Italian Restaurants in Shirley


Sundried Tomato Cafe‎: $22 for $40 Worth of Casual Italian Cuisine at Sundried Tomato Cafe‎

$22 for $40 Worth of Casual Italian Cuisine at Sundried Tomato Cafe‎

Sundried Tomato Cafe‎

Nesconset

Italian-inspired dishes range from panini layered with fried chicken or to pizza or pasta dishes such as spinach-and-ricotta ravioli

$40 $22

View Deal

PortoFino Italian Restaurant: Italian Dining at PortoFino Italian Restaurant for Dine-In or Carry-Out (50% Off). Three Options Available.

Italian Dining at PortoFino Italian Restaurant for Dine-In or Carry-Out (50% Off). Three Options Available.

PortoFino Italian Restaurant

Levittown

Chefs here specialize in dishes that are hard to find outside of Italy, producing meals from authentic recipes and techniques

$40 $20

View Deal

Red Tomato Artisanal Pizza: Wood-Fired Pizza and Iron-Skillet Pasta from Red Tomato Pizza (Up to 54% Off). Six Options Available.

Wood-Fired Pizza and Iron-Skillet Pasta from Red Tomato Pizza (Up to 54% Off). Six Options Available.

Red Tomato Artisanal Pizza

East Norwich

Wood-fired margherita pizza made with fresh mozarella and extra virgin olive oil; pastas cooked in an iron skillet; sangria and dessert

$54 $25

View Deal

Bravo Nader: Italian Dinner for Two or Four at Bravo! Nader (47% Off)

Italian Dinner for Two or Four at Bravo! Nader (47% Off)

Bravo Nader

Huntington

Twelve cozy tables are set with appetizers, soups, or salads, entrees such as veal parmesan or house-made gnocchi with pesto, and coffees

$50 $28

View Deal

Pomodorino Ristorante: Italian Cuisine or Pizza and Wings Takeout Packages at Pomodorino Ristorante (Up to 48% Off).

Italian Cuisine or Pizza and Wings Takeout Packages at Pomodorino Ristorante (Up to 48% Off).

Pomodorino Ristorante

West Hills

Brick-oven pizza with san marzano tomatoes and fresh basil, spaghetti with housemade meatballs, and lasagna with imported parmesan cheese

$30 $16

View Deal

Pastaria Pronto: Italian Food at Pastaria Pronto(Up to 40% Off). Three Options Available.

Italian Food at Pastaria Pronto(Up to 40% Off). Three Options Available.

Pastaria Pronto

Miller Place

Menu includes fried calamari, pear and goat cheese salads, buffalo chicken pizza, spaghetti carbonara, veal parmesan, and lobster ravioli

$20 $12

View Deal

Grimaldi's Pizzeria: "Zagat"-Rated Coal-Fired Brick-Oven Pizza at Grimaldi's Pizzeria (Up to 50% Off). Three Options Available.

"Zagat"-Rated Coal-Fired Brick-Oven Pizza at Grimaldi's Pizzeria (Up to 50% Off). Three Options Available.

Grimaldi's Pizzeria

Garden City

Thin-crust pizzas with handmade mozzarella, fragrant tomato sauce, and fresh toppings baked in coal-fired brick ovens

$20 $12

View Deal

Umberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant: $15 for $30 Worth of Italian Cuisine at Umberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant

$15 for $30 Worth of Italian Cuisine at Umberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Umberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Plainview

Restaurateurs with nearly 50 years in business craft specialty pizzas, salads, and elegant Italian entrees

$30 $15

View Deal

Fargiano's Pizza and Pasta: Italian Food at Fargiano's Pizza and Pasta (Up to 50% Off). Two Options Available.

Italian Food at Fargiano's Pizza and Pasta (Up to 50% Off). Two Options Available.

Fargiano's Pizza and Pasta

East Islip

Chefs prepare over-the-top Italian entrees and specialty pizzas such as buffalo chicken and eggplant marinara, plus his trademark pastries

$40 $22

View Deal

Nick's Tuscan Grill: Italian Food at Nick's Tuscan Grill (50% Off). Two Options Available.

Italian Food at Nick's Tuscan Grill (50% Off). Two Options Available.

Nick's Tuscan Grill

Mineola

Menu includes lobster ravioli, sautéed lemon chicken, gorgonzola-crusted rib eye, and pizza with housemade meatballs

$60 $30

View Deal

Sole: Italian Dinner for Two or Four at Solé (Up to 42% Off)

Italian Dinner for Two or Four at Solé (Up to 42% Off)

Sole

Oceanside

Chef Bobby Carmosino crafts Italian-inspired cuisine from fresh ingredients and some family recipes.

$60 $35

View Deal

Giardinetto Restaurant: Italian Dinner for Two or Four at Giardinetto Restaurant (Up to 54% Off)

Italian Dinner for Two or Four at Giardinetto Restaurant (Up to 54% Off)

Giardinetto Restaurant

Inwood

Eatery serves up Old World cuisine with apps like caprese and shrimp cocktail, and entrees like veal chops and lobster ravioli

$96 $49

View Deal

Mac's Steakhouse: Steakhouse Dinner Fare or Prix Fixe Lunch for Two at Mac's Steakhouse (Up to 50% Off)

Steakhouse Dinner Fare or Prix Fixe Lunch for Two at Mac's Steakhouse (Up to 50% Off)

Mac's Steakhouse

Huntington

Two-story steakhouse with antique decor serves up grass-fed steaks aged for 28 days, roasted seabass, veal chops, and other high-end fare

$65 $39

View Deal

Tropix: Lunch or Dinner at Tropix (Up to 46% Off)

Lunch or Dinner at Tropix (Up to 46% Off)

Tropix

Freeport

This beach-themed bar and dance club features a menu of burgers, lobster slides, and other seafood specialties, plus refreshing cocktails

$25 $15

View Deal

Yummy Gyro: Mediterranean Food at Yummy Gyro (Up to 43% Off). Three Options Available.

Mediterranean Food at Yummy Gyro (Up to 43% Off). Three Options Available.

Yummy Gyro

Port Washington

Menu includes marinated pork souvlaki, chicken gyros, salmon wraps, falafels, greek salads, and lamb bacon gorgonzola cheeseburgers

$35 $20

View Deal

Upstairs at the Woodlands: Steakhouse Dinner with Wine for Two or Four at Upstairs at the Woodlands (Up to 49% Off)

Steakhouse Dinner with Wine for Two or Four at Upstairs at the Woodlands (Up to 49% Off)

Upstairs at the Woodlands

Woodbury

Aged steaks and expertly grilled seafood at a mansion overlooking the Oyster Bay Golf Course

$126 $65

View Deal

Brasserie Persil: Prix Fixe French Classics Dinner with Wine for Two or Four at Brasserie Persil (48% Off)

Prix Fixe French Classics Dinner with Wine for Two or Four at Brasserie Persil (48% Off)

Brasserie Persil

Oceanside

Traditional French dishes such as duck à l’orange, mussels, and sole meunière at a restaurant rated “Very Good” in the New York Times

$124.80 $65

View Deal

Jackson Road House: Seafood at Jackson Road House (50% Off). Two Options Available.

Seafood at Jackson Road House (50% Off). Two Options Available.

Jackson Road House

Seaford

Restaurant’s menu is filled with seafood, such as tempura-fried shrimp, blackened catfish, and whole baked clams, along with pub specials

$30 $15

View Deal

Frank's Steaks: Surf & Turf Dinner for Two at Zagat-Rated Frank's Steaks (Up to 44% Off). Two Options Available.

Surf & Turf Dinner for Two at Zagat-Rated Frank's Steaks (Up to 44% Off). Two Options Available.

Frank's Steaks

Rockville Centre

Zagat-rated restaurant for more than 22 years dishes out a dinner consisting of 22-ounce T-bone steak and 1.5-pound whole Maine lobster

$134.80 $75

View Deal

Rudi's Bar and Grill: Sports Bar Meal for Two or Four with Appetizers, Entrees, and Beer at Rudi's Bar and Grill (Up to 74% Off)

Sports Bar Meal for Two or Four with Appetizers, Entrees, and Beer at Rudi's Bar and Grill (Up to 74% Off)

Rudi's Bar and Grill

North Patchogue

Import drafts and premium pints wash down barbecue wings, beer-battered shrimp, and pulled-pork sandwiches

$54 $15

View Deal

Bistro 72: Contemporary American Food, Valid Sunday–Thursday or Any Day at Bistro 72 (Up to 50% Off)

Contemporary American Food, Valid Sunday–Thursday or Any Day at Bistro 72 (Up to 50% Off)

Bistro 72

Hotel Indigo East End

Chef James Junk drapes locally procured meats and organic veggies with exotic spices

$50 $25

View Deal

The Curry Club: Indian Dinner for Two or Four or $35 for $65 Worth of Indian Food at The Curry Club

Indian Dinner for Two or Four or $35 for $65 Worth of Indian Food at The Curry Club

The Curry Club

Setauket-East Setauket

Low-fat yogurt coats dark-meat chicken kebabs, and tandoori oven bakes spicy warmth into salmon tikka masala at Zagat-rated eatery

$86.93 $45

View Deal

The Curry Club: $35 for $70 Worth of Indian Dinner for Two or More People at The Curry Club

$35 for $70 Worth of Indian Dinner for Two or More People at The Curry Club

The Curry Club

Setauket-East Setauket

Low-fat yogurt coats dark-meat chicken kebabs, and tandoori oven bakes spicy warmth into salmon tikka masala at Zagat-rated eatery

$70 $35

View Deal

Hana Japanese Restaurant: $15.99 for $30 Worth of Sushi and Japanese Cuisine at Hana Japanese Restaurant

$15.99 for $30 Worth of Sushi and Japanese Cuisine at Hana Japanese Restaurant

Hana Japanese Restaurant

Port Jefferson

Maki rolls, teriyaki, and other traditional dishes served in the glow of lantern-like hanging lamps

$30 $15.99

View Deal

Billie's 1890 Saloon: Pub Food at Billie's 1890 Saloon (50% Off). Two Options Available.

Pub Food at Billie's 1890 Saloon (50% Off). Two Options Available.

Billie's 1890 Saloon

Port Jefferson

Diners enjoy pub food favorites such as burgers, jalapeño poppers, and mesquite chicken rolls, washed down with frosty beers and cocktails

$30 $15

View Deal

Michael Anthony's Food Bar: $20 for $40 Worth of New American Dinner Cuisine at Michael Anthony's Food Bar

$20 for $40 Worth of New American Dinner Cuisine at Michael Anthony's Food Bar

Michael Anthony's Food Bar

Wading River

Seasoned chef whips up inventive small plates, pastas, and seasonal specialties such as short ribs with licorice barbecue sauce

$40 $20

View Deal

Rio Douro Bistro: Portuguese Dinner Cuisine for Two or Four or More at Rio Douro Bistro (40% Off)

Portuguese Dinner Cuisine for Two or Four or More at Rio Douro Bistro (40% Off)

Rio Douro Bistro

Farmingville

Authentic Portuguese cuisine complemented by a range of Italian dishes

$50 $30

View Deal

Road Trip American Ale House: Unlimited Sunday Brunch for Two or Four at Road Trip American Ale House (Up to 37% Off)

Unlimited Sunday Brunch for Two or Four at Road Trip American Ale House (Up to 37% Off)

Road Trip American Ale House

Terryville

Enjoy unlimited trips to the brunch buffet, filled with breakfast favorites

$79.96 $50

View Deal

Road Trip American Ale House: Gourmet Burger Meal for Two or Four with Take-Home Growlers at Road Trip American Ale House (Up to 51% Off)

Gourmet Burger Meal for Two or Four with Take-Home Growlers at Road Trip American Ale House (Up to 51% Off)

Road Trip American Ale House

Terryville

Freshly ground gourmet burger tucks itself inside a kaiser roll and is pairs with choice toppings and fries; 52 draft beers available

$49.98 $25

View Deal

Bistro 25: French American Dinner for Two or Four or Lunch or Brunch at Bistro 25 (Up to 42% Off)

French American Dinner for Two or Four or Lunch or Brunch at Bistro 25 (Up to 42% Off)

Bistro 25

Sayville

Monkfish medallions, French-cut chicken breast, and steaks anchor a menu of French American cuisine that pairs with a flat-priced wine menu

$60 $35

View Deal

HR Singletons: $35 for $55 Worth of Steaks, Burgers, Seafood, and More at HR Singletons

$35 for $55 Worth of Steaks, Burgers, Seafood, and More at HR Singletons

HR Singletons

Bethpage

A wide variety of classic American fare such as prime rib, filet mignon, angus burgers, pasta, and seafood

$55 $35

View Deal

Blue Duck Bakery Cafe: $14 for Three Vouchers Each Good for $8 Worth of Food and Drink at Blue Duck Bakery Cafe ($24 Value)

$14 for Three Vouchers Each Good for $8 Worth of Food and Drink at Blue Duck Bakery Cafe ($24 Value)

Blue Duck Bakery Cafe

Riverhead

Chow down on pastries, cakes, and artisanal breads worked into hearty sandwiches

$8 $4.66

View Deal

Masala Wok: $30 for $60 Worth of Indo-Chinese Cuisine at Masala Wok

$30 for $60 Worth of Indo-Chinese Cuisine at Masala Wok

Masala Wok

Hicksville

Pan-fried chili chicken, panang curry, golden-fried battered vegetables in manchurian sauce, and other Indo-Chinese specialties

$60 $30

View Deal

Komo Sushi: $18 for $30 or $35 for $60 Worth of Sushi and Asian Cuisine for Dinner at Komo (Up to 42% Off)

$18 for $30 or $35 for $60 Worth of Sushi and Asian Cuisine for Dinner at Komo (Up to 42% Off)

Komo Sushi

Bellmore

Sushi filled with fresh tuna, crab, and fried shrimp, or pan-Asian entrees such as pad Thai, Mongolian beef, and pineapple fried rice

$30 $19

View Deal

Thom Thom Steak and Seafood: Up to 43% Off for Two or Four or More at Thom Thom Steak and Seafood. Four Options Available.

Up to 43% Off for Two or Four or More at Thom Thom Steak and Seafood. Four Options Available.

Thom Thom Steak and Seafood

Wantagh

Dishes such as crispy bang bang shrimp, crazy tuna rolls, house-marinated skirt steak, and miso-glazed chilean sea bass

$30 $17

View Deal

Mizu Japanese Sushi & Hibachi: Sushi or Hibachi Cuisine at Mizu Japanese Sushi & Hibachi (Up to 50% Off)

Sushi or Hibachi Cuisine at Mizu Japanese Sushi & Hibachi (Up to 50% Off)

Mizu Japanese Sushi & Hibachi

Plainedge

Enjoy innovative sushi, like the Lovey-Dovey or Paradise rolls; skilled Hibachi chefs serve up flavorful dishes

$30 $15

View Deal

Johnny's Burgers: Burgers at Johnny's Burgers (Up to 40% Off)

Burgers at Johnny's Burgers (Up to 40% Off)

Johnny's Burgers

Centereach

Burgers, wings, and other simple American food favorites served in a fifties-themed diner

$20 $12

View Deal

Vinoco Wine Bar & Tapas Restaurant: $17 for $30 Worth of Tapas and a House Tapas Plate at Vinoco Wine Bar & Tapas Restaurant ($38 Value)

$17 for $30 Worth of Tapas and a House Tapas Plate at Vinoco Wine Bar & Tapas Restaurant ($38 Value)

Vinoco Wine Bar & Tapas Restaurant

Mineola

Flatbreads, paella, skewers, salads, and sushi-style rolls balance a wine list with nearly 50 international varietals

$38 $17

View Deal

Fado: Portuguese Food for Two or Four During Dinner or Lunch at Fado (Up to 50% Off)

Portuguese Food for Two or Four During Dinner or Lunch at Fado (Up to 50% Off)

Fado

Huntington

Local favorite, praised by the New York Times, serving authentic Portuguese cuisine and American favorites in cozy, comfortable atmosphere

$30 $15

View Deal

Raxx Pool Room, Bar & Grill: Two Hours of Pool for Two or Four with Pub Food and Drinks at Raxx Pool Room, Sports Bar & Grill (Up to 60% Off)

Two Hours of Pool for Two or Four with Pub Food and Drinks at Raxx Pool Room, Sports Bar & Grill (Up to 60% Off)

Raxx Pool Room, Bar & Grill

Garden City South

Players take aim on pristine pool tables and nosh on burgers and wraps between turns

$53 $23

View Deal

Villaggio Ristorante: Tapas and Sangria Tasting Experience for Two, Four, or Six at Villaggio Ristorante (55% Off)

Tapas and Sangria Tasting Experience for Two, Four, or Six at Villaggio Ristorante (55% Off)

Villaggio Ristorante

Long Beach

Baked clams, meatballs, stuffed mushrooms, and other small plates paired with sangria flights at a family-run restaurant

$63.80 $29

View Deal

Taste of Africa: $15 for $30 Worth of Lunch or Dinner at Taste of Africa

$15 for $30 Worth of Lunch or Dinner at Taste of Africa

Taste of Africa

Deer Park

Chef Isaac's West African menu includes goat soup, yams with spinach, and vegan/vegetarian options—plus American fare like cheeseburgers

$30 $15

View Deal

Meridian Kitchen: Italian-Asian Fusion Cuisine for Dinner at Meridian Kitchen (50% Off)

Italian-Asian Fusion Cuisine for Dinner at Meridian Kitchen (50% Off)

Meridian Kitchen

Locust Valley

Complex Asian-and-Italian cuisine includes sushi-bar plates, seared steak, pasta, and brick-oven pizza

$50 $25

View Deal

The Arden Kitchen & Bar: Upscale Pub Food for Two or Four at The Arden Kitchen & Bar (Up to 51% Off)

Upscale Pub Food for Two or Four at The Arden Kitchen & Bar (Up to 51% Off)

The Arden Kitchen & Bar

Port Jefferson

Duck tacos, parmesan truffle fries, and shareable small plates join loaded flat breads and inventive entrees at this rustic chic modern pub

$86 $45

View Deal

Wild Ginger - Rockville Centre: $30 Towards an Asian Meal for Two or More, Valid Weekdays or Any Day, at Wild Ginger (Up to 43% Off)

$30 Towards an Asian Meal for Two or More, Valid Weekdays or Any Day, at Wild Ginger (Up to 43% Off)

Wild Ginger - Rockville Centre

Rockville Centre

Chefs craft Asian fusion dishes such as spring rolls, spicy basil fried rice, pad thai, hibachi chicken, and hand-made sushi

$30 $17

View Deal

Sazon Dominicano: Caribbean and Latin American Cuisine at Sazon Dominicano (Up to 50% Off). Two Options Available.

Caribbean and Latin American Cuisine at Sazon Dominicano (Up to 50% Off). Two Options Available.

Sazon Dominicano

Freeport

Chefs serve family-style Caribbean and Latin American staples, from Cuban-style sandwiches to paella, within a sleekly designed dining room

$30 $15

View Deal

Croxley's Ale House: Burgers and Tap Craft Beer for Two or Four with Appetizers at Croxley's Ale House (Up to 52% Off)

Burgers and Tap Craft Beer for Two or Four with Appetizers at Croxley's Ale House (Up to 52% Off)

Croxley's Ale House

Croxley Ale House

On-tap craft beer from both Long Island and abroad pairs with signature half-pound, char-grilled burgers

$55.85 $27

View Deal

Plates South Asian Tapas: South Asian Tapas for Two or More People at Plates (44% Off)

South Asian Tapas for Two or More People at Plates (44% Off)

Plates South Asian Tapas

Huntington

Order several dishes and pass them around, getting a taste of everything from masala spices to lambchops and naan

$45 $25

View Deal

Healy's Inn: Lunch or Dinner for Two or Four or More or Carryout at Healy's Inn (Up to 50% Off)

Lunch or Dinner for Two or Four or More or Carryout at Healy's Inn (Up to 50% Off)

Healy's Inn

Greenlawn

Pub favorites such as Angus burgers, BLTs, and fish and chips match with cold brews and other drinks

$25 $15

View Deal

Select Local Merchants

  • Joe's Pizzeria and Restaurant
    Joe's in Shirley is one of the more inexpensive pizza places in the area, offering an intriguing menu that won't leave you broke. Come by for the good quality and stay for friendly service. You'll be a regular at Joe's before you know it. No specific attire is required, so feel free to dress casually and comfortably. Also, though the prices are considered to be lower than average, you aren't going to sacrifice any quality. In fact, you should be able to enjoy a good meal for $11 or $12, and can probably get in and out for $8 if you try. There really is something for everyone, with gluten-free options, as well as low-fat and vegetarian items on the robust menu. Plus, if you're on the lookout for the perfect spot for family or friends, it's been reviewed as a solid option for large groups and kids. If you don't feel like eating in, you can always grab your food to go, or just place an order for delivery. All things considered, Joe's definitely shouldn't leave you disappointed, no matter how you slice it.
    Read More
    433 William Floyd Pkwy
    Shirley, NY US
  • Carlo's Pizza
    Gather up the whole crew and head to Carlo's Pizza for a night of pizza and fun. Low-fat food isn't on the menu, so diners come to Carlo's Pizza to enjoy their every bite. Drinks all around! Pair your dinner with a beverage from Carlo's Pizza's full bar. The whole family can enjoy a meal at Carlo's Pizza with its kid-friendly fare. On warmer days, take advantage of Carlo's Pizza's outdoor seating. For those in a hurry, the pizzeria lets you take your grub to go. Hosting a swanky shindig? Call up Carlo's Pizza for their catering services. If preferred, guests can leave their vehicles in a nearby lot, though space is available on the street as well. Save your pennies for a rainy day — with prices generally under $15, you'll have plenty left over even after dining at Carlo's Pizza.
    Read More
    451 Glen Dr
    Shirley, NY US
  • Savarona Pizzeria and Restaurant
    One of the better-priced pizza places in Shirley, visitors of Savarona won't have to smash their piggy banks for a satisfying meal and pleasant experience. Whether you are stopping in for the great quality, friendly service, or both, you will never leave this restaurant unsatisfied. There's not really a recommended attire, so feel free to dress comfortably. Also, though the prices are considered to be lower than average, you aren't going to sacrifice any quality. In fact, you should be able to enjoy a good meal for $11 or $12, and can probably get in and out for $8 if you try. It offers convenient local delivery, and can even cater events in the area. When you add everything up, Savarona stands out, no matter how you slice it.
    Read More
    999 Montauk Hwy
    Shirley, NY US
  • Combo Pizza
    If you are in search of a good meal that won't leave you broke, then look no further than Combo Pizza. Whether you are visiting for the excellent quality, lightning-fast service, or both, you'll always leave this restaurant happy. Though the overall price can be a bit on the low side, you won't be sacrificing any quality. If you don't feel like eating in, you can always grab your food to go, or just place an order for delivery. A good option in Shirley, Combo definitely won't leave you disappointed, no matter how you slice it.
    Read More
    60 Northern Boulevard
    Shirley, NY US
  • Vincents Pizza of Shirley
    Enjoy a freshly tossed pizza loaded with toppings at Vincents Pizza of Shirley in Shirley. It's easy to keep your diet in check at Vincents Pizza of Shirley, a local restaurant with both low-fat and healthy fare. That's right! Vincents Pizza of Shirley will bring their delicious food to your house for any occasion. Street parking is readily available near Vincents Pizza of Shirley's Surrey Cir location. The grub at Vincents Pizza of Shirley is also a downright bargain — most people can chow down for less than $15.
    Read More
    44 Surrey Cir
    Shirley, NY US
  • Casa Gia
    Casa Gia in Shirley is a popular Italian restaurant that features an intriguing menu. Whether you are stopping in for the good quality, lightning-fast service, or both, you will never leave this restaurant unsatisfied. There really is something for everyone, with gluten-free options, as well as low-fat and vegetarian items on the robust menu. A good spot in Shirley, Casa Gia is definitely a good call.
    Read More
    800 Montauk Highway
    Shirley, NY US

Groupon Guide

Grouber