Seafood Restaurants in Hampton Bays

Select Local Merchants

With its starched white linen tablecloths and exposed wooden ceiling beams, The Coast Grill’s dining room echoes the sails and ship hulls dotting the harbor just outside. The Coast Grill pays further tribute to its waterfront locale with Chef Brian Cheewing’s menu of seafood and local produce, which has earned praise from Dan’s Hamptons and Newsday. Chef Cheewing adorns succulent cuts of seafood and free-range meats with Italian-inspired flourishes such as Tuscan kale, basil-infused olive oil, and polenta. Dining companions can devour dishes tableside or at the sunlit bar where porthole windows furnish views of passing sailboats and hopelessly lost Spanish frigates.

1109 Noyack Rd
Southampton,
NY
US

The towering windows that line the walls of Senix Creek Inn provide breathtaking views of the Senix Marina waterfront—but the scenery isn't the main attraction. The casual restaurant's seafood-centric menu blends global culinary influences: staples such as clam chowder, stuffed fish, and lump crab cakes are served alongside more exotic dishes such as kung-pao-style calamari. Marinated steaks and hearty pastas round out the offerings. To complete the restaurant's seaside aesthetic, the dining room features soft lighting, rustic bare-wood floors, and exposed rafters.

50 Senix Ave
Center Moriches,
NY
US

Located next to the bobbing boats of a marina, Kingston's Clam Bar serves up fresh air alongside its fresh seafood. Red umbrellas shade a row of tables outside along the dock, and French doors admit sea breezes into the dining room. There, servers crisscross the red brick floor with morsels on casual, plastic plates, such as a lobster roll stuffed with lemon-mayo dressing and tender chilled meat.

130 Atlantic Ave
West Sayville,
NY
US

Elm City Seafood & Grill Restaurant is known for fried seafood with a light, crisp coating. Diners can dig into platters of fried bone-in whiting, seasoned shrimp, and other seaside favorites, or take them in boxes to go. The eatery’s cooks also prepare lobster rolls, charbroiled burgers, and hot dogs.

157 Hamilton St
New Haven,
CT
US

The Lazy Lobster charms taste buds with a menu that showcases freshly prepared dishes made from New England seafood. Indulge claw cravings with a Maine lobster (market price) weighing up to 2 pounds or a Lazy Lobster roll constructed on generously buttered bread ($15.95). Wash your palate in a sea of flavor with a bucket of shrimp ($14.95) or a plate of ocean-fresh clams and mussels plunged, like disoriented scuba divers, into white-wine-garlic sauce ($10.95). New England clam chowder or lobster bisque ($5.95/pint, $10.95/quart) provide spoons with a steaming pool to dip into, and baby-back ribs ($12/half, $23/full) arrive at tables slow-cooked after being seasoned in dry rub for 48 hours, or until the meat says “uncle.”

6 Broadway
Milford,
CT
US

Dino's Seafood's culinary experts have been culling sub-aquatic ingredients to build a menu of tasty seafood for 43 years. The jumbo-shrimp cocktail harmonizes with the maryland crab cakes ($6.95 each), and the rhode island and new england clam chowders play a baseline of hearty flavors ($3.25/cup; $3.80/bowl). A briny band of fried seafood dinners unites with french fries and coleslaw ($9.50–$19.95), and a cadre of baked and broiled fish dishes swagger from diner to diner, presenting a choice of two sides ($13.95–$19.00). Chefs construct the surf ‘n’ turf out of an 8-ounce steak, a surfboard covered in artificial grass, and a choice of fried scallops, shrimp, or clams ($16.95). While sailors dine on the fruit of the sea, landlubbers nosh on an assortment of sandwiches, burgers, and hot dogs ($2.05–$12.20). Guests can park walking apparatuses in one of Dino's booths or chairs, which, like boxing matches held at Bed, Bath & Beyond, are cushioned.

540 Washington Ave
North Haven,
CT
US