Pizza in Kew Gardens, New York City, NY
500+ deals
People like to bandy the phrase "New York–style pizza" about, as if the Big Apple has a definitive slice of pie, but there’s much more to the New York City pizza scene. In other words, the best pizza in NYC could be anything from the charred, bubbly margherita pizza of Motorino to the thin-crust Sicilian squares of Joe & Pat’s in Staten Island. The quintessential New York–style pizza—foldable, by-the-slice, and fresh enough to burn the tongue—can still be found at classic joints such as Joe’s Pizza in Greenwich Village, but Totonno’s Pizzeria in Coney Island, opened in 1924, might stake a claim as the New York pizzeria. It’s at least one of the oldest.
Frequently Asked Questions
The best pizza deals in New York City are often bundled meals and discounted vouchers at neighborhood spots rather than at the most famous slice shops. For example, Ignazio’s under the Brooklyn Bridge and Little Honey in Brooklyn both feature discounted pizza-and-drink packages that locals commonly discover through Groupon.
A standard cheese slice in New York City typically runs about $3 to $4.50, with Manhattan slices often at the higher end and outer-borough spots in the Bronx, Queens, and Brooklyn sometimes a bit lower. Upscale or wood‑fired pies and tourist areas can push slice prices higher.
A typical pizza meal for two in New York City usually costs around $40 to $55 before tip if you share a large pie, salad, and soft drinks. Deal-based offers, such as Ignazio’s pizza lunch or dinner for two in Brooklyn, can bring that closer to about $32 to $40 with a voucher.
Yes, New York City diners can often save with fixed-value pizza vouchers and discounted gift cards. Examples include $20, $40, or higher credits at places like Riossi Pizza or Raffaello’s Pizza & Pastas, and reduced-price $50 or $100 gift cards for California Pizza Kitchen, commonly purchased through Groupon.
Several pizza restaurants around New York City offer about 5% cash back when you pay with an enrolled rewards card. Local examples include Palermo Pizza in North Bergen, Corona Pizza in Queens, and Napoli Wood Fired Pizza & Bakery in Cliffside Park, with these rewards typically tracked via Groupon-linked programs.
Most pizza offers in New York City allow both dine-in and takeout, though each voucher spells this out in the fine print. Ignazio’s in Brooklyn, Riossi Pizza in Manhattan, and many Bronx shops like Crosby Pizza Stop clearly list whether their Groupon-based credits apply to carryout, table service, or both.
Many New York City area pizza deals are designed for small groups or families, often covering up to four diners. Gino’s Pizza on the Upper East Side, for instance, offers set menus for as many as four people, and West End Deli on Long Island sells tiered food-and-drink credits up to about $100.
Several well-reviewed pizzerias near New York City offer discounts tied to local deals. Crosby Pizza Stop in the Bronx has a rating around 4.8 with voucher packs, Ignazio’s in Brooklyn holds a perfect recent score with bundled meals, and Little Honey and West End Deli both show strong customer ratings alongside percentage-off offers on Groupon.