Italian Restaurants in Shirley, NY

Italian Food at La Piazzetta Cafe II (Up to 46% Off). Three Options Available.

La Piazzetta Cafe II

East Meadow

Neapolitan and Sicilian-style pizzas with gluten-free crusts, and more than 35 traditional and baked pasta dishes

$35 $19

One or Three Vouchers for Dine-In or Takeout for Two or More at D'Cocco's Restaurant & Pizzeria (Up to 40% Off)

D'Cocco's Restaurant & Pizzeria

Long Beach Road & Mott Street Sands Shopping Center Oceanside

Specialty pizzas with toppings ranging signature pepperoni to bacon, chicken, cheddar, and ranch alongside classics such as chicken parmesan

$30 $18

Italian Cuisine for Dinner at AcQua Restaurant (Up to 42% Off). Four Options Available.

AcQua Restaurant


Waterfront restaurant serves family-style Italian meals such as white-clam linguini, veal marsala, eggplant parmigiana, and lobster ravioli

$60 $35

Wood-Fired Pizza and Iron-Skillet Pasta from Red Tomato Pizza (Up to 54% Off). Six Options Available.

Red Tomato Artisanal Pizza

East Norwich

Wood-fired margherita pizza made with fresh mozarella and extra virgin olive oil; pastas cooked in an iron skillet; sangria and dessert

$93 $45

Pasta, Pizza, and Pasta-Pizza for Two or Four at Cafe Rosa Pizzaria (Up to 48% Off)

Cafe Rosa Pizzaria

Cafe Rosa Pizzaria

Pizzeria creates thin crust and stuffed crust pizzas that include novelty pies such as the baked ziti pizza filled with ricotta and penne

$20 $12

Italian Food and Drinks at Pizza Corner (Up to 48% Off). Two Options Available.

Pizza Corner


Italian restaurant offers a variety of pizzas, calzones, pasta dishes, and more

$20 $12

Italian Food and Drinks for Two or Four at Eatalia Family Style (50% Off)

Eatalia Family Style


Family-style pasta, pizza, and other Italian favorites made with farm-fresh ingredients and served in lively, welcoming atmosphere

$50 $25

$15 for Italian Cuisine and Drinks at Junior's Pizza ($30 Value)

Junior's Pizza

Junior's Pizza

Thin, stuffed, and Sicilian- and grandma-style pizzas, plus veal parmigiana, manicotti, and other Italian classics

$30 $15

$11 for $20 Worth of Casual Italian Cuisine at Sundried Tomato Cafe‎

Sundried Tomato Cafe‎

Sundried Tomato Cafe‎

Italian-inspired dishes range from panini layered with fried chicken to pizza and pasta dishes, such as spinach-and-ricotta ravioli

$20 $11

$15 For $30 Worth Of Casual Italian Dining

Bella Bambina's Pizzeria & Restaurant


$30 $15

Italian Dinner or Lunch for Two or Four at Osteria Da Nino (Up to 44% Off)

Osteria Da Nino

Osteria Da Nino

Handmade pastas and unique proteins enhance rustic Italian dishes such as kale-and-spinach gnocchi, rabbit cacciatore, and seared branzino

$25 $15

$19 for $30 Worth of Italian Cuisine at Umberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Umberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant


Restaurateurs with nearly 50 years in business craft specialty pizzas, salads, and elegant Italian entrees

$30 $19

Italian Dinner for Two or Four at Bravo! Nader (47% Off)

Bravo Nader


Twelve cozy tables are set with appetizers, soups, or salads, entrees such as veal parmesan or house-made gnocchi with pesto, and coffees

$50 $28

"Zagat"-Rated Coal-Fired Brick-Oven Pizza at Grimaldi's Pizzeria (Up to 50% Off). Three Options Available.

Grimaldi's Pizzeria

Garden City

Thin-crust pizzas with handmade mozzarella, fragrant tomato sauce, and fresh toppings baked in coal-fired brick ovens

$20 $12

Italian Food and Drinks at Frank and Maria's (40% Off). Two Options Available.

Frank and Maria's

Bay Shore

The shop’s meats, sausages, and charcuterie often find their way into the onsite Italian eatery’s pasta, entrees, paninis, and sandwiches

$10 $6

Upscale Italian Food and Drinks at Passione (Up to 50% Off). Three Options Available.

Passione Restaurant

Carle Place

Gourmet pizzas, seafood entrees, and classic Italian pastas served in an elegant dining room with golden curtains and sparkling chandeliers

$40 $20

Italian Food for Two or Four or Takeout Family Pizza Dinner at Gino's of Seaford (Up to 42% Off)

Gino's of Seaford


This casual, family-friendly Italian spot serves up pastas, seafood specialties, and Neapolitan– or Sicilian–style pizzas

$30 $18

Italian Cuisine or Pizza and Wings Takeout Packages at Pomodorino Ristorante (Up to 48% Off).

Pomodorino Ristorante

West Hills

Brick-oven pizza with san marzano tomatoes and fresh basil, spaghetti with housemade meatballs, and lasagna with imported parmesan cheese

$30 $16

Italian Dinner for Two or Four with Wine at Vito’s of Port Jeff (Up to 50% Off)

Vito's of Port Jeff

Vito's of Port Jeff

Elvis impersonators and lounge singers entertain diners enjoying Old World Italian favorites and glasses of house wine

$75 $45

Pizza and Pasta for Dine-In or Carry-Out at Gino's of Northport (Up to 42% Off). Four Options Available.

Gino's of Northport

East Northport

Family-owned restaurant serves up Neapolitan and Sicilian style pizza, along with dishes like eggplant rollatini stuffed with ricotta

$25 $15

$15 For $30 Worth Of Fine Dining


Valley Stream

$30 $15

$10 For $20 Worth Of Casual Dining


Garden City South

$20 $10

Upscale Italian Dinner for Two or Four at Cala di Mare Italian Grill and Catering (45% Off)

Cala di Mare Italian Grill and Catering

Rockville Centre

Elegant restaurant and banquet hall serves a menu of Italian classics including stuffed pork chops and seafood risotto

$40 $22

Italian Food for Dine-In, or a Family Meal for Carryout at Plum Tomatoes Pizzeria Restaurant (Up to 47% Off)

Plum Tomatoes Pizzeria Restaurant

Plum Tomatoes Pizzeria Restaurant

Award-winning Italian eatery uses fresh ingredients, from broccoli to artichoke, to create gluten-free pastas, seafood, and pizza

$40 $22

Italian Food at Nick's Tuscan Grill (31% Off). Four Options Available.

Nick's Tuscan Grill


Menu includes lobster ravioli, sautéed lemon chicken, gorgonzola-crusted rib eye, and pizza with housemade meatballs

$30 $21

Pizza and Italian Food at Gino's Pizza of Kings Park (Up to 42% Off). Four Options Available.

Gino's Pizza of Kings Park

Kings Park

Pizza, pasta, salads, soups, and seafood dishes crafted from family recipes at cozy eatery

$25 $15

Italian Food at San Remo Ristorante Italiano (Up to 43% Off). Two Options Available.

San Remo Ristorante Italiano

Sanremo Italian Resturant

Italian eatery offers dishes of homemade pasta made with the freshest ingredients available and an impressive wine list

$30 $17

Contemporary Italian Cuisine at Lunch or Dinner for Two or Four at Cassariano Italian Eatery (Up to 45% Off)

Cassariano Italian Eatery


Contemporary cuisine inspired by Northern Italy includes ravioli with gorgonzola sauce and pears as well as chicken scaloppini with polenta

$60 $35

Italian Food for Dinner or Lunch or a Carry-Out Pizza Meal with Soda from Gino's of Nesconset (Up to 32% Off)

Gino's of Nesconset


Dig in to plates of pasta, eggplant rollatini, and grilled chicken or take your dinner to go with a carry-out pizza meal—soda included

$20 $14

Italian Dinner for Two or Four at Giardinetto Restaurant (Up to 54% Off)

Giardinetto Restaurant


Eatery serves up Old World cuisine with apps like caprese and shrimp cocktail, and entrees like veal chops and lobster ravioli

$96 $49

Select Local Merchants

  • Joe's Pizzeria & Restaurant
    Joe's Pizzeria and Restaurant serves up hot and delicious pizza in a casual dining environment. G-free and low-fat are just a couple of examples, come here for a quick bite that will leave you feeling healthy. Having trouble finding that family-friendly restaurant everyone will love? This pizzeria serves all ages, so little ones are welcome to come along, too. Need a night in? Don't miss out on this pizzeria's delicious food — you can carry it out to eat at home or have them deliver it straight to you. Parking has never been easier at Joe's Pizzeria and Restaurant, a restaurant located near a variety of parking selections. Joe's Pizzeria and Restaurant serves up great pieces of pizza in an even better atmosphere for entertaining you and your gang. For a pizza that is out of the world, call or make a visit to Joe's Pizzeria and Restaurant.
    Read More
    Shirley, NY US
  • Carlo's Pizza
    For that fresh, out-of-the-oven feel, Carlo's Pizza serves mouthwatering pizza with a down-home feel. Complement your meal with a beer or wine from this pizzeria's delightful drink menu. The whole family can enjoy a meal at this pizzeria with its kid-friendly fare. Catering makes it easier to organize any event, and Carlo's Pizza will ensure that it is delicious. With food this good, you'll be running into this pizzeria to pick it up yourself. Both street parking and lot parking are available near Carlo's Pizza. Carlo's Pizza offers parking for all diners, including those who travel by bike. Carlo's Pizza cooks up great, casual pizzas just how you want them: delicious and scrumptious. When you're craving pizza, make your way over to Carlo's Pizza and load up a pizza with all of your favorite toppings.
    Read More
    Shirley, NY US
  • Vincent's Pizza Of Shirley
    Deemed "pizza of the year" every year by Vincents Pizza of Shirley's loyal fans, this deliciously-cheesy pizza will have you reaching for seconds, thirds, and even fourths. For healthy and gluten-free fare, head to Vincents Pizza of Shirley. Catering makes it easier to organize any event, and Vincents Pizza of Shirley will ensure that it is delicious. Grab your meal to go at this pizzeria if you're in a hurry — or better yet, have them bring it to you through their delivery service! Brush up on your parallel parking skills — the pizzeria's Surrey Cir location offers nearby street parking. So come taste the pizza at Vincents Pizza of Shirley for yourself and see what all the ratings buzz is about. Fight for a great pizza pie by placing your order into Vincents Pizza of Shirley today.
    Read More
    Shirley, NY US
  • Tonino's Pizza
    Tonino's Pizza does not just make pizza. They serve decadent slices of heaven that anyone who sinks their teeth into rate high on their list. Low-fat and gluten-free options are featured on the menu. Reserve a table in advance and get seated when you're ready. This pizzeria offers you the ultimate convenience — in-store seating, carryout, or delivery. Can't get enough of Tonino's Pizza's tasty dishes? They also offer a catering service for parties and events. Parking can be a pain in the neck, but it's as available as ever near the pizzeria. Everyone's talking about Tonino's Pizza. Find out why when you treat yourself to a delicious pizza pie. Before ordering just a generic box of pizza, re-think that decision and go with a pie above the rest from Tonino's Pizza.
    Read More
    Shirley, NY US
  • Combo Pizza
    Pop over to Combo Pizza in Shirley for some hop (and highly-acclaimed) 'za, and find out what everyone's been raving about. If gluten is something you try to avoid, check out the G-free menu at Combo Pizza. Low-fat fare is also available for those keeping an eye on their diet. In addition to its great location, Combo Pizza is also located near plenty of parking options. Take a break from buyer's remorse at Combo Pizza, where each and every bite won't cost you much (but will taste like a million bucks). Roni, sausage, and veggie are just a few of the delicious options at Combo Pizza. Taste the shining reviews for yourself when you head to Combo Pizza for a tasty pizza pie. Select your toppings and create a delicious pizza made from scratch by visiting Combo Pizza.
    Read More
    Shirley, NY US
  • Savanora's Pizzeria
    Load up a pizza with all of your favorite toppings at Shirley's Savarona Pizzeria and Restaurant. Throwing a big party? Count on Savarona Pizzeria and Restaurant to provide top-notch catering with the same great dishes you love. Can't stay long? Not a problem with the pizzeria's take-out and delivery options. Patrons are provided with sufficient parking nearby. Next time you're looking to indulge in America's favorite dish, call the team at Savarona Pizzeria and Restaurant to help you out.
    Read More
    Shirley, NY US