Seafood Restaurants in Bay Shore


Select Local Merchants

  • Nicky's Clam Bar
    The premier destination for terrific seafood and tasty pub food, Nicky's Clam Bar in Bay Shore is one of the area's top-rated restaurants. It's a popular spot for guests looking for good quality and an incredible meal. There's not really a recommended attire, so feel free to dress comfortably and though the price can be a bit higher than average, you're going to get what you pay for. It's common knowledge that the background noise can get a little loud here. If you're on the lookout for the perfect spot for family or friends, it's been reviewed as a solid option for large groups and kids. In addition to its convenient take-out offerings, the restaurant even provides catering for events around town. Or, if you just want to pop in for a beverage, the restaurant does have a pretty decent selection at its bar. A reputable favorite for any meal of the day in Town of Islip, anytime's a good time to swing by Nicky's. Visitors to the restaurant have the ability to park nearby on the street. Should you prefer to pedal over there, bicycle parking's also provided.
    Read More
    99 Maple Ave
    Bay Shore, NY US
  • Fat Fish Bar and Bistro
    If you have a hankering for something extra tasty, sample the menu at Bay Shore's Fat Fish Bar and Bistro. The weekends are for going out for amazing combinations. Save the salad for the weekday and come grab a meal at Fat Fish Bar and Bistro. Take a peek at the drink menu here, and make sure to sample something off the list. Little guys and gals will also love dining at Fat Fish Bar and Bistro, which offers a family-friendly environment (and menu). Warm weather brings out Fat Fish Bar and Bistro's highly coveted patio seating. The dress code is strictly casual at Fat Fish Bar and Bistro, so come as you are (and as you are comfortable). Through their catering service, Fat Fish Bar and Bistro can also set out a delicious spread for your next party. null Delicious food doesn't have to be expensive, as shown by the delicious fare coming out of Fat Fish Bar and Bistro's kitchen.
    Read More
    28 Cottage Ave
    Bay Shore, NY US
  • Nicky's On The Bay
    Nicky's in Bay Shore is a well-known restaurant, delivering a familiar atmosphere with delicious seafood. It's a popular restaurant for those that want awesome food. Defined by its outdoor seating, the restaurant is a fantastic option when the New York weather is nice. There's no particular required attire, so feel free to dress comfortably. Also, though the price can be a bit higher than average, the overall experience definitely justifies it. If you just feel like stopping by for a beverage, the restaurant has helpful bar staff (and a good selection behind the bar). A good spot for dinner in Bay Shore, you won't walk away from Nicky's disappointed. Don't worry about trying to find a spot on the street, as visitors to the restaurant do have access to a private parking lot nearby. Would you rather ride there? Bike parking is also offered.
    Read More
    11 South Clinton Avenue
    Bay Shore, NY US
  • Captain Bill's
    Enjoy made-to-order sandwiches on homemade bread at Captain Bill's. When you're ready to pig out, Captain Bill's is ready to serve you the scrumptious food you're craving. The drink list at Captain Bill's has everything you need to complete your meal (and your night out). Captain Bill's is ready to make any occasion a special one with a great space and thoughtful food. Warm weather brings out Captain Bill's' highly coveted patio seating. Enjoy the vibe here with a business casual dress code. Looking for something delicious to serve at your next party? Captain Bill's also offers catering. Score free parking at the lot adjacent to Captain Bill's. Checks are bigger than average at the restaurant, so prepare your wallet. Breakfast, lunch, and dinner are all available at Captain Bill's.
    Read More
    122 Ocean Ave
    Bay Shore, NY US
  • Sea Levels Restaurant
    Fresh fare can be found at Sea Levels Restaurant, where patrons seek to sample every seafood dish on the menu. Score low-fat and gluten-free eats at Sea Levels Restaurant. Enjoy a drink with your dinner — Sea Levels Restaurant has a full bar to serve up a glass of wine, beer, or more. Whether it's just you and a date or you're bringing the whole gang, it's best to call ahead and make a reservation. The dress code at Sea Levels Restaurant is as relaxed as the ambience, so wear whatever suits you. A catering menu is also available if you're looking to dazzle the visitors at your next shindig. Always five minutes behind schedule? Pick up your food to go instead. null Fancy snacks do come at a higher price, but wow are they delicious.
    Read More
    391 N Windsor Ave
    Brightwaters, NY US
  • The Chowder Bar
    Grab a seat and dig in! The Chowder Bar in Bay Shore offers tasty eats everyone will enjoy. The healthy menu items at The Chowder Bar will leave you with a full stomach. The Chowder Bar also operates a bar, so a round of drinks with dinner is not out of the question. Take the kids along too — The Chowder Bar is a great spot for families with food that even little ones will love. Or, take your food to go. That's right! The Chowder Bar will bring their delicious food to your house for any occasion. The Chowder Bar provides a professional and quick valet service. Expect to spend less than $15 per person at The Chowder Bar. The menu at The Chowder Bar includes breakfast, lunch, and dinner — stop by for your favorite meal.
    Read More
    123 Maple Ave
    Bay Shore, NY US

Groupon Guide