  • Luigi's Famous Pizza
    Score your next slice at Luigi's Famous Pizza — this joint has pizza-lovers dishing out cream of the crop reviews. This place will leave you feeling satisfied no matter what kind of dietary needs you have. Round up the whole gang and reserve the private room at Luigi's Famous Pizza — it's the perfect spot for a big party to gather and celebrate. Don't like waiting to be seated? Make a reservation whether it's just you or the whole group. The dress code at Luigi's Famous Pizza is as relaxed as the ambience, so wear whatever suits you. Love the food at this pizzeria but don't have the time to stay? You can pick up your food to eat when you're ready, or have them deliver straight to your home. If you need to feed a big crowd, Luigi's Famous Pizza also offers catering services for parties and get-togethers. Score parking in the lot adjacent to Luigi's Famous Pizza, a local restaurant. Bike parking is quick and easy at Luigi's Famous Pizza. Treating yourself doesn't mean breaking the bank, come taste the great dishes Luigi's Famous Pizza has to offer. So who's hungry? The highly-acclaimed pizza at Luigi's Famous Pizza is ready and waiting to be served. So head on over to Luigi's Famous Pizza and order a pizza filled with all of your favorite yummy toppings.
    Read More
    Lincroft, NJ US
  • MJ's Pizza Bar & Grill
    For an entree that scores high on the taste test, try one of the many options available at Mj's Pizza Bar and Grill in Tinton Falls. The bar at this restaurant is fully stocked, so pair your meal with a glass of wine or beer. Load up the mini-van and bring the kids to this restaurant — they'll love the menu and scene here as much as mom and dad. Fridays are for fun! Come check out the vibe at Mj's Pizza Bar and Grill. Eat outdoors Mj's Pizza Bar and Grill (weather permitting) with their beautiful patio seating. Stay connected at no cost thanks to Mj's Pizza Bar and Grill's wifi. At Mj's Pizza Bar and Grill, your large or small group can be seated quickly and comfortably. Good luck spotting a suit and tie at Mj's Pizza Bar and Grill — casually-dressed diners are the norm here. Meeting the gang for a movie? Pick up some food from this restaurant. Mj's Pizza Bar and Grill is conveniently close to a parking lot. Fancy-schmancy price tags don t always bring the best results, and Mj's Pizza Bar and Grill s super yummy, mid-range menu is taste-test approved. At Mj's Pizza Bar and Grill, you have the option of paying by major credit card.
    Read More
    Tinton Falls, NJ US
  • Portofino Ristorante
    Portofino Ristorante captures the heart of Italian cuisine. Portofino Ristorante is also a good option for those with special dietary needs, offering both low-fat and gluten-free items on the menu. Portofino Ristorante is great for a large crowd and offers a private room for parties, celebrations or other merry gatherings. You can't book your table ahead of time at Portofino Ristorante, so show up early for your pick of tables. Head to Portofino Ristorante in comfort, where attire is business casual. Or, take your food to go. Can't get enough of Portofino Ristorante's tasty dishes? They also offer a catering service for parties and events. For an easy walk to the restaurant, diners can park in the neighboring lot where valet is also an option. Prices are affordable, with a typical meal running under $30. Isn't it time you tried Portofino Ristorante's great Italian place to satisfy your cheese cravings?
    Read More
    Eatontown, NJ US
  • Attilio's Pizza
    Attilio's Pizza does not just make pizza. They serve decadent slices of heaven that anyone who sinks their teeth into rate high on their list. It serves everything including gluten-free and low-fat options. Whether you have a group of five or a group of 20, Attilio's Pizza can seat both large and small groups. For the nights you just want to stay in and cozy up, order in great takeout or delivery from this pizzeria. Call Attilio's Pizza for catering if you have a big event coming up. Take advantage of the free parking next door to Attilio's Pizza. Your tab at Attilio's Pizza will generally run you about $30 per person. Everyone's talking about Attilio's Pizza. Find out why when you treat yourself to a delicious pizza pie. So for a piece of pizza that truly sings, you'll love taking a bite out of the pie from Attilio's Pizza.
    Read More
    Tinton Falls, NJ US
  • Cracked Olive Market
    Take a trip to Cracked Olive Market in Holmdel and make your next meal a good one. Get online gratis thanks to Cracked Olive Market's complimentary wifi. For those who prefer to dress down for dinner, Cracked Olive Market's low-key style is the perfect match. Through their catering service, Cracked Olive Market can also set out a delicious spread for your next party. This restaurant serves up innovative meals, so stop in, order takeout, or call for delivery. Whichever road you choose, happy eating! Cracked Olive Market offers complimentary parking at a lot close by. Cracked Olive Market offers safe bike parking outside. There's no need to bust your budget at Cracked Olive Market, with most meals costing under $15. You can stop by at practically any time, since Cracked Olive Market serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner.
    Read More
    Holmdel, NJ US
  • Attilio Restaurant & Pizzeria
    Craving pizza? Head on over to Lincroft's Attilio's Restaurant and Pizzeria for a tasty slice with a crust you can't resist. Help yourself to a healthier lifestyle at Attilio's Restaurant and Pizzeria, where gluten-free and low-fat plates are the standard. Don't go off the grid! With the free wifi at Attilio's Restaurant and Pizzeria, you can surf the web and get some work done. Enjoy mind-blowing dishes in the peace and quiet of your own home with delivery or takeout from Attilio's Restaurant and Pizzeria. The parking options near Attilio's Restaurant and Pizzeria are quick and painless. Attilio's Restaurant and Pizzeria dishes up breakfast, lunch, and dinner, so stop by for your favorite meal. Fight for a great pizza pie by placing your order into Attilio's Restaurant and Pizzeria today.
    Read More
    Lincroft, NJ US