Bars in Sayville


Select Local Merchants

For a no-frills watering hole, Blackbirds' Grille is a great spot to kick back. Both low-fat and gluten-free menu items are offered at Blackbirds' Grille. Televisions are strewn throughout the bar, so fans can stay up to date on the latest sports happenings. Bring the whole clan to Blackbirds' Grille — kids and parents will love the menu and ambience here. Blackbirds' Grille's outdoor seating is available during the warmer months. Gather up your friends, coworkers or family members and head to Blackbirds' Grille for a group meal. It tends to get especially busy on weeknights, so be sure to call ahead and make a reservation. Folks tend to dress down at Blackbirds' Grille, so keep comfort in mind when heading to the bar. For the tastes of Blackbirds' Grille from the comfort of your next party, the bar also offers catering services. If you're in a hurry, place an order for pickup instead. The lot adjacent to Blackbirds' Grille provides free parking for diners. Cyclists will also appreciate the plentiful space to lock up their bikes outside the bar. You can fill up on Blackbirds' Grille's delicious fare without spending an arm and a leg — in fact, typical meals there run under $15. Stop by for three square meals a day — Blackbirds' Grille serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner.
553 Old Montauk Hwy
Sayville,
NY
US
Dressing up the traditional sandwich, The Portly Villager is a go-to lunch spot. The Portly Villager does not prepare their menu with low-fat items, though, so those following a strict diet may have better luck elsewhere. Catch the sports highlights on one of the TVs at The Portly Villager. Tots and tykes will be right at home at The Portly Villager with its kid-approved food and ambience. At The Portly Villager, the prime seating is on the patio. Come check out what all the buzz is about. At The Portly Villager, your large or small group can be seated quickly and comfortably. null If preferred, visitors can leave their vehicles in a nearby lot, though space is available on the street as well. Store your bike at one of the many racks outside of The Portly Villager. Your tab at The Portly Villager will usually run to about $30 per guest.
261 W Main St
Sayville,
NY
US
For bar nibbles and pub food par excellence, Flatbush Pub is a top pick. Flatbush Pub worries about making delicious food, not counting calories. Flatbush Pub is a good restaurant to dine with a small or large group. It doesn't get much more laid-back than Flatbush Pub, so dress for comfort when you come. If you need to feed a big crowd, Flatbush Pub also offers catering services for parties and get-togethers. Drivers can park in the neighboring lot. Chow down at Flatbush Pub without blowing your budget — meals here usually cost less than $15. Credit cards won't be handy at Flatbush Pub, it's cash only.
3 Lakeland Ave
Sayville,
NY
US
For bar nibbles and pub food par excellence, Garage Bar and Grill is a top pick. Dieters beware — Garage Bar and Grill does not offer low-fat cuisine. The dress code is strictly casual at Garage Bar and Grill, so come as you are (and as you are comfortable). Garage Bar and Grill prides itself in its delicious catering. Avoid parallel parking and slide into a spot free of charge — the restaurant offers free parking next door. The average check at Garage Bar and Grill will stay below $30 per person, so it's a relatively affordable option.
667 Montauk Hwy
Bayport,
NY
US
O’Reilly’s flame-wielders dish up an eclectic menu of traditional Irish-pub fare amid fetching period décor and games fit for the whole family. Imbue taste buds with the savory flavors of a twice-baked shrimp potato ($7.48) before unbridling a gallant fleet of forks upon a legion of irish-sausage links straddled with mashed potatoes and sautéed onions ($14.98). Or invoke the Earl of Sandwich without donning a fluffernutter-encrusted crown by perusing O’Reilly’s selection of handheld eats, which includes the succulent short-rib grilled-cheese sandwich slathered in horseradish sauce ($10.48) and the Bookmaker—a robust layering of filet mignon, sautéed onions, and mushrooms ($13.48). Homemade by O’Reilly’s crack chefs, the strawberry-rhubarb cobbler robes itself with regal dollops of whipped and sweetened Jameson butter ($4.98).
927 Montauk Highway
Oakdale,
NY
US