Try It: Brandy Old Fashioned
You may be familiar with the old fashioned cocktail, typically made with either bourbon or rye, plus sugar, bitters, and an orange-slice-and-cherry garnish. But in Milwaukee, brandy is the spirit of choice in the popular cocktail. Why?
Thank (or blame?) the 1893 World’s Fair, which was held in Milwaukee and featured a new brandy from California-based distiller Korbel. Wisconsin fairgoers loved the Korbel, so much so that Wisconsin bars rushed to stock up on the stuff. The old fashioned cocktails popular in big cities like New York were just starting to gain popularity in the Midwest and bartenders weren’t beholden to a specific recipe (the first official recipe for an old fashioned wasn’t printed until 1895), so they took liberties and swapped out the traditional whiskey for brandy, thus creating what would eventually become the unofficial official cocktail of Milwaukee.
Learn more about the cocktail here.
Pro-Tip: Order it “sweet,” which lets the bartender know to add a splash of lemon-lime soda.
Considering brandy’s relative unpopularity among younger drinkers these days, you’re unlikely to find brandy old fashioneds at the city’s modern craft cocktail bars. But, if you look, you can still find plenty of Milwaukee restaurants proudly serving the drink to die-hard fans. Hint: look for it in the supper clubs and the dive bars.